DAFTAR PUSTAKA Akridge, J.T. and T.W. Hertel. 1986. "Multiproduct Cost Relationship for Retail Fertiiizer Plants". Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 68 : 928938. Amang, B. 1995. Kebijaksanaan Pemasaran dan Harga Gula di Indonesia. PT. Dhafrna Karsa Utama. Jakarta. Anwar, E. 1992. Prospek Masa Depan lndustri Gula : Ditinjau dari Kebijsksanaan Sosial Ekonomi, Teknologi clan Sistem Kelembagaan. Seminar Prospek lndustri GulaIPemanis. Pusat Penelitian Perusahaan Perkebunan Gula. Azzam, AM. 1998. "Testing for Vertical Economies of Scope: An Example from U.S. Pig Production". J. Agr. Econ. 49 : 427-433. Ball,
E. V. 1988. "Modelling Supply Response in a Framework". Arner. J. Agr. Econ. 70 : 813825.
Multiproduct
Baumol, W.J., Panzar, J.C. and Willig, R.O. 1982. Contestable Markets and the Theory of industry Structure. New York : Harcourt Brace Jovanovich. Beattie, B.R. and C.R. Taylor. 1985. The Economics of Production. John Wiley & Sons. New York. Berndt, E.R. 1991. Practice of Econometrics : Classic and Contemporary. Addison Wesley Publishing Company. Massachusetts. Besley, R., T. Young and D. Colman. 1987. "A System Aproach to Modelling Suppty Equations in Agriculture". Int. J. Agr. Econ. : 151-166. Binswanger, H.P. 1974. "A Cost Function Approach to the Measurement of Elasticit~es of Factor Demand and Elasticities of Distribution". Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 56 : 377-386. Breusch,T.S., and A.R. Pagan. 1980. "Lagrange Multiplier Test and Its Application to Model Specification in Econometrics". Review Economic Studies 47 : 239-253. Chambers, R.G. 1988. Applied Production Analysis : A Dual Approach. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Chambers, R.G. and R.E. Just. 1989. "Estimating Technologies". Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 71:980-995.
Multi-output
Chand, R. and J.L. Kaul. 4986. "A Note on the Use of the Cobb-Douglass Profit Fundion". Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 68 : t62-164. Christensen, L.R., D.W. Jorgenson and L.L. Lau-1973. "Transcendental Logarithmic Production Frontiers". Rev. Econ. Stat. 55 : 28-45. Christensen, L.R. and W. H. Green. 1976. "Economic of Scale in U.S. Electric Power Generator". Journal of Political Economics 84 : 655 - 676. Comejo, J.F., C.M. Gempesaw II, J.G. Elterich and S.E. Stefanou. 1992. "Dynamic Measure of Scope and Scale Economies : An Application to German Agriculturen.Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 74 : 329-342. Debertin, D.L. 1986. Agricultural Production Publishing Company. New York.
Economics.
Macmillan
Dewa, K.S.S. 1996. "The Measurement of Total Factor Productivity Growth using Production Frontier : A Case of lnigated Rice Farming in West Java". Jurnal Agro Ekonorni 15 : 1-19. Dibyo Prabowo. 1978. "Penghijauan dan Pemanfaafan Air: Kasus dl DAS Solo Hulu". Prisma 8 : 70-76. Djojosubroto, D.I. 1995. Masalah Gula di Tengah Dinamika Ekonomi Indonesia. Seminar Pergulaan Nasional dalam Rangka Menghadapi Perdagangan Bebas. Badan Litbang Departemen Pertanian dan Yayasan Sacharosa. Jakarta. Erwidodo. 1990. Panel Data Analysis of Farm Levet Efficiency, Input Demand and Output Supply of Rice Farming in West Java, Indonesia. Ph.D. Thesis. Michigan University. Falcon, W.P., W.O. Jones and S.R. Pearson. 1986. Ekonomi Ubikayu di Jawa. Penerbit Sinar Harapan. Jakarta. Ferrantino, M.J., G.D. Ferrier and C.B. Linvill. 1994. Organizational Form and Efficiency: Evidence From Indian Sugar Manufacturing. U.S. International Trade Commission Office of Economics. Washington. Gabriel, K. R. 1971. The Biplot Graffic Display of Matrices with Application to Principle Component Analysis. Biometrika 58 : 345-467.
Gonarsyah, I., S. Hartoyo, A. Susmiadi. 1991. Keragaan lnpres 911975 dan Prospek Pengembangan Perkebunan Nasional. Makalah Seminar P3GI. Gujarati, D.N. 1988. Basic Econometrics. Mc Graw-Hill International Edition. New York. Gunawan, M. 1988. Adoption and Bias of New Agricultural Innovation in Jawa Barat, Indonesia. Ph.D. Thesis. University af Minnesota. Hartoyo, S. 1994. Pengaruh lnfrastruktur terhadap Penawaran Tanaman Pangan di Jawa : Pendekatan Multi-input Multioutput. Disertasi Doktor. Program Pascasarjana, lnstitut Pertanian Bogor. Henderson, J. M., and R. E, Quandt. 1980. Microeconomic Theory : A Mathematical Approach. Singapore : Mc Graw Hill Book Co. Third Edition. Intriligator, M. D. 1978. Econometric Models. Techniques Applications. Prentice-Half, Inc. New Jersey.
and
Johnson, J. W. and Wichem. 1993. Applied Multivariate Analysis. John Wley and Sons. New York. Jollife, L.T. 1986. Principle Component Analysis. Springer-Verlay. New York. Jonasson, L. 1997. "A Policy Oriented Multi-input and Multi-output Measure of Overall Efficiency and its Decomposition". J. Agr. Econ. 48 : 52-64. Jorgenson, D. W. and L.J. Lau. 1974. "The Duality of Technology and Economic Behaviour". Review of Economic Studies 41 : 181 - 200. Koestono. 1991. Kemampuan lndustri Gula Pasir untuk Mencapai Swasembada. Majalah Pangan 8 (2). Bulog. Jakarta. Koutsoyiannis, A. 1977. Theory of Econometrics : An Introductory Exposition of Econometric Methods. Second Edition. Macmillan Education Ltd. London. Lau. L. J. 1972. "Profit Functions of Technologies with Multiple Inputs and Outputs". Rev. Econ. Stat. 54 : 281-289. . 1976. "A Characterization of the Normalized Restricted Profit
Function". Journal of Economic Theory 12 : 137-163.
~
Lau, L. J. 1978. Application of Profit Function M. Fuss and Mc Fadden (eds.), Production Economics : A Dual Approach to Theory and Application, 1 : 133-216. Amsterdam : North-Holland Publishing Co. Lau, L. J. and P. A. Yotopoutos. 1972. "Profit, Supply Demand Functions". Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 54 : 1?-18.
and Factor
Lopez, R. E. 1984. "Estimating Substitution and Expansion Effects Using a Profit Function Framework". Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 66 : 358-367. . 1985. 'Structural
Implication of A Class of Flexibte Functional Form for Profit Functions". Int. Econ. Rev. 26 : 593-601.
