STI]DIAISLAIIIKA Il'|DONESlAl'| JouRNAL FoR rsLAMrc sTUDrEs
Volume 3, Number 2, 1996
CNNruCIruC THE IMAGE OF ISLAM AND MUSLIM WONTO:
INDONESIAN EXERCISES
TarmiziTaher
Goo nruo SprnrtuRt Brtrucs tN CtREBoN-JRvRrursr Bntrr SYstrrrl: A R+ucrnrur CorurrRrBUTroN AcRrnsr rlr SvrucnETtc ARGUMENT A. G. Muhaimin
THr TnncrDY oF CttuRnruE: THr RrsrsrANcE oF HRrr Hnsnru To rHE CotollRl- Powrn Chusnul Hajati
THE KH/TTAHoF 1e26 ReexRvrtueo:
Vlrws oF
THE NU II.I Posr.CIpnSUNG CONGRESS
Ali Munhanif lssN 0215-0492
tru
1919
STUDIA ISI,AilIIKA lndonesian Journal for ldamic Studies
Volume 3, Number 2, 1996 EDITORIAT BOARD:
Harun Nasution Mastubu M. Quraisb Sbibab
A AzizDablan M. SatriaEffendi
Ntuilab Lubh M.YunanYusuf Komaraddin Hidayat M. Din Syamsuddin
Muslim Nasution Wabib Mu'tbi EDITOR.IN.CHIEF:
Azlumardi Azra EDITON: Saiful Mujani
Hmdro Prasetyo Joban H. Meuleman
Didin Slafruddin
NiMunbanif ASSISTANTS TO THE EDITOR:
Arief Subban Heni Nuroni
ENGUSH I.ANGUAGE ADMSOR: Juditb M. Dmt ARABIC LANGUAGE ADVISOR: Fuad M. Facbruddin
COVER DESIGNER: S.
Prinka
STUDIA ISLAMIKA 0SSN 0211-0492) is a journal published quafterly by the /rrstitut Agama
Isl^m
Ne6en (IAIN, The State Institute for Islamic Studies) Syarif Hidayatullah,Jakuta. (STT DEPPEN No. I2giSVDIUEN/PPG/STTA976) and sponsored by the Department of Religious Affairs of the Republic of Indonesia. It specializes in Indonesian Islamic studies, and is intended to communicate original researches and current issues on the subiect. This iournal warmly welcomes conffibutions from scholars of related disciplines.
All anicles published do nor necessarily represent the views of the journal, or other institutions to which it is affiliated. Ihey are solely the views of the authors
Awis Karni
Al-Tasawwuf fi IndrinisiyA; DirAsah li Nuskhah Kitib M ath li b a l- S liktn T a' lif Ytsuf al-M akAsiri A.
Abstrace Mubammad Yir.suf al.MakkAfi (1627.1599) is one of tbe tbree prorninmt Maslirn tbinkers ubo arose in seuentemth century Nusantara (ndoncsia) The othq two dre Nuruddin ar-Raniri (Nrtr aLDtn al-Rinlrt) (d. 1558) and Abdunauf as-singhili (Abd al-Ra'rtf al.Sinhilt) (1615-1693) from the Suhanate of Aceh. As with the otbers, Ytr.suf alhfiahisAr| who was bom in the kingdom of Goua, Mahassar, hnoun today as tJjung Pandang South Suhuesi, dnoted bis life to kkm. He was preoccupinduitb tbe study of aario w s ubj ects rekting tokalim (the o lo gt), txawwuf (s ufism) and. shari' ah (shmic hw.,) and wrote no feuer than 23 books in Arabic. MatAlib al-SAlikin (Ihe Requat of the Travelbrs) (MS) is one ofYfi.suf alMdk Art\ interestingworhs. The subject that he deals with rnost in tbis book istasawwuf.by emphasis on theinseparabiliry ofrawhid(the Unity of God), ma' rif.ah (gnosis) and' ibidah (ritual). He mainained that if someonc missed one of tbese inseparable aspects be uouldfall as apolytheist. To conztince his readns of the notion of tbe onmess of tbe three, he madt an analogt about the inseparability of f'ruitfrom leaztes and trees. In his opinion, it is irnpossible to imagine
afruit aithout
rablefram
trees
and
its tees and leaves.
lcaztes as the
soulfrom
In tbis aralog,fruh
is as insepa-
tbe body.
Tawhid is tbe main sufiect of bL preoccupation in tbe MS. Yilsuf aldnf.nes tawhid ds a stdternent and an act of ffirrration that God is One. He states that thqe is no existmce either in this uorld nor in the uorl"d after qcept the Onc existence. It seerns thatYilsuf al-MakisAi\ aiew o/tawhid reflects the position of nrost Muslirn rnjstic in the suf. tradition, i.e., tbe tawhid ofwahdat al-wuj0d (the uni4t of fuings). Yfi.suf al-Makisii acernplifies the existence of God in tbe unhterse witb tbe position of spirit (rih) uithin tbe bunan body. He emphnized that, altbough the spirit is only one, its existence ca.nnot be said as to only be in an ann, head, or body,
Makkirt
163
Studia Ishmiha, Vol. 3, No. 2, 1995
164
AuisKami
the body. al-Makisirt thm points out tbat its appearance esc,ists in all beings in :u,whid, Ykuf al'Makisii vis n on tln his acpwitint. univerc. Bad. on tlx forruktc a basir acpkrution ofsawal issus in ls lantic uorsbip, srcb as ma' rrfah (Eintual btruledge), 'ibMah (wo?ship), and mu'imalah (social tnjttnction). But tbe tnost intqesting part to note in the MS is that Yfisuf al-Makishrt acplairu the complicated concept of Iskrnic rrytsticism in more simple ttrtns. TItk oftmtook tbefornr. of the author\ aklity to use nTetdphorical kngtages Instead.
it
e*ists
in
tbe atholn of
God\ existmce is dcf.nitely abo one, but
is considered to be a high can easily follow Yrtsuf alreadcr the cornrnon knowlcdge, Eiritual Mak isiri\ rnrystiral treatise in the MS. It is obsmtable tbat, for insunce, Yttsuf aLMakkiri usa an analogt to acpkin tbe signifi.cance of tbe maqdm (suga) osAliko, travell.q, to acbieue tbe real truth. Ytsuf al'Mah'kAi atbich erablea points out thdt the tuth has aparticukr system of rankingthrough wbich a to
forrnuhte bis idcas. Hence, altbougb ntysticism
leuel
ptrson rnustfollou the sages step h step.A tAlik", be said, cannot acbieue the real trutb uithout startingfrom tbe louer stage in uorsbip, i.e., t^whic.. ma'rifah rrnd'lbadaJL It is analogous to a tree. Lihe trees eueryuthere, tbe truth has a body (aralog for the rawhid), branches (aralog for ma'rrfah) and fruits (analog for' tbirdah). Follaaing this argument, Y'kuf al-MahAsii thm argua tbat it is irnpossible for a "sihk" to obtain the fruix (ibldah) utitbout climbingto pass tbrougb the body and brancha. In add,ition, tbe tact of the MS refucts Yilsuf al-Makisirf \ paxern of Sunnl rngstical tradition utbicb diai.des autbtd into tuo categories: the uuthtdfor sufis and for l"y p*p\". Although Yfisuf al-Mahisii does not ekborate in any dcail his conception of rawl:ird for laypeoplc, he noncthebss girtes an acpkration of thetau,hidfor sufis. Yilsuf al-MakisAi noted that the tawhid for the suft is pattuned by the doctrine of tbe unity of beings, introduced by sufis such as lbn Arabt, uhich fulieaes that all beings are dependcnt on the existmce of God, due to His Supreme Being. Therefore, the real existmce is only for God, uhereas tbe other existences are only unanations (talall\ from the most Suprerne Being. Haaase4Yilsuf al-Makishrt\ inclination towards suftm does not lead him to ignore the intportance of daily uorship. As dcsoifud in the l"ast pas'
in of the MS, d "sAlik" needs to secure his/ber rektionship witb God througb paying gredt attention to dzily uorship. It is clear tbat tbere are a number of books written by Yirsuf al-Makkirt athicb share the spirit as the MS. In othu uords, bis undersunding of sufi.sm represents the great interest uken by most of tbe mystical scbools in tbe MalayJndonaian arcbipekgo in sages
17tb century, ramely, tbe reconciliation betzpemwahdat al-w,,t'$d(tbe unity
of
hing)
and
kkmic
orthodoxV.
