Opening
Alexander Boer
[email protected]
Uit te reiken stukken & voertaal
1.Agenda 2.ICAIL 2011, LIT 2011 en ISWC paper 3.Presentaties Alle materialen zijn in het Engels Voertaal voor de bijeenkomst is Nederlands Presentatie Yiwei Gong is in het Engels
Deelnemers
Project Partners Sjoerd Meihuizen namens NWO Geinteresseerden van andere organisaties Symposium Agility voor uitvoeringsorganisaties (1 oktober 2010)
Programma van vandaag 14:00-14:30 Voortgangsrapportage en overzicht van Agile project (Alexander Boer) 14:30-15:00 Agile Services: A Reference Architecture for Creating Dynamic Processes (Yiwei Gong, engels) 15:00-15:30 The MetaLex Document Server (Rinke Hoekstra) 15:30-15:45 Pauze 15:45-16:30 Kennisacquisitie voor ontwerp en diagnose (Alexander Boer) 16:30-17:00 Agile in groter verband & de toekomst (Tom van Engers) 17:00 Een drankje
The project
Alexander Boer
[email protected]
The project
AGILE: Advanced Governance of Information services through Legal Engineering About agility in public administration (PA)
Fast & flexible implementation of policy decisions
Prompt and useful feedback to policy makers
Flexibility in architecture & network arrangements
Project funding is related to innovations in serviceoriented architecture (SOA) Leibniz Center: legal knowledge management (KM), acquisition (KA), & engineering (KE)
Delft: Complex Adaptive Systems (CAS & MAS)
Service-oriented architecture
Service: a good that is produced and consumed at the same time – Usually in exchange for money – In IT usually information – Service providers and consumers – Service provision as opposed to hierarchical steering (with commands) – Inside vs. outside
“Market metaphor” for flexible solutions to resource allocation problems
Design perspectives towards the organization
External perspective: the organization as an agent or component Internal perspective: the organization as an environment or system 8
PA partners: the Immigration & Naturalization Service A fine example of the ambiguous nature of services Policy reacts to events worldwide
Horizontalization of residence permit monitoring enforced self-regulation by network partners o
Employers
o
Schools
o
family members
PA partners: the Tax & Customs Administration (DTCA) Yet another fine example of the ambiguous nature of services
Worldwide tax competition Horizontalization of financial transaction monitoring Network partners o bookkeeping software developers o employers o accountants o financial services providers
Innovative concepts in Agile
Policy & environment as design constraints & reasons for change: mapping the design space for agile implementation of public administration services Happy flow & hard cases (noncompliance, legal effects, cost effects) Agent role approach to the knowledge acquisition bottleneck in public administration Innovative concepts for MAS development Agent roles & problem solving cycle
Overzicht en voortgangsrapportage
Alexander Boer
[email protected]
Overview
Status of the project Summary of old results New results since last meeting
Connections with other developments Research agenda
Status of the project
PhD theses Staff issues Progress of the project
Publications & Scientific impact Impact in society
Other developments Outlook
Status of the project
PhD theses – Legal aspect: Saskia (& successor Max) have left us
– CAS aspect: Yiwei gives a presentation
Staff issues – Replacement for Saskia starts after the summer (Italian) – Additional funds from IND to allow our new student to finish a PhD thesis
Progress of the project – No serious tool development yet – Serious gaming: only a small informal test – Yiwei: input for (comparative) case study
Status of the project
Publications & scientific impact – CS & Law, eGovernment Jurix, ICAIL, COMPLAW papers, JEDEM article
– Knowledge acquisition EKAW best problem analysis paper, AO article invitation
– Business Information Systems & Compliance LIT paper
– New research proposals MAS for policy analysis & serious gaming as a KA approach
Status of the project
Publications & scientific impact (2) – Egovernment (Delft) Measuring process agility (ICEGOV paper)
– Service-oriented architecture Mapping RIF to BDI rules (IJSSOE, LNCS papers)
Impact in society – Continued work with IND and Belastingdienst – New projects with other public administration partners
Status of the project (Tom) Connections with other developments –
INDiGO
–
Real estate risk detection (Belastingdienst)
–
Frame-based modeling of sources of law (Kadaster)
–
KAAS
Research agenda –
Agent role coordination problem
–
UI abstractions (design patterns) for agent roles Plans, rules, events
MAS configuration/scenario definition
–
Feedback from MAS simulation & evaluation model for design
–
Serious gaming
Summary of old results
Interfacing sources of law to rules & MetaLex Mapping business rules (RIF) to BDI (AgentSpeak/Jason) Layers of reality Layered generic problem solving model for administrative organizations
From sources of law to implementation in context
Source & metadata (MetaLex)
Model sentences & concepts (Automated parsing)
Business rules (RIF, SVBR)
Agent role (BDI rules)
Wat willen we weten van wet- en regelgeving? (Saskia)
Gestandaardiseerde metadata • zowel technisch (open standaarden) • als inhoudelijk (ontology) •toepasbaarheid in de tijd te bepalen: lex posterior principe en aanverwante patronen •uitoefening regelgevende bevoegdheid, mandatering en delegatie van regelgevende bevoegdheid om rangorde te bepalen: lex superior principe •Lifecycle van de rechtsbron beschreven als gebeurtenissen/handelingen
Wat willen we weten van wet- en regelgeving? (Saskia)
De inhoudelijke tekst • Terugkerende modelzinnen •Vertaling modelzin naar ontwerppatroon
• Terugkerende begrippen •Wanneer betekent X hetzelfde en wanneer iets anders? •Evolutie van begrippen (conceptual drift)
• Hoofdregels en uitzonderingen •Lex specialis principe: het specifiek bepaalde gaat boven het algemene •Wanneer zijn twee regels logisch strijdig mbt. een geval •Valt dit uit modelzinnen te halen?
Drie kennisdomeinen (uit het Agile project)
Drie kennisdomeinen en veranderingen
Drie kennisdomeinen en veranderingen
Drie kennisdomeinen en veranderingen
Drie kennisdomeinen en veranderingen
Drie kennisdomeinen en veranderingen
Probleemoplossen gegeneraliseerd Generalized problem solving feedback cycle
kennisbronnen
kennisbronnen
Terugkoppeling van problemen naar de wetgever Monitoring-processen Op drie abstractieniveas
Van de regelgever naar de werkvloer Productieprocessen op 3 abstractieniveaus
Externe invloeden op regelgeving Implementeren regelgeving
Externe factoren die leiden tot reorganisatie en innovatie Autonome innovatie
New results since last meeting
Making basiswettenbestand metadata accessible as MetaLex/RDF (Rinke) Agent roles as KA metaphor Diagnosis & coordination in agent rolebased MAS KA as serious gaming
Programma van vandaag 14:00-14:30 Voortgangsrapportage en overzicht van Agile project (Alexander Boer) 14:30-15:00 A service-oriented architecture for agility (Yiwei Gong, engels) 15:00-15:30 The MetaLex Document Server (Rinke Hoekstra) 15:30-15:45 Pauze 15:45-16:30 Kennisacquisitie voor ontwerp en diagnose (Alexander Boer) 16:30-17:00 Agile in groter verband & de toekomst (Tom van Engers) 17:00 Een drankje