Mackie, J.A.C. and W.J. O'Malley. 1988. "Productivity Decline in the Java Sugar Industry from an Olsonian Perspective, in Comparative Studies in Society and History". An International Quarterly of Cambridge University Press 30 : 725-749. Moore, M.R., N.R. Gollehon and M. B. Carey. 1994. "Multicrop Production Decisions in Western Irrigated Agriculture : The Role of Water Price". Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 76 : 859-874. Mosher, A. T. q965. Menggerakkan dan Membangun Pertanian. Saduran oleh S. Krisnadhi dan B. Samad. Jakarta: C.V. Yasaguna. Mubyarto dan Daryanti. 1991. Gula: Kajian Sosial Ekonomi. Aditya Media, Yogyakarta. Mulyana, A. 1998. Keragaan Penawaran dan Permintaan Beras Indonesia dan Prospek Swasembada Menuju Era Perdagangan Bebas : Suatu Analisis Simulasi. Disertasi Doktor. Program Pascasarjana lnstitut Pertanian Bogor. Nelson, G. C. and M. Panggabean. 1991. "The Costs of Indonesian Sugar Policy". Arner. J. Agr. Econ. 73 : 703-712. Pakpahan, A. 1982. Analisis Fungsi Produksi Usahatani untuk Menunjang Pengembangan Daerah Aliran Sungai Cimanuk. Jurnal Agro Ekonomi 1 : 2849. Panggabean, M. 1995. Quo Vadis lndustri Gula di Jawa. Seminar Pergulaan Nasional dalam Rangka Menghadapi Perdagangan Bebas. Badan Litbang Departemen Pertanian dan Yayasan Sacharosa. Jakarta.
Pindyck, R.S. and D. L. Rubinfeld. 1991. Econometric Models and Econometric Forecasts. Third Edition. Mc Graw-Hill Inc. New York. Pope, R.D. and A. Hallam. 1988. "Separability Testing in Production Economics". Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 70 : 142-152. Prabowo, D. 1996. Monitoring dan Analisa Prospek lndustri Gula di Jawa. Center for Policy and Implementation Studies (CPIS). Jakarta. Pusat Penelitian Perusahaan Perkebunan Gula Indonesia (P3Gf). 1997. lkhtisar Angka Perusahaan Masa Giling 4980-1997. 1992. Pemikiran Arah Penefitian dan Pengembangan Sub SeMor Perkebunan Gula pada Pembangunan Jangka Panjang Tahap I1 dan Khususnya Repelita VI. Pusat Penelitian Perkebunan Gula Indonesia. Pasuruan. PSE dan P3GI. 2996. Dinamika Ekonomi Tebu Rakyat dan lndustri Gula Indonesia. Studi Panel Petani Tebu. PSE dan P3GI Buku II.Bogor. Ray, S.C. 1982. "A Translog Cost Function Analysis of U.S. Agriculture, 1939 - 77". Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 64 : 490-498. Rosegrant, M.W., F. Kasryno, L.A. Gonzales, C.A. Rasahan and Y. Saerfudin. 1987. Price and lnvestment Policies in the Indonesian Food Crop Sector, IFPRI, Washington D.C., and CASER, Bogor. Rossi, N. 1984. "The Estimation of Product Supply and Input Demand by The Differential Approach. Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 66 : 368375. Rusastra, I. W., A. Supanto dan A.N. Amsari. 1999. Keunggulan Komparatif, Struktur Proteksi dan Perdagangan lnternasional Gula Indonesia. Dalam Ekonomi Gula di Indonesia, hal. 421 - 475. Disuntincl oleh Sawit, M.H, P. Suhamo dan A. Rachman. Penerbit lnstitut Pertenian Bogor. Salmon, D. C. 1984. An Evaluation of Investment in Agricultural Research in Indonesia, 1965-1977. Ph. D Thesis. Faculty of The Graduate School of The University of Minnesota. Sawit, M. H. 1985. Fungsi Respon dan Fungsi Permintaan Tenaga Kerja. Jurnal Agro Ekonomi 4 : 1-10. Sawit, M. H.,and D.T. O'Brien. 1991. Multiple Output Model of West Javanese Rice Farmers. Working Paper Series. Department of Economics, University of Wollongong.
Sawit. M.H. 1993. A Farm Household Model for Rural Households of West Java, Indonesia. Ph. D. Dissertation. Department of Economics, The University of Wollongong, New South Wales.
. 1998. Dua Puluh Dua Tahun Program TRI di Jawa. Agro ) : 37-56. Ekonometrika XXVlll (-l
Sawit, M.H., P. Suhamo dan A. Rachman. 1999. Ekonomi Gula di Indonesia. Penerbit lnstitut Pertanian Bogor. Sekretariat Dewan Gula Indonesia. 1997. Rencana Operasional Pemecahan Permasalahan lndustri Gula di Indonesia. Shumway, C.R. 1983. "Supply, Demand and Technology in a Multiproduct Industry: Texas Field Crops". Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 65 : 748-760. Shumway, C.R., R.D. Pope and E.K. Nash. 1984. "Allocatable Fixed Inputs and Jointness in Agricultural Production : Implication for Economic Modelling". Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 66 : 72-78. Shumway, C.R., and W.P. Alexander. 1988. "Agricultural Product Supplies and lnput Demands : Regional Comparisons". Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 70 : 153-161. Shumway, C.R.,R.R. Saez and P.E. Gottret. 1988. "Multiproduct Supply and lnput Demand in U.S. Agriculture". Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 70 : 320337. Sidhu, S.S., and C. A. Baanante. 1981. "Estimating Farm-Level lnput Demand and Wheat Supply in the Indian Punjab Using a Translog Profit Function". Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 63 : 237-246. Silberberg, E. 1981. The Structure of Economics. A Mathematical of Analysis. Auckland : Mc Graw Hill International Book Company. Simatupang, P. 1987. Fungsi Keuntungan : Landasan Teori Terapannya. Pusat Penelitian Agro Ekonomi, Bogor.
dan
. 1988. Penentuan Ekonomi Skala Usaha dengan Fungsi Keuntungan : Landasan Teoritis dengan Contoh Fungsi CobbDouglass dan Translog. Jumal Agro Ekonomi, 7:l-16. Pusat Penelitian Agro Ekonorni, Badan Penelitian dan Pengembangan Pertanian. Departemen Pertanian.