Studia khmiha, Vol. 3, No. 2 1996
Aatis Kami
Al-Tasawwuf fi Ind0nisiyA; DirAsah li Nuskhah Kitib M ath li b al S ilihi n Ta' lif Y0suf al-M akAs Ari -
Abctratsl MuharnmadYkuf al-Mahisiln
(1527-1699)
salah seo-
rang dari tiga Fnikir M'slirn Nusantara (Indnnsia) taknnuhz. yang bidap di sehiurabad.ke-17. DoayanglainnyaadalahNmrdd.inar-Ranii(I,'liral-DtnalRAn?rt) (d 1 6 5 8) and. AM.maaf as-singkik (AH al-Ra'ilf al-sinkih) (1 6 1 5 1 693) yntg basal dzri Koularan Aceh. kbagaimanz dtn yang disebut tsakhir itu, Yisuf al-Makisii, Iahir di knajaan Gaaa Makassax, yang deaasa ini di.hcnal dmgan sebuan tljmg Pandzng Srilauai kkura ulah mmgaM.ikan hidaptya unu'tk perryebaran Isknt Dia tclah rnenusatkznpuhatianrryapadz kzjian mengaui fubagai bklang khu.sasrrya yang bthznaan denganldAm (teolag),tzriawvrt $ufisrne)dan shartah (Ifukum kkm)dan mmulis tidak kurangdari 23 buhudalamkhasaArab. -
MatAlib al-SAlikin (IIarapan-barapan Orang Sufi) (MS) adalah wkh satu karya yang menarik dai Ykuf al-Makis irt. Bidang gdrdpdn y an g dia geluti dakm buku ini adalah tasawwuf, dengan tesis uuma tentangtidak mungkin dipi*h bznrrya antara awhid ({e-Evan Tuhan), ma'rifah (lrnu ilahi) and. 'ibirdah (iu,s). Diz rnempahanhnn pardangan bahaa apabik saeorang hebilzngan sakh satu dai unsr.tr-unsnrydngak wpiwhkzn itu, maka ia tzlah jatuh padz stkap seorang rnusyrik" Dalam upaydng unwk mqakinkzn pembaranya mmgeirai pnnstp kebsattnn pada sebaangphon, dia mmggtrw.kz.n. sebuah aralogi wttangtid^ak rnungkin dipisahkannya antara buah datri baungpobon dan ungkai daunrya" Dakrn pandangannya adalah satu hal yang tidak rnunghinn untuk membayangkan hah tqlepas daripohondzndzunnya Di dakrnndogi ini, tidzk mungrtinnyabuzh tspisah dari dzunrryasamabalnya dmgan tidahmungbinrrya jiwa ttrpisah dari badan Diskusi mmgmai Tawhid motEakan x'rbyeb utnma dzlam MS. Yfisuf alMakisAi mendifinisikalt awhicl sebagai suatu peruyduan dzn prikku atas ksaksizn sneorang babwa Tuhan itu En Dia merryaukan bahua tidak ada r!)t4lud baik di dunia ini auu di akhsat ranti selain \Yujud Yang htu itu. Tantpak. bahua pardangan Ytsuf al-Makisirt tenang tawhid mnrgarnbarhzn posisi unxumftyd. para sufi dalam trad.isi mistik kknt, yakni, awhid dakm
165
Studia
kkmika.
VoL 3. No.2. 1996
166
Auis Kami
wrn wahdat
wujil ftsatuan @ujud). Ytsuf al-Makisii menrontobkan ehdzkm akrn semnta sebagaimara fufudukan rob (rth)dzkrn
aI
sistensi Tuhan
badan seorang manusiz- Din merrchznhzn bahua, mshipun rob itu banya wtu, eksistmsirryatidak dapat dikzukzn baltaa iz banya menentpelpada bngan, ke-
pal4 auubadan wja Me/ainkzn,iabnanayarn didalzrn sekrult raga seorang manusiz-
al-Mahisili kemud.ian merryimpulkzn bahwa eksistrnsi Tuhan tentu
sajahanyasatu,tctnpipenarnpakzn-1,'lyaadapadasunuazaujudyangadadiakm se/n6a ini. Bqdaarkan pada sikap intelektuzl atas tawhid sertacam ini, Y'tsuf al-Mak'is irt bensaha untuh msumusknn suatu pmjelaan dasar mmgmai Mbagai pmoa/an dalarn sistern keagamtan kkm, sucb as ma'ifah (pmgeuhuan
iLlhiyah),'ibAdah(ritus),ard.mu'imalah(perinuh-perinahsocial). Taapi, bagian yang paling merurik dakm MS adakh baltaa Y,kuf al-Makis,iri mmjelaskan konsep-kornep mi*isime klzrnyangcangih itu meklui bahasa yang lekh sdnharw Hal ini wlihat dakm kernnmpuan pmulis MS dakm mmggurakan bahasa meuforis utuk mm,tmuskan panikiran-pemikiranrrya Dengan @tu rnakipun mistisisme diangap sebagai sebualt ilmu pengeahuan spiitual tingkat tingpmrbaca area.mpun dengan mudah dapat mmgthuti ulaxzn-ulasan mistik Ytsuf al-Makis Ari dalam MS. Dapat diternui baltaa misalnya, Ytsuf al-Mahis irt menggunakan sebuah aralogi sewaktu mmjelaskzn pentingnya maqlm (tingkaan)yang memungkinkan seorang tAlik", pmgentbara (ufi), mmdapatkzn kebruran sejati. Ytrsuf al-Makisiri mmunjukkan bahaa kebrwran tersebut mentpunyai sistem unga yang fususun meklui rrwra sxeordng hans mmdaki anga itu seapak dnni seupah korang "sAlik'i kaunya, ti.dak. dapat nrcrtrapn puncak anga ad.i anpa mrlewati tingkat y ang paling rendalt, yaita tawlid, ma'rifah dan'ibidaL Hal ini mirip dmgan sebaangpohon. Sebagaimarw pobon di mana saja, kefuaran merniliki baung (analogi untuk
awhid/, cabang+abang (**logt untuk ma'nfah) dan buah-buahan (arnlogi unfilk'Lb6./rJry' Mmgikuti drgulnen ini, Ytsuf al-MakAsAri untuk kernudian fupandangan bahua adalah tidzk, munghin bagi seorang "sdhk" untuk, mmgapai budh (b Arfr)unpa m.ernanjat baangpohon dzn mebaati cabang-cabangnya. klain itu kiab MS mengambarkan nad.isi Sinni dakm mistik Yisuf alMakisir[ yang mernbagi awhid ke dzkm &,n kategor^* tawhid untuk pard t"fi untuk orangawam. MahipunYkuf al-MakkArt tidak mernbaltas secara deuil kanseprzla mmgenai tawlidfbagt orang dztraffi, dia toh m.ernfui penjelasan panjang lebar nrengmai tawhid bagi orang suf.. Yisuf al-Mah.isirf mengarisbazuahi bahua tawhid unturk, orangsuf diririknn dmgan ajarun mistik ksatuan raujud., yang diperkmkka,n oleh para sufi, sepmi lbn Arabi, yang mEtakini balruta smu.a rLajud bagantung pada wujud Tuhan, disebabkan oleb Vujud-l,lya Yang Maha Agung. Karena itu, wujud yang sebati banya milik Tuh ara sedangkan wuj ud. y ang hinny a h arrya nwup akan p dncaran (aj@ d*l
d"
Vujud.YangSatuitu Studia klamiha, Vol. 3, No.2 199(
3*,115 c,,r-ri
,;J-iE 2i,.,',1 L;l/.1-^ zl+r4azrl &{
}r[slSoJl
.J.-ttst
i*siil
^i/lh ufittruil Jh
:.g+ul
-5; 6-Wl il1 e cttf q5-r-l ,rr (Azyumar di Azra) trri 6>rGr,_,1 ,y-ll t-r gay c;-,-;-r4 oy.*-;"o gtJl o-lt e J--tl, ri).i :Jf;," ;i ,r!{^--lt e-t3)\ -r*e (\ loA / \ .14 jJ:ll) firruruddinar-Raniri) ,sl.,t]l 'A-J, J*9) c(\ 1tf-\ 1t o/t t . o- \ . y t) (Abdurrauf as-singkili) .\(\l1q-\ryv/t t I \-\.rv) (Muhammadyusuf al-Makasari) gr)Lt
aa\-)t f#t Jle e ;,15 )L.,"iJ ;u tf ; $ ;;),uJt ,!J^-r lJ Ji c-Jl ,su;-c\. F/ r#,f Jt*f_r,!**-lrl u9;y-tl p>iKJt /e 1 car-A\ J3 6,5 a;i o!t* J" .--..."J 4:,),i-)t flJt .*-iJ\: r;J (a+ft L,ilJt Uuf yy rr yf I -lf -ri i5rLK1t .r-ra.-:Ju cirt-Jl; U-A|S r--lt dr- Li),tiJl )pl_bJ\ 6tS-e *.-)b 6| Ur* r;;,$lt-Jt JL. otj* -t ct:f d Airalt .i,a \L ,*-s -:.;1
167
Studia
khnika,
Vol. 3, No.2, 1996
168
Auis Kzmi
C*tflJl qllAAlJiS
r#-
(+);Jlr aJtJt
oi-.6
Ji
+b,UJl
r+ ilt4)).Jll
d ilr..Cl ' i
i.lll ir"&11 6..r5i r.l.*.,1
.rt .iill oi.n .r-l J"rl U l!! .rf-1 c! JI 0tr)t{ 6tt $ r! .tuXt ,-p
Z,'--* 1i:tJl1 ii-Jl: Jf,y'l)
;-bUJl
l:Ul
o-to
Jtu Jg
'-'-t
e
C-:iU
c(n U ;F:Jl oisi cYiJ^i, crrtJu .ott_tl \: Ls-e !: U LF Y ;f, :, y;-J,.;t L Ot-';l ai-*Il-t rf,ll fLa. .+ AJ e @r A* eJUt criil; JJLJI J4x'-
of
.;+*tt o;
.Atrly L)-rt)
JJ! cr $tt .;;'-|lt .:JI; J:. (Sl Jl k-r) ^:V a-b j 6:Ul1 V-h ;."6rLJly ai-Jll Jrll a?,-'*t- e#t ;F ol g cwj+1
:dq
,-JtJ"
dt, e
+t :wt
t--:*
flt "ft $a. rr-ll f
+Fjll .i ,-t-t e#t .l;
-r--lt ,,t*t gJt ,**,- vt:(Jt Ur,_P .;oKlr*lt .lf J et+ Vts >3> j\ it>1 :f -ll6.t21 .\,rj .'t d .trir- p1 c;tgyaAl 4^6n- g;Jl ri-tjl -f i.u; Jry "-.-]-ll lV ,S Y-9 crrr$Jt l'-,lt "* )-r-f Y .-rr4:J1 )al ,"a:;s.Ujr Lae YL:, eIJ+ etet) &l ckl:.6:.'r-Il z;JL\) r l;ll r-e*-ell rp +Jl L^;
J!
l+b4,J"4nll &\ rl-beK #'n,f qF F y tFf J"6., ,S L-J! Jt}r f rjKr .g;Jr f d-e frC- JJ-l ,:*-ri q*ri! Jt:Il eU! cl-Jj! )Bl,i ,--l ..rili e t-f -f il t*.* dt*j)U (ail) J---*;-roft ,tt*.;)! ,*'" a-Jl AS)\ ") .A-it;e) d-t[i Ul 4j)l .,*," U!, .1," dxj)!,-! , uai gSt,-A5,.*-i Y cErJl
c,uil!
"/
d-{tj
S
Sndia khmiha, Vol. 3, No. 2 1996
Al-TasauwuffiIndinisii
169
+-.lf :;!t5 U l*^-ii urLa;,-,&-ilu "'J!" t'1'f ,f,e -jl$.St ;*--1 Jl -r+, ;.ll ;;u ."oL^"J ";Yl'1 ",*iJf" gt u39-
oi-
"*J!"
+rJf{ trl aiU rr -r--lj1 'r;lj, -r-ll :# c$2>1J! "r-- ;V oJtJt oi.n (sAe .ot)>J Gi,t-f y C lr! 6fS \yS t*: gf S y-LS
e-JtS
crLi..oJ
cot*;)l ,r*-l J! ra-W Jt r! lJlJ
U)\,*'-J C#t q'i"" .ai;\" qi, ,F *l &: ,;; ,F; rr*r' iu
r---UJ
f ,-J o;l ,1r'; ,F C tr.ry 'l ,!)5 -t*r-t#' J, $ .4juJ ,ti rP 1; ,F f S *3Sl (Jl-) dK,. r,.*Jt et-bel ,-f .,i tr-ry A atlu.r*ll ,j Cs)l '-r-v "r<j9 ,-;'Ir ar--r;:r ,r-r G-:Jl Urt-- oJtJt oi-" .,,li .,--41 ,thel F e,ig .ta-t.irr .s.,fr U W t\ I ,A,,^ui' *r,Jrur* Jy,y >r,alt 1; ,F Ut* ol ,st J, ,Jtl Gbtn -;'-y gJt ia+ :l't:'l J& J- .J"61* glrlj "!" JJ-a t-. .ur fJ;!t 4j\-**' a'Je ;r" C)V r
f P s\ rslt.i J-6. ;:I S; u"t-t 6))'et l r'*t .':t '-t-9,3Jt csl-r eJ f, alt I oa-( .'rf J-l t-. a\S lre:'- ! t -iJJ" Jtu ',r-:Jl JJ5 .irt<Jf
J;!r
r-t r^tJ; Jl t-tti * v ll-Jl lra AAt e ir uK' ;f n J*up rrrf uai,tlyr" :nr Jr;i q-Jtr ."r^iJl t-rjls
o-t.c
"o,-(=i
t"lrf l3.-+y,.,trJ
lr o.l-r4 fl o!" ,lrKr; f ,d*.{r rv :;lJl} ."cjb'- d9
3-a a-J-e14,t-'.*,
de
G3
)t->)r'r; ,F Jf $4 .>1"1 llt
.iiJr oia aJ)Ul 6rJ d-d*i tj.r" I Stud.ia
khmika
Vol. 3, No. 2 1995
6-i--11
e
,-r
.:ljJly a;A\) toasli'e
170
Auis Kami
! yl .r!.t ,F C:|ts -L*4r Jt+;r ,F"a_r. GjJu 1.:l.rJry z;*)ty l-* u > *-,;lt ,- 1.r^; .J4-rr JI # d^lJ1 ,f ;+ j\ ,F l* ,t" J-:^t ,-A 1e 6\ t3-*1.{ot , d-L4rF 'h4t '6, Jl "t!1" :JL; ;, .}-* t-r! ";P,lt ,r.--g F or_f S €4,y.iL,6 ..Jl5 1!! ..11 :r*9 ..j!(r a ,6,.+, n! -$r;)r r;r: .K-; ,-fi-ll eJf ei cot-c)l L;a;> LFf P-L-u-, g)\ :*\s ,lf + 6;;!l ,_f,-)l t_f : leS ,;,}Lt r3*rl -r*l / L;.2 grJl}r "-t -r-:c
;p
rf"t-it
oil,
cuJt 4lf CJi 7-.,.; caLL(jt 4i1i G, tsl..:" nt
)rS #
1!l ;:la.:,
,f
ct.rJ
;\r,S
nl reDi .i, lr!, ,JLi)t 4.;ti d .lf ,rf-., U .otV ;e-h ptrJt .t
,i F. c ,il'r. g;Jl aJ)l :^ nr-r ,-r--ly "irl u! .-rr;-oYt f .-x-l tyS .i .-F I s
elt
.Y
r.>pl
,nti,
Ai
4i_.;utt
..;
,f5 f-t" 1'-o ,-'*,
t+' t-;l 'f *-A\ ,f >r*;Jt l-. J-f JJjS-t ,*J! ,-* j_rs Vt_rJ tl*- *l d" Lji ,;*c. cne7l JL<-J r1.r-rl
Fl
,u
J, Wf ."-r C#t ,*4 ililr oiJ:,*J? .4I tr-l .iljLJt *Jt- .,; e
a*,
eilr
9l;, FJt Jl ,r-_ p .,#,Jt Jl j)l tS
Srlsll >3->16.t--g
,t*-ll ;.r--l
a-eUJt ,.J
4*g
4/ )
.a
6={t sl1.*- ;rLJli .r--t, ,,ir V1 >9y )r ,1,1
I
Studia Iskmika, VoL 3, No. 2 1996
Al-Tasauwuffilndinisiyi
-Jr )-beaetL,F'r; -*',-iwA e
a1JJ
aiJ
171
";:tJl"..r;*'
4 ras)\ or"L t**.4$! c/ t,f J r-Pl.*' G -r,Le.:1-rJ1 ;Jb .'.19 da#'Jl ;jJ.>
,>\>1
cuas*:Jl J""e e^.ro\ rt*-o!t
6:Jt
,"a:;s.s .F\S
-j-,V) l.t>;r
,e",o,-
rJl
4J
c;.rjt
JI;
,lt
,FUJI
+l \l oLJl Jt )" -)
i:Ul S *-JllS J+ll a]'i- j;;
"?,lf
e;iJr
F s.luD-r
oer*l\..ll -i-U \,*\s c6:Ul1 *-Jls r+-dl Jlle.Uf*.if
ryAt
gct- qLf .f p\t tlt ;
j;-
oi.=+ 1; F "f-r.oLKl :U)l o,)Jt nl JI ^. L1 i*.-fl r.5-tJl CJLJI g*,"
Ji
"Jr;)
t-f J)
4-.rjJ! K*"*:, 'e ,F #
1,,(1 ol
o)q.J^Jf-,! qJ" r-J-l lr,a JL k:li!
e!, & -*-s .g!Jt y l.rx." F'.