Simatupang, P., dan Mewa. 1987. Efisiensi Teknis Usahatani Kubis di Desa Galagah, Surnatera Barat. Pusat Penelitian Agro Ekonomi, Mimeo. Simatupang, P., I.W. Rusastra and B. lrawan (1990). Economic Incentives and Comparative Advantage in Livestock and Feedstuff Production : A Methodological Introduction, in Kasryno, F. and P. Simatupang (Eds.), Comparative Advantage and Production Structures of Livestock and Feedstuff Subsectors in Indonesia. CASER, AARD. Bogor. Sirnatupang, P., A. Rachman dan L. Peiitasari. 1999. Gula Dalam Kebijaksanaan Pangan Nasional : Analisis Historis. hal. 476 - 534. Dalam Ekonomi Gula di Indonesia. Disuntina oleh Sawit, M.H., P. Suhamo #an A. Rachman. Penerbit lnstitut Pertanian Bogor. Sinaga, R.S. 1975. A Normative Sugar Cane Supply Function and Optimum Land Rental Plan for A Proposed Expansion of the Sragi Sugar Factory in Central Java Indonesia. Ph.D. Dissertation. Montana State University. Soentoro, N. lndarto dan A.M.S. Ali. 1999. Usaha Tani dan Tebu Rakyat lntensifikasi di Jawa. Dalam Ekonomi Gula di Indonesia. Disunting oleh Sawit, M.H, P. Suharno dan A. Rachman. Penerbit lnstitut Pertanian Bogor. Soetrisno, N. 1984. Farmers, Millers and Sugar Production in Indonesia. Ph.D. Dissertation. University of the Phillippines. . 1991. Penelitian Tentang lndustri Pengolahan Gula Pasir di
Indonesia. BULOG. Jakarta. Squires, D. 7987. "Long-Run Profit functions for Multiproduct Firms". Arner. J. Agr. Econ. 69 : 558-569. Statistik Bulog 1969-1991, 1983-1993, 1986-1996. Badan Urusan Logistik. Jakarta. Sugianto, T. 1985. "Production Efficiency of Cauliflower (Brassica Oleracca var Botrytys) at Ciarutan, West Java, Indonesia". Jurnal Agro Ekonomi 4 : 27-39. Suryana, A. 1987. "Keterbatasan Fungsi Cobb-Douglass dalarn Pendugaan Elastisitas Permintaan input". Jurnal Agro Ekonomi 6 : 19-28.
Timmer, P. q987. The Corn Economy of Indonesia. Comell University Press, Ithaca. Weaver, R.D. 1983. "Multi-Input, Multi-Output Production Choices and Technology in the U.S. Wheat Region". Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 65 : 45-56. Wbisono, C. 1995. Gula dari Era Oei Tiong Ham Concern ke Era Robert Kuok. Seminar Pergulaan Nasional dalam Rangka Menghadapi Perdagangan Bebas. Badan Litbang Departemen Pertanian dan Yayasan Sacharosa. Jakarta. World Bank. 1982. Indonesia : Policy Options and Strategies for Major Food Crops. East Asia and Pasific Regional Office. Report No. 36866-IND. Zellner, A. (1963). "Estimations of Seemingly Unrelated Regressions : Some Exact Finite Sample Results". J. Arner. Stat. Ass. 58 : 977-992.
Lampiran Tabel 1.
No
Pabrik Gula
1
Asembagus Panji Olean Wringinanom Prajekan De Maas Semboro Pajarakan Gending Jatiroto Wonolangan Kedawung Kebon Agung Krebet Baru I Krebet Baru I1 Candi Baru Krian Watutulis Tulangan Krembung Gempolkrep Cukir Jombang Baru ~gadirejo Pesantren Baru
2 3
4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11
12
13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20
1
21
1 22
23 24 25
I d e n t i f i k a s i Pabrik Gula berdasarkan Tahun Pendirian dan Jumlah Hari Giling, Jam Berhenti Giling s e r t a Kapasitas Giling Periode 1990-1997.
Tahun Didirikan
Hari Giling
Jml
Jan berhenti terhadap tot 1 jam gi I diluar Hari Jumlah Libur
.ing/24 jam
lain
I I
Terhitung jam berhenti (ton) 2 323.4 1 449.2 938.0 1 124.9 2 627.8 805.2 4 263.7 1 106.5
1 336.9 5 660.7 1 258.2
2 866.4
3 329.6
2 851.5 3 518.9 1 626.2
1 065.4
1 955.6 1 346.1 1 379.3 5 300.4
2 379.1
1 937.4 4 860.0 5 260.6
Lampiran Tabel 1. Lanjutan.
No
26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51
Pabrik Gula
Moj opanggung Merican Lestari Rejoagung Baru Kanigoro Pagottan Rejosari Pumodadi Sudhono Mojo Tasi lanadu Colomadu Ceper Baru Gondang Baru Madukismo Kalibagor Trangkil Pakis Baru Rendeng Cepiring Sragi Sumberharj o Pangka Jatibarang Banjaratma Tersana Baru
Tahun Didirikan
Jml Hari Giling
1852 1918 1909 1954 1894 1884 1890 1832 1884 1883 1871 1871 1927 1860 1955 1839 1835 1825 1840 1835 1836 1911 1836 1842 1909 1937
142 158 143 123 112 127 134 135 135 123 115 86 111 122 137 99 166 153 133 103 152 139 121 93 104 114
Jumlah
7.95 6.75 8.30 7.85 12.98 16.29 4.60 4.11 5.41 17.32 10.44 16.92 13.64 9.72 3.95 28.62 5.53 8.66 6.69 22.27 21.14 11.19 12.67 9.56 7.16 8.48
Jam berhenti % jam g i l i n g Sebab d i l u a r pabrik Sebab dalam Kurang Hari Lainpabrik Tebu Libur lain
4.08 3.18 5.33 5.48 11.63 5.20 1.53 3.00 1.80 5.89 3.74 6.71 5.63 7.13 2.45 28.05 5.25 7.66 5.73 3.43 12.59 8.75 7.45 4.07 2.97 3.62
3.85 3.43 2.95 2.37 1.35 11.09 3.07
0.02 0.14 0.02
1.11 3.61 11.43 6.70 10.21 8.01 2.59 1.50 0.57 0.28 1.00 0.96 18.58 7.05 0.93 5.22 5.42 4.19 4.59
0.14
0.26 1.36 1.51 0.07 0.27
Kapasitas giling/24 jam Terhitung Tak t e r h i t u n g jam berhenti jam berhenti (ton) (ton)
2 698.9 2 707.1 3 778.7 4 921.4 1 775.7 2 810.7 1 996.8 2 011.1 2 343.8 2 655.6 3 229.7 1 084.6 1 430.5 1 500.3 2 988.0 1 051.5 3 165.7 3 232.0 2 690.6 1 807.6 3 062.2 1 793.5 1 662.7 1 899.7 1 470.1 3 002.6
2 2 3 4 1 2 1 1 2 2 2
1 1 2 3 2 2 1 2 1 1 1 1 2
500.1 536.0 489.1 562.6 571.6 603.4 909.0 931.8 223.5 263.6 924.4 927.6 258.8 367.3 874.4 817.6 000.0 974.8 521.8 478.4 527.7 613.0 475.7 735.0 372.0 768.0
Lampiran Tabel 1. Lanjutan. Jam berhenti % jam giling Sebab diluar pabrik Sebab dalam Kurang Hari Lainpabrik Libur Tebu lain
Tahun Didirikan
Jml Hari Giling
Jumlah
Karangsuwung Sindanglaut Gempol Jatiwangi Kadhipaten Bone Gunung Madu Jatitujuh Sei Semayang Kuala Madu Cintamanis Bungamayang Subang Takalar Camming Pelaihari Gula Putih Mataram 69 Naga Manis 70 Sweet Indo
1896 1896 1847 1896 1876 1962 1978 1980 1982 1983 1984 1984 1982 1981 1981 . 1981
104 101
11.40 10.99
10.84 5.36
0.56 5.60
38 75 95 162 87 140 153 156 130 113 105 95 99
10.36 17.24 33.94 12.98 19.82 49.86 28.29 20.03 21.37 11.62 8.37 43.20 30.07
5.72 8.43 27.32 1.15 15.11 3.94 2.02 6.13 9.30 9.48 8.25 12.19 5.31
4.64 8.81 6.62 4.88 4.71 34.55 17.87 13.90 12.07 2.14 0.12 31.01 24.76
1985 1992
165 51
12.87 42.64
2.84 76.01
4.61 8
LamPUng
1995
112
23.54
12.83
9.96
No
Pabrik Gula
52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68
0.03
Kapasitas giling/24 jam Tak terhitung Terhitung jam berhenti jam berhenti (ton) (ton) 1 837.4 1 314.2 1 1 2 11 3 4 4 4 5 2 2 2 4
049.3 127.6 318.7 396.0 740.9 004.0 078.0 884.7 636.3 933.5 974.8 503.5 352.1
1 6494 1 184.0
1 9 3 2 3 4 4 2 2 1 3
950.8 961.5 731.2 918.0 122.1 891.0 401.0 069.7 644.0 628.2 745.0 748.2 346.1
0.13
6.82
8.82 8.40
2.55
0.09
5.33 5.75
11 047.0 3 311.9
9 852.7 633.7
0.75
8 482.2
6 865.9
Lampiran Tabel 3. Program SAS untuk Menduga Parameter Fungsi Biaya Translog a.