ot-'- o;tfy
'/:
oj-o
6r
;
.;?.lt
,U;Jr
:.+ i.UtJtf a.c,"rJ*
nl
o-,, JI ,P"
J\t"L\ e-U-u . Ar
.;L
aJt
f
tf )
,.1r
to
i aW e L^;i
g i' Jl ,l-*; ,irt ,* t7-t) o)FJ iltrl J+ eilLJt ti<s ,t-i1 .o1i Jl " -j*ti ) 4! J:--rl! .a5 ,lt JI Jy;S 'x.-D\s.6-r--1y :a-Et Jl \ .A Jbt 6t-r ,y Ulll +"!t .p, ^a\:{ ;-9 C#l g= ul uylr o;"-, d\ ,ysv\;rs',,Ic nl Jl -r"rl ,ul* oj-^ cf" 6l->1
.,,J€
A\
J"
(#JUI .lllA.iS*Jtt cre dJril" I arhJr 6JJauJl/JJ*rJt .t
a;ljl 4r-u ,y 4I -E \tI;-Kl^Jt *JtL' o\j*,J -)-t'" e,Jj.J\ J* dr "fL,E " Jtll i-^tir ,,n:5 A J-5- 4*ij JlJi'Jl JjJ) ,J!i a"111 Studia
khmika, Vol.3, No.2
1996
172
Auis Karni
i...ij$)t ailjl j ,p rrb i.KJt oi-" dlj c".-l!" # J*l 91.;...-l ot--. gl!-, ciJl*J JoU r*l ,;Sit-"lt ;".If1 vr|+ )l) uJlJ tJ^,,. ci$ JI Jyrl: ap dll JI L#..:, F" cr,<.lt*1l rJ' l^; yl-i.|l crFjl ,f.1,,.:Jt ,r., .-J,EJI
ta;t2rll1(udjimah)
+i)
rJ ,t--b ,t',,f
el))
G,)l4:--iJJ)l ..rrt-- ;f t-F-J, U
"f
W tz"-h ell*,".'tf 4n .z+-J)l * u:s-,-rl .+ a:.Jt,-rt-Ft,sl ,r*',-t-t gJt df +-Vt a_l t\ir-S W * 6l:Jt .:Urilt oi-a .SrtJts &-Ats J.-tt p eutJt ;t UIJ,aj,rll ,f e-tV dtr1lt1 Lslts,,r.-lt ,f_tL,v Uu-* .(niJ, JI JyTS
*,"11
oi-a.1J*,- JI.rlo
ea ,apl\ra Lfr
ctijl
p eijtJu .;)tJl
cs{j
,lu" -# fu" & ;-;i ++ fI ,Jll! ^Ly * al-y'pr '#.JI .sl 6;!t ;rr|Jl Jl .,rrll dy: i>LJl ft; Jl eULJt J*" Jl ;5.r" X LsAtt 7*\ op -'Ul ,_F Jrelt J'5-rt ,t ,j. ,*-AlJ r:-tJl lu,
L-t+i ti! "giiL" a.olt Jt,#-u+.r':l ..rfur tjK^1 ,,.itry!t; Pt E"tb -p)..:tit eU, g. .+bi; ,j*Jr Lfr a$t oe>dl eul.Jt qJL," u-:Jl L"!,!r 1.:t-.r;lr; ;ri!r Jl.p; "+r!." d'^]-f Jt L+!i
.l' u ,h,r
clJJtJl \-4+ f-
.,:Jl
(;rtJl; u-A\l rr-ll)
ai)r:Jl
..:L/il gl
c.i*-ll p -t*t CJt .:Llf./ tj: 6*
ar-
e^",-Jl .')!t
Studia Ishmiha, Vol. 3, No. 2 1996
Al-Tantwufflndinisii
173
J:t+ ./U(l al'-i-.a U'l.o' U -€l 4V 4-ij 4-tJl ,y'1.7o Jl:- 6l'" >i-* j)\;J-J" U o*y ;.f!t ;u:'t)u
drJ d-'-Jl ,../J
.l6l
&b U -S ! .,ryt.J
cr
;;-e
pUr tI
.ry.(Jr .7ur(Jt
t-t.r- l)!
,F y Utb
d/
ca3[!l u1
./.tt, o Jl-#
rr-iJ-
f-.6J Jf F-
*-dlr J.-ll)
o>t-of
u-6 .r=-tJt aJt*.
p
abl-$t
,fjl6 ls +L(Jt
gP
f--Jt
.'l.o Sl
..*'.i
& I uri' ge c-411
,-U1"'ri! /+
lr
i=iul /.f o L-+ .TUKJ|d/ U|Il e .1i:Lojlj
Jt-.,
*t*t r'-y'| ge u)t L+ r.-ll
JlJ,- ;)l-'.Jl;r e-*Jf L41
csjt F
J-j
l-r-
s;l d-'-Jt
V
6,1t]-
,F y tF
e-Jz*"& /+ errJl
.:u;Il.,,il,;Il
e--Jt1 r:{djl
a-rJt t**;JlJ a,-J:Il o.*Jl
u- i
l,-r1f
;f!l1
ut-l
r.f!l
.r .:-'.Jl
.J*ll rr CUJr oLi)l t* 6tc\i' J! p** ,lf;,SrgPlt gr,-.")t r.-y'| ,* y 'ti u;Jl ;,. .l>LJlg *-J:t a-b,il-idl ,*)* .r-,3y'l ,-+ elrl ,-; \"9 i-+. ,r-, ;*il Jt' JtJl .F- s7\ z*-u t+' e-3 sf Ji 4I,**r t-{1 a-t pt"-rYl .,.4 cs$l ,r"!t 'i-lr
\Jt1 Jll ,i7lai>L ir a;rKJ.t "+Jl" d{ Gb. "--a gJt U}v .l,t ,r.--1 Jl ,n-!. p),tJly .ilt n+l.r-l yl --.u!r J J,.:{ .;J!u .oUt-,
eJJr*iU
-tFJ ,s\
f 'SV+14ili; q'r'-!t .r-y g.:Jt Cr; cJt3l Jlr"!. lljl
.\\0.,-ar.1 n-*-1**)-e,J"L
tr;t
J(1
I 'ul .,tr ,f
L-.ue 4t.r;ls
+t;.(j1
.iJ!r
;ull
g;f a-bL:Jl
Studia khmiha, Vol. 3, No. 2 1996
,.----.i
JJs ge JpKJU
p)Jt
j- f
+ t:W. 6\ P\
lyyul -,L(jt tta Tyay
tp
174
Auis Karni
eI,Jst.\"i-,--iAl JJ ,Ut,
Uutr
J!
ptt, (t-r-)r) Ail-t-rl Jlr"'^r
.:;l;l .;Jt r t $abilah rubi$ ,-,*{i Ll"J L*Jl{ ,-r)\-4 i.iJ:1 ,;$JtJt JJ,;ro r-a.*-a--\ G tts Lt ;j)uJl e-rr--)l .(*-t p>Ur1 ;J!r !l .54 / .s.rlr -r""; ,r,l ob.r" -r.l u*+i ;l ;n]l ,-r!-\ :.:-'L;rK"1r ;-., 'r--; 'JLJr ab ,t-p of;(fr , t\ a;r\ c--J -t"l-* arD ,\tj- G-i -t 4-a- lJ-+ r, '* j o*S Wf\1 -,*i L+ :; / rBt ;c oUt LLt i* J! ;rl*1)l oi .s;!r UI(,)IJ ,!L.f FI r+! y\ ,r .,t-U6r:Jf +r5 U e f\ a*) ui '>>1j
J-b
6*
J-e
Jf-3r
-.l'.Scp!t
JJ
,*\
,-?;)Jlrl
a-**tJ\
$p c'l-y
ua*';f lL^;T 4
JUo
,J \ 'A o,,--)1 .r-J, -':Jl J'ij :aJr;1 fa;a-; l+ ,.;F c-r,|- .,,l a"+; r,.,!-) lil1 .s!"- .-l^ # qll L;,r
s!,,- ri-" J- iti
6-t-r
q*"...J-J" ,C-'r ai.-r;r" L^J+tltyls +i L+,\o"...F" a..+rl \Jn rt* rr.- u)L-.r+1 arll J- Jt uj; lil .JTll ,-) o,-ts ..r.U .r,l -r;-c
4*i $ .r-Jr &jJl oi iy ,p:J\ *s ,*.+U(t oi*a- 'PF ci '-,4t * L*;\ rL) rJ kp ceUtJl WV S d\ ,F\y d,1, Jl
j C"-* +}t e-+ 'r; ';! U|l U*s c:y'--;Jl ;vs L*y -t-r g':'jr :r;! cU1 ;5'r- r"!t \b
-,_t)Al J*J:JI 4--U
dr-,
.:tlt
1r^
* e al4'i*r .rL-.l,bJl .b F ...rl-*Jt, ,4\) r\-ill cr*J'! ,p),,?Al rrll _*\-f r !r!t .'tl r-J Uil\ l$ Kr cete*l\
)tWl;flr f etA\ Jrll ts# Studia
96Jr t-r, ol6It
khmika, Vol.3,
No. 2 1996
ALTasauanffilndinisiyi
a.r-'t
175
t#' aF 6sp .q
r'2lt .\ J-l ,*y Jrlt :;r*; Jl -*;- r.-ll: e*t CJt ,* ,6. uf, .pr*ll *s ,* 4r,y-)l ;,!t ,a; e;-rJt pUt r.-ll ;uJly a;-all ;-r pt",n)l 6S ,gn}l o,-l-e !t 6Ut -relty etdt J.-y'1 f l*-.l-*,; lr JJ-b ' ,-; el;r-r:Y13; a;-e p.r; dJl Jylt .r.-;t '+ s\ 9 -i-, g'ilt t p-ua diJl CA\ rrjJJ aXLr f-# U e tf -ll t'r,^ .'tl z'-bl2- a^K r
,_f -,J\ Cr+i ,-l--11 l.t--y (F{"*. Nasution) L;;-"-a>
,_t t-f
...*J
o1l
d:*-l-U
.,/ ,sfJ- )f
rJ;;La p-ti
-tij
J 4j JJJ+
^l J^..." n' f >y>1oJ g;-r-Jl t-,11 cd >3--1) J,-.- g;iJl c.ll > j-*1, a-A':' . \r"oil )_fi_t ya1 cJ->-l j t,fi-f ilJ4 I cr"f-!l U- ,J-i (!,-4'!-i -l\.'JlJ
,y ot-f ,-;-y gJt t l-Ld a;n\ upj.dl J.-11 of+ t.r," ue+JJ jtr-j rr-11 1a L f-,-J.ei d/ 4 ! .;^q la;-l;:; k,S)l .dll ;) "f:*Jt
.e.-l\ dtl k ll;,,;Jl '-r-S\ i.t-y;E; Studia
khmika
Vol. 3, No. 2 1996
176
AuisKami
€lt &)Li.,j,;dll
,n'
,-
)Frl
erl,bll
Jf .,tJrJl al
*p
eV
:ci'J
.rjlr;-o.It
,-;-*-e g;f
i-jtiit Ull
Je;r
l'€;e
-el
ar;!t ry-Jl -\
J+--: z,,-ji+ f ,r+ 4)$1.2;e !,r C-l U ,"! ;r/l9 ul,Ull k"-ir.t V.j) oJs e re kJp..U,.*. C:Jlr, '4 r;t-,;u. "f...q""J ,LeJ, ;*-*J\ t^d )-r ."* JI L,* -lf )r-, otJI rl,- .u'lt-',? Il i .1r oa{ ,+;.,J.l oj-o ,rj1 .'\1...1 '. L"r.i ..JLf t-6- a*), ,f g, U+tr
e
tl ,Pl t *.rn .,.*,.., cti YJ ,fr l: clb, 6s; up r.>j,-,. >5>1 .V i;"lUl'i" !J ,pl a .(.:ljJl ,3ldlt; aiJ.-rl +.i-Jl-Y .L#tol-t WU.." zb *t:rtiJd..
;:rJt .rtiJt etb d!, ( irJ.t oi,6;
p-! .rljJl il .0.* c.rl.*Jf fj4r, U*; nf .:l: ;r-.c (t1t--,1 .![;r 1 or.*U Cf ,W!l: ..:ti.eJl ,S F1 q5f c,..ftjJl ltJl UJ- at: 6;l \-V AS caJ;,It LAfi t^' c(i:.,ljJl c.r:-Jt
oW!t-1 .rti.olJ g.141 "r11"
.oltj,tt":f
6tt' G 6-r Jl!
l:r.*t ,:tiJt e-.- ,J_l!t d.lJ! u,G,J 'lF)l "t-.s ({gia.:,-i ,i,f .5'o ,,,i.;fl r9./l .-r! r,l.r-1*1 .:JX ! VIfo, c.>ti-cl et*l
l t-*y ill" :qol-r-. u;,pt-;Jr e-,-.rlt 4I ,-*t- Jl "* aJtJt 0i,", yrrt jLJr ,rF)t ,k -;Sl J.i; ail}r oi-" J! eJJrl ." ;I ,4 ^,- s$a I
.
*.
f
j
aAb,
u;'-{
ai)t-!l
.-.,*Llt .lL"r!l q-+*r
L,y
L--)l
d-ll;t
I
'r.;t-..- 4j1! .,19
el: Jflt aJt ,l otpll o1 t f (4J^,Jl ;+1 JI d-)qieYl Udl
e
ij|fJt 4-.tltl rr,J Wli L,xLJl dtf>\J q*rJU O! ,qJjlt e,t,ilt-r
L+*+iLi,
Sadia Ishmika, Vol. 3, No. 2 1995
A
d-l.!l Jt J-*; ,sb +if :.r-r., a-b ,y ut1 tu-)t>!l
l-Tasauuuffi Indinisiyi
"f }:> .;Ilr trU "l JfrlJ Ul a!t-:Jl .lt"r!r y-r "r! .tt(-o+!l-r J1!r ,q"l., rrl "t Clr {,.611
ut4IS
.4
d:Ja-:Jl dJl-d.Jl
LJJI
j*-t f-l.t dJjt
d"1;Il J-a.ijl .-lq
;.iiit
t4t;:!",J1 UJI ..,l.a.:.Jl
e-ry.;
i.jJl -f
a;jl
oj.o
g +:l;e1^:Wl ap df ,Jl.d, ,irU .;Ulr .(AY : f1 oTlrl "or5;15".irt Jf ,-r-,"-h f ,sfl ut( .;=.I-,Jr ciA)l .:ljjl ; qr-Lll ,_.-...Jt,f t-tV,b,y c-;tS,;Jr arrjjt JqrlE ;
a*.,,Llt ;r.ot-Ejl
:- f t-it U-6J (.,lJl
)rp 'tl* ; i,-ei ai$- o1V $ JyU Y cEijtJfulr sl'-r.Jt;'.U=; J)l ,JdJt r4b^{ * .t_r, a-erae /lJl lii .,j 4ili )-r-)).lt .rU;- *-#,f ;tV-Ut Ud .d ;i ::
,"Jl
Jlrj
llr.)l
L-o:.r- (JJl L#lj ;-,.. LJI ,>G_,oJl JI-I'J .YYi.ul
uili
.rLi-p
;"-,,1^ll
"tr
,rudt
Ub
Jt
;=*:Jt )JJ}l
eur+
.aj>\,jl1
W a;* Ef :;!tf J* C.-ltr,ti co)lf a:t*fq uy,jrr -Jl a*L- C C,f :4it^- )-r) _f Vt_r_f .a.;At eLb JF ,.rU],.J .Tr4it) J, o)r4b{ t l.*t.G fS rV)-F) 4._U if Ji-rf dJ.)L-6 l-L; L.' C.-lt c.t slt ,* /Ur{ nr a}|e uc|.* L-L 4t d,a*, ./ Ul U-6 ,il* eui$ c.dl! 6-rt- a*ii s91-,tf +-* "lf of .t, ^in 6,r-t.l u ,a-^_J!r a;- :.--1-,r? ,F eu! /Ui J! *4.a.;) ci-r.--11 tal a;;fr ,lJ ,lut J.6 e \S -# Ct 4Jtbrl r+ -r_,s Lp ,-p .dr i:grll titJ.t ,:'4 a? A*il JI .h i5iJr c.,arjJr ;-c _il.a ! zi;Ll i 4i1i l-+ ;J5 n-ii rg1. t-t,It ;JJ; 6il #j; t;aely y: ,.1
Y
Studia
hhmika,
Vol. 3, No. 2 1995
o6_l>l
r
178
\t\p
AukKami
J-!
l.r'; L
g,Jt
-r-:c
;F:
il|}l
,f-rtt gy'l ;1 jSJ lu; o;G; l-. -r;-c j1 5k"1 ,AU;u U-3,lg,"t!.t U -tS G 6-r
.>i-"1
o,r-a
zc
L ;1 +u zur(ft aD:lt -os/\,f s-t3I.ia 3-Jt "*J ,* toj 4sVtflsz*i a-r)\r J;4) .e\A\J p$ry -ij!t ;; Jlr+ rtJly !L-f JI r.-- p>'\Jr1 1"1r 6-r--r) ;.-rL-!l Jl.*^!" ;Jlr ,tl ol! .r-a1 .J_,!t a;rJJ aat; ai:l-lG c+|.:;Jl t-y";pf.nl a* .q:r .djk"l1 6l;*.t.pf5 nr 41 cq:UJl +;,I! kL:, "lU.(Jr, c;>rilt ,X ".Jl";.Jy-+t
t
JL-_r) a-j,t -t-3; Crr'
-S+ ,y
f-6J.
.Ii z;)s
t^fi" I qlt Ol, a:tUlt ^i/! ^#t5 *";ro1
q;;l
,>\'JL-a- JJI"d.-{ ncJl dJJtT
o-*-r
'(*'l-,,r C-
ui c:-w1$ rq"lll ,r, Jt
J\
f t >I;-,
,* ,4_l .i- F L-+ "JJ,Kj F" Ju L -L.i ."i^iJt t_r-l\ f Jrlr .n' -O gr:Jt 1t;+t
6i;Lt ltJt "r 1 rl Lo-r--i c.jUr (-!;!r /U' "r ob) -|9 rl*itll J;!t --t lr olj.tll ut e\y uru l:l .tt..r-;=;J-l lUr .> 4;a "* J! UEJI oj-Jll k+ tl-:..; -6y. &9 a,:Jl 'f4 csJl .,*aJl ,_r_l\s 1,4)t ait-b UJ;uf ,'-f lJ .r1:1 oti-,a zb-l)t uL-:. nl +;r:Jf a;j.i ; ,r-r U*+t ;r*Jt urV d,4: dl!t tl-:"Jt -r-_* b .6;;!\ /Ut "l ;.fls r6)|L.r)l Ju"*-t s aiL-j)r ;f,;lr ,.A: Cjju J
.4#L*.
JJrl .lUr ri-a ,kl t i\-j)l fJ
""fu
y {! Jr-+ (Ata*imandros) eS,tiV=--i'UIJ .rUl ,y d\ rl;Jl; r-"\-e +tl ,y (Empedoklas) u,,J{1al elt * (nus)
:JLrll ,y Ly;,.
(Anaxagoru)
AtfSUfl
J$ -ri
ffhales)
gp1 .s.\}\
,1vl;Jly rLlll
,1.:Jt1
Studia hhmika, Vol. 3, No. 2 1996
Al-TasawwuffilndLnhiyi
J.jl;ll ..rt-;tl 65ij
rtrT
tjio
.YV6r-rJt
a JA
@epikos)
179
,-/# l.+
.l Ur
U"a
,Fl
t
-Sl Jl l-*S S.llUJr JUtl J,(j" UI .\h.irt ,r1 pt.to;o+)jl jcr4s .r'r;r!t !?r e nr ,r1 Ju s
(socrates)
b\;"-..11 :r,-y
;r5v p;i-; (Plotinus) t**:
cgJl-J-t J-o
nl
J{.i JJ4
(Pitagoras)
'f)-f|
\-Wt os; .rq-blJ 1r a r& 6 c lut ,xl, .,Pt C L,)-)l :,,1",l,ill ,ti!r ,i xS jf or! U tril .;Jt -"rb ,*-b f ,* I lJl Ji-.r f"ri *,">\-)l ;;)^jJl .r-tf .,,trUJt
e
l:-r-ult ;-5Jt
fu-,W lr .tf1 .,1Uf .r-r*U cf-r.J s;Jl ;uJl :;,*-rJ.l -#;-5.J\ ojaly .,J1!t ,:--Jl .1o.lu ,;i lj-o .(6rt-. !y )Lelf--.x.. F -*-r) cr)Ul Ji JJ)l JiJl..l s^-- u-6J lb eJuJt ,:*-ll L:: J1!t .:r,-rtt ,; -fu;uJl >r*rJ.l "Jilt cr1
)_F_f r4b;;i)\ oj-o;-.y
ga*;n
Je
.''.,:lrJl ,UJl
a--c JLc,- cSJt
,p .-id\ F\lF cr)Lll ,F-y'! 6Fj,. 1r,6 lUt ,Xt L^4 .a-1;!\ t'tr)t k\ ,e .,:Jl JJll ;>t-lt, atrrll1 I Ul '& ,l''J; tittsls (Saturnus) J-Jt Ji.sr-)l i)i!l o.#\ $ J,Ui J+ J-#1 fy fiupiter) csj;Il; ,(Mar$ ,ttJS (;t!Jt .Jtft C-)P.*:] ,FJl
1.r-A
.gu)
,A1 g-1t cr d J j ,e a P lj,,r; jA:-U\ uZ-.1 .gn
4lij L5-
(de Boer)
/ Ul
U.a .'lf ,r.,trUt
c-31 o14 6t--\16y
6lt *
l*1 ,41 c$-yt;
-t-t G);rA1 ,,.>--r- /Ut
l.La u,lJU-U
\t-.o.-".