Program tahapan data
/ + + + *Program SAS 6.12 for Windows *+**/ /+*** Tahapan Mempersiapkan Data * * * / libname victor 'c: \user\Victor Siagian (EPN99)' ; option nonumber nodate; title ' '; proc format; value fkps low-<3000 = 'Rendah' 3000-<6000= 'Sedang' 6000-high = 'Tinggi'; run ; / + Konversi nilai nominal ke nilai riil + /
data gab; set victor.data1; format kps fkps ; if n->546 then delete; label x1 = 'Tebu giling (ton)' x2 = 'Bahan bakar (kg)' x3 = 'Tenaga kerja (orang)' pxl = 'Harga tebu giling (Rp/kg)' px2 = 'Harga Bahan bakar (Rp/kg) ' px3 = 'Upah Tenaga kerja (Rp/tahun)' cxl = 'Biaya tebu giling (x Rp 1000) ' cx2 = 'Biaya Bahan bakar ( x Rp 1000)' cx3 = 'Biaya Tenaga kerja (x Rp 1000) ' zl = 'Biaya Management (x Rp 1000) ' 22 = 'Biaya penyusutan (x Rp 1000) ' ql = 'Produksi Gula (ton)' = 'Produksi tetes (ton)' q2 = 'Harga Gula (Rp/kg)' pql pq2 = 'Harga tetes (Rp/kg)' trql = 'Penerimaan Gula (x Rp. 1000) ' trq2 = 'Penerimaan tetes (x Rp. 1000)' kc = 'Total biaya ( x Rp. 1000) ' phi = 'Laba/Rugi (x Rp. 1000) ' t = 'Trend Teknologi' dl = 'Dummy Status (l=Swasta, O=BUMN)' d2 = 'D-y kapasitas (l=Rendah. O=lainnya)' d3 - 'D -y kapasitas (l=sedang, O=lainnya) ' d4 = 'Dummy lokasi (O=luar Jawa, l=Jawa) ' d5 = 'Dummy Proses Pabriksasi (O=Karbonatasi, l=Sulfatasi)' d6 = 'Dummy rendemen (O=lebih kecil 7%. l=sama atau lebih besar 7%) = 'Kapasitas'; kps run;
.
/ * Manipulasi Data * / data victor. dtl; set gab;
/***
Total Biaya Variabel * * * /
/*** Share ***/ stebu=cxl/biaya; sbakar=cxZ/biaya; stenaga=cx3/biaya; sgula=trql/biaya; stetes=trq2/biaya;
/*** Harga Input htebu=pxl ; hbakar=px2; htenaga=px3/12; hgula=pql; htetes=pq2;
***/
/ * * Transformasi Logaritma lb=log (biaya); hxl=log (htebu); hxZ=log (hbakar); hx3=log (htenaga); hyl=log [hgula); hyZ=log (htetes); yl=log (qll ; y2=log ( q2 l ; m=log(zl) ; s=log ( 22 ) ; / * * Variabel Interaksi * * * /
***/
Label = 'Log. h a r g a t e b u g i l i n g ' hxl hx2 = 'Log. harga Bahan b a k a r ' hx3 = 'Log. upah Tenaga k e r j a ' yl = 'Log. p r o d u k s i Gula' y2 = 'Log. p r o d u k s i t e t e s ' = 'Log. h a r g a Gula' hyl = 'Log. h a r g a t e t e s ' hy2 m = 'Log. b i a y a Management' s = 'Log. b i a y a p e n y u s u t a n ' lb = 'Log. t o t a l b i a y a V a r i a b e l ' t = 'Tahun' stebu = 'Share tebu' sbakar= ' S h a r e bahan b a k a r ' stenaga= 'Share tenaga k e r j a ' = 'Share gula' sgula s t e t e s = 'Share t e t e s ' dl - 'Dummy S t a t u s ( l = S w a s t a , O=BUMN) ' d2 = 'Dummy k a p a s i t a s (l=Rendah, O=lainnya) ' d3 = 'Dummy k a p a s i t a s (l=Sedang, O=lainnya) ' d4 = 'Dummy l o k a s i (O=luar Jawa, l = J a w a ) ' d5 = 'Dummy P r o s e s P a b r i k s a s i (O=Karbonatasi, l = S u l f a t a s i ) ' ; d6 = 'Dummy rendemen (O=lebih k e c i l 7 8 , l=sama a t a u l e b i h b e s a r 7 % ) run;
/**** b.
Akhir P r o s e s Data
*****/
Program pendugaan p a r a m e t e r rnemasukkan dummy Dl
/***** /*****
f u n g s i b i a y a t r a n s l o g dengan
Program SAS 6.12 f o r windows * * * * / Tahapan Pembentukan Fungsi Biaya T r a n s l o g
libname v i c t o r
'c:\user\Victor
Siagian
****/
(EPN99)';
o p t i o n nonumber nodate; t i t l e ' '; data d t ; s e t victor.dt1; run : options ls=75;
T i t l e 1 ' H a s i l A n a l i s i s Fungsi B i a y a ' ; T i t l e 2 ' F u n g s i Biaya T r a n s l o g K u a d r a t i k dengan R e s t r i k s i
(Dl)';
p r o c s y s l i n d a t a c d t sur s i m p l e ; Eql: model l b = y l y2 h x l hx2 hx3 m s y l y l y2y2 yly2 h x l h x l hxlhx2 hxlhx3 hx2hx2 hx2hx3 hx3hx3 mm ss ms y l h x l ylhx2 y l h x 3 y2hxl y2hx2 y2hx3 ylm y l s y2m y2s hxlm h x l s hx2m hx2s hx3m hx3s t t t t h x l thx2 t h x 3 t y l t y 2 d l h x l d l h x 2 d l h x 3 dl/dw;
Eq2: model Stebu=yl y2 hxl hx2 hx3 m s t dl; Eq3: model Sbakar=yl y2 hxl hx2 hx3 m s t dl; srestrict eql.hxl+eql.hx2+eql~h~3+eql.dlhxl+eql~dlhx2+eql~dlhx3=l; srestrict eq2.hxl+eq2.hx2+eq2-hx3=0, eq3.hxl+eq3.hx2+eq3.hx3=0, eql.ylhxl+eql.ylhx2+eql.ylhx3=0, eql. y2hxl+eql. y2hx2feql. y2hx3=O0 eql.hxls+eql.hx2s+eql.h~3s=O, eql.hxlm+eql.hx2m+eql.hx3m=0, eql.thxl+eql.thx2+eql.thx3=0. eql.dlhxl+eql.dlhx2+eql.dlhx3=0: srestrict eql.hxl=eqZ.intercept, eql.hxZ=eq3.intercept; srestrict eql.ylhxl=eqZ.yl, eql.y2hxl=eq2.y2, eql hxlhxl=eq2. hxl, eql.hxlhx2=eq2,hx2, eql.hxlhx3=eq2. hx3, eql.hxlm=eq2 .m, eql.hxls=eqZ.s, eql.thxl=eqZ.t, eql dlhxl=eq2 .dl, eql.ylhxZ=eq3.y1, eql.y2hx2=eq3.y 2 , eql.hxlhx2=eq3.hxl, eql.hx2hxZ=eq3.hx2, eql.hxZhx3=eq3.hx3, eql.hxZm=eq3.m, eql. hxZs=eq3. s, eql.thx2=eq3.t, eql.dlhxZ=eq3.d1;
.
.
/ * * * * Pengujian Dummy Gabungan (Slope) * * * * / sTest Eql.dlhxl=Eql.dlhx2=O/print; run;
c.
Program pendugaan parameter fungsi biaya translog dengan memasukkan dummy D2 & D3
Title2 'Fungsi Biaya Translog Kuadratik dengan Restriksi (D2
&
D3)';
proc syslin data=dt sur; Eql: model lb=yl y2 hxl hx2 hx3 m s ylyl y2y2 yly2 hxlhxl hxlhx2 hxlhx3 hx2hx2 hx2hx3 hx3hx3 mm ss ms ylhxl ylhx2 ylhx3 y2hxl y2hx2 y2hx3 ylm yls y2m y2s hxlm hxls hx2m hx2s hx3m hx3s t tt thxl thx2 thx3 tyl ty2 d2hxl d2hx2 d2hx3 d3hxl d3hx2 d3hx3 d2 d3/dw; Eq2: model Stebu=yl y2 hxl hx2 hx3 m s t d2 d3; Eq3: model Sbakar=yl y2 hxl hx2 hx3 m s t d2 d3; srestrict e q l . h x l + e q l . h x 2 + e q l ~ h x 3 + e q l . d 2 h x 2 + e q l . d 2 h x 3 + eql.d3hxl+eql.d3hx2+eql~d3hx3=1; srestrict eq2.hxl+eq2.hx2+eqZ.h~3=0. eq3.hxl+eq3.hxZ+eq3.h~3=0, eql.ylhxl+eql.ylhx2+eq1.y1hx3=0, eql.y2hxl+eql.y2hx2+eql1y2hx3=0,
eql.hxls+eql.hx2s+eql.h~3s=O, eql.hxlm+eql.hx2rn+eql.h~3m=O, eql.thxl+eql.thx2+eql.thx3=0, eql.d2hxl+eql.d2hx2+eql. d2hx3=0, eql.d3hxl+eql.d3hx2+eql.d3hx3=0; srestrict eql.hxl=eq2.interceptr eql.hx2=eq3.intercept; srestrict eql.ylhxl=eq2.yl, eql.y2hxl=eqZ.y2, eql.hxlhxl=eq2.hxl, eql.hxlhx2=eq2.hx2, eql.hxlhx3=eq2.hx3, eql.hxlm=eqZ.m, eql.hxls=eq2.s, eql.thxl=eq2.t, eql.d2hxl=eq2.d2, eql.d3hxl=eq2.d3, eql.ylhxZ=eq3.y1, eql y2hx2=eq3.y2, eql.hxlhx2=eq3.hxl, eql.hx2hx2=eq3.hx2, eql.hxZhx3=eq3.hx3, eql.hxZm=eq3.m, eql.hx2s=eq3.s, eql thxZ=eq3. t, eql.d2hx2=eq3.d2, eql.d3hx2=eq3.d3; / * * * * Pengujian Dummy Gabungan (Slope) * * * * / sTest Eql.d2hxl=Eql.d2hx2=0, Eql.d3hxl=Eql.d3hx2=O/print; run :
. .
d.
Program pendugaan parameter fungsi biaya translog dengan memasukkan dummy D4
Title2 'Fungsi Biaya Translog Kuadratik dengan Restriksi (04)'; proc syslin data=dt sur; Eql: model lb=yl y2 hxl hx2 hx3 m s ylyl y2y2 yly2 hxlhxl hxlhx2 hxlhx3 hx2hx2 hx2hx3 hx3hx3 mm ss ms ylhxl ylhx2 ylhx3 y2hxl y2hx2 y2hx3 ylm yls y2m y2s hxlm hxls hx2m hx2s hx3m hx3s t tt thxl thx2 thx3 tyl ty2 dlhxl d4hx2 d4hx3 d4/dw; Eq2: model Stebu=yl y2 hxl hx2 hx3 m s t d4; Eq3: model Sbakar=yl y2 hxl hx2 hx3 m s t d4; srestrict eql.hxl+eql.hx2+eql.hx3+eql~d4h~1+eq1.d4hx2+eql.d4hx3=1; srestrict eq2.hxl+eq2.hx2+eq2.hx3=0, eq3.hxl+eq3.hx2+eq3.hx3=0, eql.ylhxl+eql.ylhx2+eql.ylhx3=0. eql.y2hxl+eql.y2hx2+eql~y2hx3=0, eql.hxls+eql.hx2s+eql.h~3s=O, eql.hxlm+eql.hx2m+eql.hx3m=O, eql.thxl+eql.thx2+eql.thx3=0, eql.d4hxl+eql.d4hx2+eql.d4hx3=0;
srestrict eql.hxl=eq2.intercept, eql.hxZ=eq3.intercept; srestrict eql.ylhxl=eq2.yl, eql.yZhxl=eqZ.y2,
.
.
eql hxlhxl=eq2 hxl, eql hxlhx2=eq2.hx2, eql.hxlhx3=eq2.hx3, eql hxlm=eq2 .m, eql.hxls=eqZ.s, eql thxl=eq2.t, eql d4hxl=eq2.d4, eql.ylhx2=eq3.yl. eql y2hx2=eq3.y2. eql.hxlhx2=eq3.hxl, eql.hxZhxZ=eq3.hx2, eql.hxZhx3=eq3.hx3, eql hx2m=eq3.m, eql hxZs=eq3. s, eql.thxZ=eq3.t, eql.d4hx2=eq3.d4;
. . . .