a*:JU
a;L
.,,trlJt 6\, p lLJt i,t+ ,p *b" -dy;r-li rr1;La rj-^, .nr )_F) W 4 /r*U u;-!t ;rUt oli ,rJJ: uK-Jr ."r1J1l
4J
.'J) --$
Studia
kkmiha,
Vol. 3, No. 2 1995
180
AuisKzmi
tib $ llJtr
6rUU
rsJ|l
"t-,
)l'.ijYl ljo;
ck-Ji
.;1r-"r;
er-u tr! tta.jj)l
uri
.lf
,*-,F:
fri s-t'^i .,ir ps Jr^.f trri llJl Ot JJi'.'6 6l1Lil1 '.aj+iL\ e) lr U+ ;r> 1.r+ ,-l ,f : l$ Cf ;rL' llJl .stl! Jtr dr3j1 cf Ul e,1- fUar a,-;- trrii; ,.,t sJlrt-iil J:- t'Jt ,t f,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,$
o)y*) ,-*\1
2-)-e :;6;-,a
.-*11 .*.6j.4il)
.i,r :a(;rtr
+
CJ-lr-
...U*lJaj
J1!f Ji'Jl JI c7t \+ drU 'tJ"r-'t t3i t l!! o:;*1 F U":;ut a rt*;ts
.4iriJ J"rer a})S ti^1gf's-eiJ+
.>ab 6l ..i
"Jilr
w .>FjlJiJ
,Sar ,-/s 7.\1.,\teab >t--r)t *tf JUr--LiJl L+
.a-I)l U-b
tS
,-r-l\
iiJ)
'l*l,.>o;t
'*;;1 >vjt ctf
a*ilJ
oe Tast Gs'J-Ft .rY.rljl*Jl oab ,--.-ll;f**{ a*;; ;te
6-lt
,*
o)t+) f tJl ,1-r \tD
't--z-:H\
y
ilJl ,Fl a lUl U," .l! ,+UtJS4 '>t.cl Jl),f.rll dl':.>\-)l UIJ 'ii I iri1 ajLll1 I Ul J! ;J+'i I l4.r* 6>1,. ;r, aI -gtttijl q ;J\'a U J"- tr*Jl J-pl ,-f I Ut
dl-. .y'Ul J-i'il rl-"'ijr r
y o)+
./U1 Jilr
.-i LIrl) l)Lll o! .s+l-;4"*lJl a;)jJl t-\ 9y e ;t)l .rr&<-It ,r"!l .r F d, ldl Cr .;t. l!! UJJ Jl+l z**\ J"
6.r--.11
tr-it ,11 I \-'Jl t:4 -"b Jr I \-J\ ,tV L--F a-E-)U1 o-t gJr .9i, .lt+ r* JI r5r-.>t--ol ot"Ult a,;)\-iil t sl L-+ lJr-;tLJr a-*Jdl JI qfl lt Jt '>V e -S e i't->1"-.1.:.5 'Jt $,L/ J-u./z-Jl trt'f.'-r! ,L.-" d/l1 Lr.,l-1t-iJl '; ,;+^t "br .lL ua+.Ljl Jl r# I \-jl 6'b ^-'"p: >9--'j,\ Studia khmiha, Vol.3, No.2 1996
Al-TauuatffiIndinisii
181
,:-jl ;J-J -6j.r ul,ull ajtJt elt :, # rJL- ltJl U-6 ,:t+ ;Ur 6 j;t 6lt u"t-oz.lbtir .rYL"t-fi-)l;"r-1 a4i ; J! ,t-*. jl;r-J f.6., g. r[JYl J,e Jtall
LU> 1911-r--11 l:r*y JL-r.lL
^hi
..*.-..i
.1r .1o
,r*rJ,l ,t!i
ci-1E
.lf ,"
Cf
el>1zjjll ;ar ,f-e,i,- I eu.it "r-ji &iJU A-*JIifl J5 rJo- (,r-t" gJt, all .,rl) L."yt itlt o.r-o i .4ili 4 it\ z';-c U-6, dlj r,.:liJl g-o A-e;-, a;-,.Jt c-;ti li! L+ (il;'Il c. ttj-:, t+ .ir::il J! .sr1 ,,!t .-,! .,i,t
G/\ C,tl c lS cSJl g. Oib ,t-)'- 6-Jl t JU a;jjl ,-rl-*Jt, i-Jti .rt;i/ o.r-c. d-|r* aul .ot ,,e,-rt-b e a:\> 6l-o1 4y .l 6-b'-
JSJ) ,64;,Jl;r-,1 or5: t.5: ;t*)) e-J\
.!1
\*' t -5+ I
,-t*, t+' 4*i Jell J! rdil lsr .y-9f ,fill
f
qlUt a;i-.lJ
"lJ-.:lt
o,
LdJi J-(d) J-=-ll;.- otey'l ,rl-r"a .pLe *ts L?te +j :EJ -t-t gJty cq4;tll1 tr";!t1 aj;Jt s;J ct$l Ji" -tS-A\ Jf-dlt r.-l! i9o-{ i-*.tuJl1 ,t$t J*11 ot* Jylt r,-ll 4" a*; gn\
et)l r,rll
u-6
dlt
,r:*-ll cjA\ J'-ll
csle u'l't'Jl
lil: .lul
,lt .rl-i." aru drr ,CJjf JS -)l.uJJl U i"-U' e b-p .'r! .J;- *rt J.;,-oJlF" I o*r grt ,.J;Jl \q'. dhp- ,'-t c,irl 6li ,f CF- i -n-r- bill .,lrf J-r.ey cdL*;)l "-r-1
jJU n1 L_'
Stadia
khmiha,
VoL 3, No. 2 1995
182
Auis Kani
r-r.r.4:Jl
;,-ft- cf r"& u-St l^{ ;*ra
gJt t
;-rd;
g;jJl
r.-tl
.1S;
.'ti
.Y
gt
tJ eLp;)l;5f I ,FS ,,-d-;Jl dr{Y ;!.i*[ +-f ls-f Jt ^4+Jr .c6 ,r a+!t ';ft ,j .Sl +le * 6: "JJJUI" a*-"f .r5f.r: .r"a gJt q\S ,y 4 F+"J "o\t ";t Jl 6-b,,r*t-- &)Lil J,-lr,l eLI; i4;- c.e, lr! i:lJll ai-oll-r rr-ll c.2-r
dili dJiS 6.ts-*
c;-iJolt
'*
"6 I SS,.
til1 .a--e$l ,J,tKJt -r--At r^-r
"irv" cr.*Jl CJi
s;Jl -,U<Jlir J:!t ,*t ( a-ii:" iil-ll oja .ro1;li .l:LJty aj.*Il: rrll ,rr1 ;u!t JJX -Llt
J--Uit .s..-olt
O-r,.
rt'-t' -rt tri d Pltr;\
Fa-
I -ut- pt
.':l Je,lt ,,S-rp
6>rvy.yf ,lj,a1 ci:LJr J^.#
ll
Jn
/ c!
.rL.5 a,.- ,p!t ,J" . .",pt trll 6>rVr,-,fu eU, a -51s . r1-\,r-> "!. tSJ6-- d 4,tjf JI !.-jli;l J! crf U Jr..-i-rr ejJl l45
,o, .dUl ;t:- L,f a"a.*t .:Jt:tJr 4^rl ,* S* k+;*l c(Srilanka) ,L+! (*-;;V 4j!i (4rt;r{l qr-i1}- Jl .--* 6Jt g>-' ^-{f "r, (4.,)\-)l *S 4#\.:L$t ,F ;f ly-)l J,Sld Jl +i:t-Al -t--uuJl .rv"a-.)-)l a-., xJll .J-r+*it dA-{ L.6*i f.- ,.rjJl dL-Jl ;-* *s ;b4 j t#t + ,jf ,ll .s-,ejt;:_r o\ 4,r)jl-l Ui+l u r:l tL- l: u\ e ul 6>1Jgl ot-tpf c;-rjl .jUl JJJ5 ,JJ +i:ta,; ,qi},-l ,r." ,J)-)*
ist';i*
I o;fa ,;-y- g;Jt.-tra;r Ql.*;.-+
.