.
. .
/ * * * * Pengujian Durmny Gabungan {Slope) * * * * / s ~ e s tEql.d4hxl=Eql.d4hx2=O/~rint; run;
e.
Program pendugaan parameter fungsi biaya translog dengan memasukkan dummy D5
Title2 'Fungsi Biaya Translog Kuadratik dengan Restriksi (D5)';
proc syslin data=dt sur; Eql: model lb=yl y2 hxl hx2 hx3 m s ylyl y2y2 yly2 hxlhxl hxlhx2 hxlhx3 hx2hx2 hx2hx3 hx3hx3 mm ss ms ylhxl ylhx2 ylhx3 y2hxl y2hx2 y2hx3 ylm yls y2m y2s hxlm hxls hx2m hx2s hx3m hx3s t tt thzl thx2 thx3 tyl ty2 d5hxl d5hx2 d5hx3 d5/dw; Eq2: model Stebu=yl y2 hxl hx2 hx3 rn s t d5; Eq3: model Sbakar=yl y2 hxl hx2 hx3 m s t d5; srestrict eql.hxl+eql.hx2+eql.hx3+eql.d5hxl+eql.d5hx2+eql.d5hx3=1; srestrict eq2.hxl+eq2.hx2+eq2.hx3=0, eq3.hxl+eq3.hx2+eq3.hx3=0, eql.ylhxl+eql.ylhx2+eql.ylhx3=0, eql.y2hxl+eql.y2hx2+eql.y2hx3=0, eql.hxls+eql.hx2s+eql~hx3~=0, eql.hxlm+eql.hx2m+eql.h~3m=0, eql.thxl+eql.thx2+eql.thx3=0, eql.d5hxl+eql.d5hx2+eql.d5hx3=0; srestrict eql.hxl=eq2.intercepk, eql.hxZ=eq3.intercept; srestrict eql.ylhxl=eq2.yln eql y2hxl=eq2.y2, eql.hxlhxl=eq2.hxl, eql.hxlhx2=eq2.hx2, eql.hxlhx3=eq2.hx3, eql.hxlm=eq2.m. eql.hxls=eq2.s, eql.thxl=eqZ.t, eql.d5hxl=eqZ.d5,
.
.
eql ylhx2=eq3.yl, eql.y2hx2=eq3.y2, eql.hxlhxZ=eq3.hxl, eql hx2hx2=eq3.hx2, eql.hx2hx3=eq3.hx3, eql hx2m=eq3.m, eql.hx2s=eq3.s, eql.thxZ=eq3.t, eql.d5hx2=eq3.d5;
.
.
/**** Pengujian Dunnny Gabungan (Slope) ****/
run
f.
.Program pendugaan parameter fungsi biaya translog dengan memasukkan dummy D6
Title2 'Fungsi Biaya Translog Kuadratik dengan Restriksi (d6)'; proc syslin data=dt sur simple; Eql: model lb=yl y2 hxl hx2 hx3 m s ylyl y2y2 yly2 hxlhxl hxlhx2 hxlhx3 hx2hx2 hx2hx3 hx3hx3 mm ss ms ylhxl ylhx2 ylhx3 y2hx1 y2hx2 yZhx3 ylm yls y2m y2s hxlm hxls hx2m hx2s hx3m hx3s t tt thxl thx2 thx3 tyl ty2 d6hxl d6hx2 d6hx3 d6/dw; Eq2: model Stebu=yl y2 hxl hx2 hx3 m s t d6; Eq3: model Sbakar=yl y2 hxl hx2 hx3 m s t d6; srestrict eql.hxl+eql.hx2+eql.h~3=1; srestrict eq2.hxl+eq2.hxZ+eq2.h~3=0, eq3.hxl+eq3.hx2+eq3.h~3=0, eql.ylhxl+eql.ylhx2+eql.ylhx3=0, eql. y2hxl+eql.y2hx2+eql.y2hx3=0, eql.hxls+eql.hxZs+eql.h~3s=O, eql.hxlm+eql.hx2m+eql.hx3m=0, eql.thxl+eql.thx2+eql.thx3=0, eql.d6hxl+eql.d6hx2+eql.d6hx3=0; srestrict eql.hxl=eq2.intercept, eql.hx2=eq3.intercept; srestrict eql.ylhxl=eqZ.yl, eql y2hxl=eq2. y2, eql.hxlhxl=eq2.hxl, eql.hxlhx2=eq2.hx2, eql.hxlhx3=eqZ.hx3, eql hxlm=eq2.m, eql.hxls=eq2.s, eql.thxl=eqZ.t, eql.d6hxl=eq2.d6, eql.ylhxZ=eq3.y1, eql.yZhxZ=eq3.y2, eql.hxlhxZ=eq3.hxl, eql.hx2hxZ=eq3.hxZ, eql.hxZhx3=eq3.hx3, eql.hx2m=eq3 .m, eql.hx2s=eq3.s, eql.thx2=eq3.tr eql.d6hxZ=eq3.d6;
. .
/****
P e n g u j i a n Durmny G a b u n g a n
Joint:
s t e s t eql.ylyZ=O/print:
{Slope)
****/
run;
g.
Program pendugaan parameter f u n g s i b i a y a t r a n s l o g dengan memasukkan dummy gabungan Dl, D 4 dan 05
/***** /*****
Program SAS 6.12 for windows ****/ Tahapan Pembentukan Fungsi Biaya Translog
****/
libname victor 'c:\user\Victor Siagian (EPN99)'; option nonumber nodate ; title ' '; data dt; set victor.dt1; run; options 1s=75;
Title1 'Hasil Analisis Fungsi Biaya'; Title2 'Fungsi Biaya Translog Kuadratik dengan Restriksi
(Dl,D4,D5)';
proc syslin d a t a d t sur; Eql: model lb=yl y2 hxl hx2 hx3 m s ylyl y2y2 yly2 hxlhxl hxlhx2 hxlhx3 hx2hx2 hx2hx3 hx3hx3 nrm ss ms ylhxl ylhx2 ylhx3 y2hxl y2hx2 y2hx3 ylm yls y2m y2s hxlm hxls hx2m -2s hx3m hx3s t tt thxl thx2 thx3 tyl ty2 dlhxl dlhx2 dlhx3 d4hxl d4hx2 d4hx3 d5hx1 d5hx2 d5hx3 dlyl dly2 d4yl d4y2 d5yl d5y2 dlylyl dly2y2 dlyly2 d4ylyl d4y2y2 d4yly2 d5ylyl d5y2y2 d5yly2 dl d4 d5/dw; Eq2: model Stebuzyl y2 hxl hx2 hx3 m s t dl d4 d5; Eq3: model Sbakar=yl y2 hxl hx2 hx3 m s t dl d4 d5; srestrict eql.hxl+eql.hx2+eql.hx3+ eql.dlhxl+eql.dlhx2+eql.dlhx3+ eql.d4hxl+eql.d4hx2+eql.d4hx3+eql.d5hxl+eql.d5hx2+eql.d5hx3=1; srestrict eq2.hxlceq2.hx2+eq2.hx3=0, eq3.hxl+eq3.hxZ+eq3.h~3=0, eql.hxlhx3+eql.hx2hx3+eql.hx3hx3=0, eql. ylhxl+eql. ylhxZ+eql. ylhx3=0, eql. yZhxl+eql. y2hx2teql. y2hx3=0, eql .hxls+eql .hxZs+eql. hx3s=0, eql.hxlm+eql.hx2rn+eql.hx3m=O, eql.thxl+eql.thx2+eqleql.thx3=0, eql.dlhxl+eql.dlhx2teql.dlhx3=0, eql.d4hxl+eql.d4hx2+eql.d4hx3=0, eql.d5hxl+eql.d5hx2+eql.d5hx3=0; srestrict eql.hxl=eqZ.intercept, eql.hxZ=eq3.intercept; srestrict eql.ylhxl=eqZ.yl, eql .y2hxl=eq2. y2, eql.hxlhxl=eq2.hxl, eql.hxlhx2=eq2.hx2, eql.hxlhx3=eqZ.hx3, eql. hxlm=eq2 .m,
eql.hxls=eqZ.s, eql.thxl=eq2.t, eql .dlhxl=eq2 .dl, eql d4hxl=eq2.d4, eql d5hxl=eq2. d5, eql. ylhx2=eq3. yl, eql. y2hx2=eq3. y2, eql.hxlhx2=eq3.hxl, eql.hx2hxZ=eq3.hx2, eql.hx2hx3=eq3.hx3, eql. hx2m=eq3 .m, eql.hx2s=eq3.s, eql. thx2=eq3. t, eql.dlhxZ=eq3.d1, eql.d4hxZ=eq3.d4, eql. d5hx2=eq3. d5 ;
. .
/++**
Pengujian Durmny Gabungan (Slope)
****/
Dl: sTest Eql.dlhxl=Eql.dlhx2=Eql.dlyl=Eql.dly2=Eql.dlylyl=Eql.dly2y2=Eql.dlyly2=0/Print; D4: sTest
Lampiran Tabel 4. Statistik Deskripsi dari Total Biaya Tidak Tetap, J u r n l a h Output, Harga Input Tidak Tetap dan Biaya Tetap. Variables
Sum
Mean
LB STEBU
Log.
SBAKAR
Share bahan bakar Log. produksi Gula Log. produksi t e t e s Log. harga tebu g i l i n g Log. harga Bahan bakar Log. upah Tenaga kerja Log. biaya Management Log. biaya penyusutan
Y1 Y2 HX1 HX2 HX3
PI S YlYl Y2Y2 YlY2 HXlHXl HXlHX2 HXlHX3 HX2HX2 HX2HX3 HX3HX3
MM SS MS YlHXl YlHX2 YlHX3 Y2HX1 Y2HX2
Y2HX3 Y1M YIS Y2M Y2 S HXlM HXlS HX2M HX2S HX3M HX3S T TT THXl THX2 THX 3
TY1 TY2
t o t a l biaya Variabel
Share tebu
Tahun
Lampiran Tabel 5. Hasil Pendugaan Parameter Fungsi Biaya Translog dan Fungsi Pangsa Input Tidak Tetap dengan Variabel Dummy Status Pabrik (Dl). SYSLIN Procedure Ordinary Least Squares Estimation Model: EQ1 Dependent variable: LB Log. total biaya Variabel Analysis of Variance DF
Sum of Squares
Mean Square
46 499 545
243.87186 7.41255 251.28441
5.30156 0.01485
356.892
Root MSE Dep Mean
0.12188 16.28411 0.74846
R-Square Adj R-SQ
0.9705 0.9678
Source Model Error C Total
C.V.
F Value
Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX3 M
1 1 1 1 1 1
s
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
YlYl Y2Y2 Y1Y2 HXlHX1 HXlHX2 HXlKX3 HX2HX2 HX2HX3 HX3HX3 MM SS
MS YlHXl YlHX2 YlHX3 Y2HX1
1
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > IT1
Variable
DF
INTERCEP
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
Y1 Y2 HX1 HX2 HX3 M S T D1
1
Variable Label Intercept Log. produksi Gula Log. produksi tetes Log. harga tebu giling Log. harga Bahan bakar Log. upah Tenaga kerja Log. biaya Management Log. biaya penyusutan Tahun Dummy Status (l=Swasta, O=BUMN)
Model: EQ2 Dependent variable: STEBU Share tebu Analysis of Variance Source Model Error C Total
DF 9 536 545
Root MSE Dep Mean C.V.
Sum of Squares 8.26647 2.74340 11.00987 0.07154 0.74436 9.61123
Mean Square 0.91850 0.00512
R-Square Adj R-SQ
F Value 179.454
0.7508 0.7466
Parameter Estimates
INTERCEP
Y1 Y2 HX1 HX2 HX3
Parameter Estimate
DF
Variable
Standard Error
T for HO: Pararneter=O
Prob > IT1
1 I 1
I 1
I
M
1
s
1 1 1
T Dl
Model: EQ3 Dependent variable: SBAKAR Share bahan bakar Analysis of Variance Sum of Squares
DF
Source
Mean Square
F Value
ProblF
Model Error C Total Root MSE Dep Mean C.V.