)..2
a.tt*. Jrr,"
c*J ,S-i\,.:l--),tpl djrt;+l.r;,1., r",--; C/l ,t\,rt*a; J*':-l t-;r q-.rt5.,,. ,-r!t ,-*l ,-t' br-,J' -,-!f U- ..#lt jtl
dr-
Stadia Ishmika, Vol. 3, No. 2 1996
Al-Taawuufflndinisiyi
W
e-*)) L-o
183
.rL-J'[Jl oli-t 'r^sLjJll rl-rjl 6>t't'et rtl)|1 rU-Jl1 r[:'iJU Jt Jr-}) e'ttA\
"oL,qJl1 ol-:'iJl"
6JJ\ ":ya$l eU-, .-rr '>tg!l )\3)l Jl ,ly--,o,- r-i-r it) oL4ll ,t-;Jt of -f o-l\'"t-"''-
rf q ls
,rLilt Jl Wkl! fq I .r"3 gJr L+ Cs .'lt-rlJl oliJl; 'u'iJl L+ t':ril l.r-; 6J,-C.t e--'lt ; Ji! Fl 3Ju aitll alt*' Jl a;)\'J! ajtJl d Jl gJrt o-t\s.l' ,r- d j\ ,7i 'JJ JJI 1; ,F 'rl ;;t "f U+ ci\ir -are)t f ;fJ-- * .:4t g;J lul t^t'*'; U-Jt A\ aif" ir, nl *r ,,lurrlr .'ll oy..-ru o116 g,'\sr'tY:-l,J! t5; 6> S l-u.;t -di;,!; o1;Ln 4Uj Lt- Jr-Jl; 'r"'11 J! c-Hl qA)r -,r!l .+r+ #rl ,4t)\ )r\ & 1)J")t" :air"Il cP f
o!
Ju; .lr.*j;.
u ++t ,rW\ s.-o."9
I
,.t jrl)Fll , rr
1!!J
r, 11 4Jaf' "l lt
_FJ
$ ,-b9 gJt 'JI .at1 J+S \.,-b kJe .> j\ s.-'-r; ,-rJl ai/l dli iiJt LLii
(+-l/J &V i,ty,)
,r-r-lt it--s *i
\^-(t ,"Wt
.4! a'JJ a'-"o:; Fr nr r^ k*;JlJt, .rjt- ; ,,+l Jl f il rCl J! .s.,,41 r--aJl e|-c' '-i-ri CJJI l'd5
L-.;,3
V-rsgf
a.lUr ..r'3r
.ili\-Jl
i,aLill &ut '*JL' vt'f 't e .;)LJIJ A-Jlr rr-ll ,,.r1 -u'F *
6) aiA\.;rf +;;',. drJl J*tj\,t' o-,V ':t'(t 1- i '\:r-dl 'Y ,sJJ\ ,?y *y;:-r ri -r.-lr elJ! .7uit 1- L'i '^.;)t1;4 .G-lt ut r ls Studia hlamika, Vol. 3, No. 2 1996
184
Auis Kami
d-"ri
diJl e t-at\ o! , "4.t* e-t'" )J4 I te g lr! -a-rg grtJt . f
;.r--1
,*-64
.;-;:'1
eiJi
.ilJ;31
.6.:t--tJ! g-+. .ae
6'-J\
ayA\ I
j\ aaAJl ,_t*-/l
Studia klamiha, Vol. J, No. 2 1996
A
l.Tasauuuffi Indinis
iyi
185
:Ui^l$ll ar+alr Lb4t) t-|:ric 4i,).*)r ajtnjrJ erl#Jr *(Jr J- Jsl &l a5t, (Ji . \ r,\tlt L- J-4 YV-Yo 6r )_rlj(Cisarua) lt-.,t:.:;d[CMI) da.L*|l 14-,f :j_eJr -r-L iI alJt >{-:, "raL:, 6.ts+t 5U-!l $fV "l "f}-l .o*l ,rl,*L. e\ j-2.)t -:ira>t-t--t Ed *j .:l+le!:r isLll dF ;L-- .+r-"1 " Pandangan Hidup Ulama Indonesia" ({JD ,.Srr* .j -t-t-.a', .\ u-rb, oo i ,'LrJl ;.-.:iLJ! (Ji aJU/ $l iaJl .5t i:it , c1";s"-j-g-rJ)l et^LJl .\ ,f ,\ lAA a:- rrli Yo-Y t (VfV u4 qr-;y")l eL-Ul ;V ab;l t*\
i,-.aJ\.31"1
Jl
,LJl
,.rr! *t" Jl ,b'l .r (Pesantren) u,>L-!t +Jl q"ea)'-)l UUiJI J".,t-
"Kirab Kuning; ProdukPeradabanlslam"
rl :(\ 1AA) \ :\
,,-]"ur- Ja)\n "4t-*" WI.t> _tVs "l l.a.Jt -KJt sf.ri:-" 4:Ju, * ,k-tl r (uft4 z4)#t a,,a-)! a-t-JJ .+ll tlt *bl o)1 (r-t) 7y-z-z3L-
.Yr.ac\1AA
jrtl Jl g;U L-nlt t.tt U;/ .t .YYo-YYt :(\ 11.) \ t1J,:) ("+Jt r^tJl 4+ i,-l-.:Jl qi,1l f .tt,,.tl cL^LJt l(- .1 -ui crL-.iIt.9 .:,L-J-Jrt e;,-p ;r9\t 5t .:,t *Jt ,rr . o t+,-yLl i.tl Jk i--,tll ,rrL^i*)l ll CJt . 3. ;6:^:, "t-otJt lti.rJt_9 "Laporan Kegiatan Bidang Pl &,-bjl-a'V)\i ro-r,-.,Jl i-tJll ,u-bit
-LiL -L-5
,1-,"
.1"
ge*--)i
\ 11
dU
. aj- jt-;:Jl
JlAr rl-
.,r1
.,ar*"] Pendidikan"
; rl i.4Jl *-<Jl J-p c )Jij U lJ:Jl ewlt il+ .r t(Kyai Makhfudz Tremas) o"\ri by;9 6^Jt t(I(yaiNawawiBanten) .;'! Kyair4t+ "LrJll 6rJl c(Kyai Abdul Ghani Bima) L4 jUl -r."c tJl
6
j-r.
4\
I e '.- a:j-!l et-L;
c(K.yai Abdul Shomad Palembang)
6LJU r-^-aJl
-t-e g;JltArsyadBanjar)
&Vri g--Jrt fi(yai Hasyim Asy'ariJomband el* 6F!lf,!LA Cr&' -dL$ c+J,iJ U-1!t o7:Jl Jl aapb! .(Kyai A. Rifangi Kaliwungu) -*-lg ;"--tJr, cr(Jf +:, i olr^r.:a e -J itir,.-.,i.ll s1.,1- J, J! F$r.e' ep,lf ,eU! .-l*t edt gUiJl .j$tr a-L-)1 +'-1V.:Jl iljl "Asal Usul Tradisi (J>lJ dr-Frl )-+ tbl ../.-/l ;L:i C- i, z*b, Studia Ishmika, Vol. 3, No. 2 1996
186
AuisKani
cPesantrmt1"z-2.ril -r,oLJl
d
+*-lJt -rJu:Jt
t'g-,1uil1
Keilmuan di Pesantren"
.A:\1AL 6*")tC)l Persfektif Sejarah: ,ilt '''-o Aii
di Nusantara dalam ; bll to*t)-[)l J'i#J!l d {+)-)l
"Pemikiran Islam
i-1je
";*1"1
ir(;Jt"1
'y
Sebuah Sketsa"
irL ,pJ irL.:,t r:Jl i,t4lI rYV-\ 1 : (\ 1 1 \) Y c(Prisma) t*-1t; q"^.bSi' '"-.i\;fi'4-{ }t ,f i-,-r L'; I Vlu,rJr ot*lr 0t ,J cJt4l ti-" i ^'lri .+L::Jt
"Tiga TahapPerkembanganKeilmuan
i:JJl ol,
Utb f&" cli Ji ?"-F. '^ ";1">!t d'lt
bly"l di Indonesia: Mitologi, Idiologi dan Rasional" ;jl':.ll a'*bJl ,L^4-/ JlJi;l .l"rsfJtt c.r-j;u{)l1 ,uc'aAt,L-*tsl"l .tV-torac(\11t) "Pesantren and Kitab ,-rt t+- 4)c ).aLt F- aJLJI oiJ i^;J! cf; .11 ' l cr)L:Jl
Ja:Jt
Kuning: Maintenance and Continuation of a Tradition of Religious L*r+)sJu)t iJJ^tl ; tv-YV :(\11Y) Y : o )a:tOUp rlearning" .Ao-VY :(\ 1tY)
6t ,St ,i
q'a:)t
di JI dJlj j
r-tJI
t
: Y c (Ulumul Qur'an)'t-tt;Jt
d/ dJl J--f JL
Jo+
.t-l; cn]t 't* .l
'
\-t
:"c.,!lJ'r!!" i- t"--+rr! ; (.J--lJl -bLfJl J,Li s rr;t ,tp ,oavAt i'4Jtjjl {Jl,}Jl y . \ \ zJ.,-*1 LL:'tt U*a .u-, ;S)l ab| 6nt rj"e Cl*Jt Jll ;l L Jll o;Jt e\--Jet;,r;;dr;arlt4loulJta-fu, S,{s ,^SI ri 6-t\ .
\
.t*+rJ! e e-At.r^.lJt .5'ql.i:lt ttbt c--S'Y \ .f tar".>L!t ;f;Jt ,^\ r." i+i .\ Y C-+l J-& ,31 "Jaringan
,OVr
Lil
ctjJl
;Jl* C.:4 A t-*r-.5jJl .:;-9t-{t.g.:}t
ot \ll,J;t ,1;uu; 6l\1Jl
-U--9!r rrJ-:.Jl ,L.Ie
a.ttu.Atl
cs1-)-ll-9
.t
r
s-*vl'u)l
"f, a(-.1"1 Ulama Timur Tengah dan Indonesia Abad \ V"
!u-!l aj- V. L-lrr.JV-t)t-io gU-Jt ,llt GVy;!1 .g .J :VfVi c"ar,)\-1t ;r.illt ;4:-!J*jJt .rt-K*;)t Jt+ .+ Qst-t-l .YA{,-roA e ,l \ 1A1 c(LSAF) j .i Jil\-^ ))-S.ll
Studia
hhnikq
VoL 3, No. 2 1996
Al-Tuauu{f Indinisiyi
.Y Y
"f
t87
tgDl-! ;rK;Jt.JJ J* 6+i .\ t p (r2Jl tii .\o .yy vt--.v 3/t g; 'll
JF Jf Jfu- aJtll oi'6 ' \ v trl 1'+--.S>it!r r* o&14).d)\l)l .J';+-o 6r s^ !*+r$! d "Ash'ari wL:f ,r, (George Maksidi) sr*"rft p:- tbv c,r,)L)l 3luJt (Studiz L.-.)L/ ,>L-|il cand Ash'arite in Islamic Religious History" .5t';Jr a-r*:ll of ilt Jt
"/)t-)t
J-!
J+--:u i,ta
onc't'l-\1 :(\11r) \A 1A'-YV (\11Y) \Y klamica) Tradisionalism in Islamic Religious History The Conflia of "i "Remarks
Modernism Middle East ue t(lCarl Leidenl .l.rJ Jtt-J) Tradisionalism and "The Non Ash'arite Shafi'ismof ; t(\ 111 cr'L* a-t- :;1-i; AV-VV
(Relae
Des Etudes
khmQuu)
V>L-lt i-til
al-4
tAbiHAmidal-Ghazali"
.YoV-YYl:(\1A1; oi
)-+\" ct-l1 o->)t
t--'s w:11,-e\\4t ijt-all
L/ b.rir-!
t-alAl
uet'az trL;Jt 'trt
,f qg J\7r)\ rr + !.) "g'"!t TDe ,(\(olfgang Karcher) -r-3.:.6 eV Jss (Manfred Oepen) ,ji 4Pu
,rr "Principlesof PesantrenEducation"
Impact of Pesantrm in Education and. community Deoelopment in Indonesia j Llttz) r;jl (+Jl ,lt-* ,f:*Z '\ 'f-\ 1V g"a c(\ 1AA t; f :Uft*; Tradisi Pesantren: Studi Tentang Pandangan ,Q,artawsyari Dhofier)
r -, J :Uft*;
4:Jgl L-bJl
q/ Ut ;l:,' +it .f ,sr*.Jt t'J;!
/tj
Hidup Kiyai
.Lo-tt :(\ 1At c[LPIES] sr c9 \1 t+ ,_* ilS: c.rUJ':Jt P G )rJ ciJlF ol1 ,f )t olLf )/-' ,Jajl ' t : r -r+Jl ,".r,)L-)l .7r!r ;;-t-- '.c\ i4J\.31" tlr;-'a t';Ji; 't" G\ "Telaah t(MuhammadTholhahHasan) J-* a^IL -tJl c\ \ - Y (\ 1Al) c.rri c
.ri dU, ,;"-r-otJl u;
\ tAA
--5..1r
.t,*) 6fi"l
\V
-
c\
.;-)l -.::(Jt '.JtL,"1 Kitab Kuning
\ o (Muntilan Magelang)
6,i*U
"MengenalPemikiranKitabKuning"
"Pergulaun Dunia Pesantren; c(Dawam Rahardjo)
Stadia
khnika,
Vol. 3, No. 2 1996
oe
di Pesantren"
9'1.:' J'6o ;-hW
6)f-
-r-r',l-t llJ)
C
tlS -st'at1
d
l"el iLd\
clY.j :UrtE) q6Dyl U et;! :.tat-Il / lo 6r) Membangun dari Bawah" 613 J-;"1"Menguak Pemikiran Kitab Kuning" J (V. - oo :(\ lAo (n L-r;,lrl-* .f cY\ - \Y :(\1Al) \ i \ J4l cy"c\r-.iu.oJl -^-K.tr "Epistimologi Kitab Kuning dalam Khazanah Keilmuan" cChozin Nasuha)
(\1Al) \ i \ rdl(["LflJl U\+t est-i.a|t.5r ur- orp"l -^-:(J1"1 "Kitab Kuning di Pesantren" t(Sahal Makhfudz) bye )* * ^ ,r*--*1: \V- \o 6;)*L- .,-t-l-**r.;rbLjll jillj. c["-rat 11 Gr\*,*-, "Kajian Kitab di Pesantren: r(Nurcholish Madlid) V PV r; f;r . t lLL .ril; -t-At :.ra-It ,su ,"6 a-tt:"1 Lingkup, Makna dan prospeknya', ,FilP).r*rrll 4-*t i*,t+l ..-r, -r<-Itr ^4.ll ,jo al-11.r-, i o)\;" ry"oz-p:1
-
YY
.\ 1AV lFi l1 ,Urtl-,eJJl
.f - \ ";+l
:(\ 11Y)
\
'.
o
olji-
"Pesantren
,rst** .j ,.t-a. .\, .t,gLJt6*//.,!F.Y\ .l \ 6;LJt 6>,Jt .\ \ and Kitab Kuning" crr---+JJ;t i;rL .Yl.Vl
L--b"
t i Y drll f*tYY .(A .) f A c, *"i; 6*_ri1 ,Itl
c(\ ClY)
.y
.Y
t
.-:(J1" ..rr!
.rl" .r o . \ \ ,"rf-'oi" (-FlJ ar.r-rl J.r .y 1 YYA ."pl j-e)l
-ri'',iorU .tV Segi Arketisme dalam ct--"+ uaJl-; -,:' .\ \ .YY1
"Pembahasan tentang Beberapa
c"r.l r'i-'ojl
-
.-.:(lt ,-a-n; -i-ilj! * cf c-J1"1 Beberapa Kitab Jawa dan Melayu" eL-le;L- LLrJ rb;;,.r e^-Jt zz4 ;s;Jr:Jt j 4Jta, (t"41')U1-1 a:yLJ,!
;f asul
'A-t)-lt
u;).\1AA r,l/
Yo
- Yt Uft-
(LIPD,j4J,!.^*t-ul
6-r-Jl JLat* -Ljl cq-a;Jtl d,-+.r}r"p" e;;!r oYL*l "Tilikan Singkat terhadap Berbagai Kumpulan Hadits Nabi Muhammad" c(Djohan Effendi)
c6)F J--; )J--a.j<'1"a+ft c-e:t-!t "4--eJ^e J).g J--e ..ittr d3"l "L*-*;-r.;l pies ,-rUr- e!-r"r:a o:- -l ,*t'-rpsV ? lf ;L* ;.rr!j" 'Lle Sttdia Ishmiha, Vol.3, No.2 1996
A
rffi I ndinis iyi
l.Tasauw
Marcoes-Natsir and John Hendrik Meuleman) "Perempuan di antara sle4;u1 i-a.; L-|s €t +- i)-tiyl a^tJ;ftJ4 LembaranKitabKuning"
M.
"Kitab r;.--*-* el
)J ib isJS c\11 - 1oo t(\tlY I(INIS),r'+l:Uft*;
-;^\ -31"1 .\
Kuning dan Perempuan, Perempuan dan Kitab Kuning" v
t-
1o,3/LJt
1
6-/t G i" e\ iLa\ *<Jt-r ;l )t ),;1)\ ) . tY \ cr7. LJt 1*/t .f JL s 4Fi ' Y . tYY - 211 ,a*a;+,Jt .Y '
C
.2Y L
,6-/l
.Y \
".; ' tf t ,;;tL)t 6*/t .r I qsjJl ;r4JJ. iL, ari1U *b'" J\ *-4 JlJl ,-r!i call}l oia ; 'f l UV ^*lf.pU .-urJl
j
;\.t)\
PI./UI
q. .
"lr!t
i! r"" dl iL i--Alr<Jl 4r-, 4iti JI 6;t p1)iJr ert . \ Ao ' air i'fit 'i dJ-b .,r lr ,;uJr a4p F (ncll ,-f u-tv t ;ot', Jt) elJi.l o+ r-"e\ "L;;" ,r.-'o- rgo Jf F" .t|r ) u fV ;
Liu!..r,
"e
o-..,t
1
(Salim b.'Abdallahb. Sumayr)
,J, (G \(J Drewes)
Note on Muhammad Sammaniya Practices,
rr"
L.frJi .6 .)
al-Samman,
chiefly in
khmiha,
Vol. 3, No. 2 1995
ht
,t'lt-s -* \+vdt aPJ
c'rrE "U!t
.^+ttJt J1
-!t Lbr)
His Vritings and \ 1 th
Century'
Batavia, according to 'written Data"
.AY
Studia
dil -ri t"i-'Yt
c.t
.C
& *6
t(\ \\\)
(ArchiPeD
LY
itn)Yt