0.00735 0.04840 15.17938
R-Square Adj R-SQ
0.9024 0.9008
Parameter Estimates Parameter Estimate
Variable
DF
INTERCEP Yl Y2 HX1 HX2
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
HX3 M
s T Dl Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX 3
1 1 1 1 1 1
Standard Error
Variable Label Intercept Log. produksi Gula Log. produksi tetes Log. harga tebu giling Log. harga Bahan bakar Log. upah Tenaga kerja
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > IT1
1 1 1 1
Log. biaya Management Log. biaya penyusutan Tahun Dummy Status (l=Swasta, O=BVMN) SYSLIN Procedure Seemingly Unrelated Regression Estimation
Cross Model Covariance Sigma
EQ1
EQ2
EQ3
Cross Model Correlation EQ1
Corr
EQ3
E Q ~
Cross Model Inverse Correlation Inv Corr
EQ1
EQ2
EQ3
Cross Model Inverse Covariance Inv Sigma
EQ1
EQ2
EQ3
System Weighted MSE: 1.2225 with 1600 degrees of freedom. System Weighted R-Square: 0.9515 Model: EQ1 Dependent variable: LB Log. total biaya Variabel Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1 HX2
1 1 1 1 1
Parameter Estimate 8.679505 -1.008837 1.982587 2.002938 -0.016958
Standard Error 1.289784 0.442844 0.395373 0.068270 0.007392
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > IT1
6.729 -2.278 5.014 29.338 -2.294
0.0001 0.0231 0.0001 0.0001 0.0222
HX 3 M
s YlYl Y2Y2 Y1Y2 HXlHXl HXlHX2 HXlHX3 HXZHX2 HX2HX3 HX3HX3
MM
sS MS YlHXl YlHXZ YlHX3 YZHXl Y2HXZ Y2HX3 Y1M Y1S Y2M YZS HXlM HXlS HX2M HX2 S HX3M HX3S T TT THXl THX2 THX 3 TY1 TY2 DlHXl DlHXZ DlHX3 D1
Variable INTERCEP Y l Y2
HX 1 HX2 HX3 M S
T
D1
Variable Label Intercept Log. p r o d u k s i G u l a L o g . p r o d u k s i tetes L o g . harga t e b u g i l i n g L o g . h a r g a B a h a n bakar L o g . upah T e n a g a kerja L o g . biaya M a n a g e m e n t L o g . b i a y a penyusutan Tahun Dummy S t a t u s ( l = S w a s t a , O=BUMN)
Model: EQ2 Dependent variable: STEBU Share tebu Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > I TI
INTERCEP Y1
Y2 Hx1
HX2 HX3 M S
T Dl Model: EQ3 Dependent variable: SBAKAR Share bahan bakar Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > IT1
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX1 HX2 HX3 M
s T D1 Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX 3 M
s T D1
Variable Label Intercept Log. produksi Gula Log. produksi tetes Log. harga tebu giling Log. harga Bahan bakar Log. upah Tenaga kerja Log. biaya Management Log. biaya penyusutan Tahun Dummy Status (l=Swasta, O=BUMN)
Cross Model Restrictions: Parameter Estimates
Variable DF RESTRICT -1
Parameter Estimate -0.394123
Standard Error 0.505337
T for HO: Parameter=O -0.780
Prob > I TI -4360
RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT
L Inv(X'X)
I n v ( L Inv(X'X)
L'
L'
LB-C
Lagrangians
4405.4662482 -22716.50762 -22716.50762 351347.26236 T e s t : Uji Dummy s l o p e s e c a r a s i m u l t a n 10.00175 DF: 2 FValue: Numerator: D e n o m i n a t o r : 1.222466 DF: 1600 ProbrF:
230.58745251 -2552.202816 8.1816 0.0003
Lampiran Tabel 6. Hasil Pendugaan Parameter Fungsi Biaya Translog dan Fungsi Pangsa Input Tidak Tetap dengan Variabel Dummy Kapasitas Produksi (D2 dan D3) SYSLIN Procedure Ordinary Least Squares Estimation Model: EQ1 Dependent variable: LB Log. total biaya Variabel Analysis of Variance Sum of Squares
DF
Source
50 495 545
Model Error C Total
244.20026 7.08415 251.28441
Root MSE Dep Mean C.V.
0.11963 16.28411 0.73464
Mean Square 4.88401 0.01431 R-Square Adj R-SQ
F Value
Prob>F
341.267
0.0001
0.9718 0.9690
Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX1 HX2 HX3 M
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
s YlYl Y2Y2 Y1Y2 HXlHXl HXIHX2 HXlHX3 HX2HX2 HX2HX3 HX3HX3 MM
ss MS YlHXl YlHX2 YlHX3 Y2HX1 Y2HX2 Y2HX3 Y1M
1
1 1 1 1
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > IT1
Y1S Y2M Y2S HXlM HXlS HX2M HX2s HX3M HX3s T TT THXl THX2 THX3 TY1 TY2 D2HX1 D2HX2 D2HX3 D3HX1 D3HX2 D3HX3 D2
D3
Variable
DF
INTERCEP
1 1 1
Yl
Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX 3 M
s T D2 D3
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
Variable Label Intercept Log. p r o d u k s i Gula Log. p r o d u k s i t e t e s Log. h a r g a t e b u g i l i n g Log. h a r g a Bahan b a k a r Tenaga k e r j a Log. upah Log. b i a y a Management Log. b i a y a p e n y u s u t a n Tahun D-y k a p a s i t a s (l=Rendah, O=lainnya) Dununy k a p a s i t a s ( l = S e d a n g , O = l a i n n y a )
Model: EQ2 Dependent v a r i a b l e :
STEBU S h a r e t e b u A n a l y s i s of v a r i a n c e
Source Model Error C Total
DF 10 535 545 Root MSE D e p Mean
C.V.
Sum o f Squares 8.28275 2.72712 11.00987 0.07140 0.74436 9.59163
Mean Square 0.82827 0.00510
R-Square Adj R-SQ
F Value 162.489
0.7523 0.7477
Parameter Estimates Variable
Parameter Estimate
DF
Standard T for HO: Error Parameter=O
Prob > I T f
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX1
nx2 HX3 M S T D2 D3 Model: EQ3 Dependent variable: SBAKAR Share bahan bakar Analysis of Variance DF
Source
Sum of Squares
Mean Square
F Value
Prob>F
Model Error C Total Root MSE Dep Mean C.V.
0.00744 0.04840 15.37000
R-Square Adj R-SQ
0.9002 0.8983
Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
INTE Y1 Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX 3 M
S T D2 D3 Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX1 HX2
1 1
1 1 1
Variable Label Intercept Log. produksi Gula Log. produksi tetes Log. harga tebu giling Log. harga Bahan bakar
TforHO: Pararneter=O
Prob > IT1
1
1 1 1 1 1
Log. upah Tenaga kerja Log. biaya Management Log. biaya penyusutan Tahun D-y kapasitas (l=Rendah, O=lainnya) D m y kapasitas (l=Sedang, O=lainnya)
SYSLIN Procedure Seemingly Unrelated Regression Estimation Cross Model Covariance
Sigma
EQ1
EQ2
EQ3
Cross Model Correlation
Cross Model Inverse Correlation Inv Corr
EQ1
EQ2
EQ3
Cross Model Inverse Covariance Inv Sigma
EQ1
EQ2
System Weighted MSE: 1.2029 with 1597 degrees of freedom. 0.9538 System Weighted R-Square:
EQ 3
SYSLIN Procedure Seemingly Unrelated Regression Estimation Model: EQ1 Dependent variable: LB Log. total biaya Variabel Parameter Estimates Variable INTERCE Y1 Y2 Hxl HX2 HX3 M S YlYl Y2Y2 Y1Y2 HXlHXl HXlHX2 HXlHX3 HX2HX2 HX2HX3 HX3HX3 MM
SS MS YlHXl YlHX2 YlHX3 Y2HXl Y2HX2 Y2HX3 Y1M Y1S Y2M Y2S HXlM HXlS HX2M HX2S HX3M HX3S T TT THX1 THX2 THX3 TY1 TY2 D2HX1 D2HX2 D2HX3 D3HX1
DF
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > IT1 0.0001 0.3326 0.0001 0.0001 0.5908 0.0001 0.0573 0.3270 0.0310 0.5139 0.0096 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.4889 0.0307 0.0229 0.1854 0.5628 0.2387 0.1247 0.0002 0.0706 0.0004 0.1004 0.0002 0.0001 0.5387 0.0001 0.0040 0.0001 0.3835 0.0001 0.0042 0.0001 0.0348 0.4936 0.0411 0.0015 0.0273 0.0681 0.2119 0.0673 0.0564
Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX1 HX2 HX3 M S T D2 D3
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
Variable Label Intercept Log. produksi Gula Log. produksi tetes Log. harga tebu giling Log. harga Bahan bakar Log. upah Tenaga kerja Log. biaya Management Log. biaya penyusutan Tahun Dummy kapasitas (l=Rendah, O=lainnya) Dummy kapasitas (l=Sedang, O=lainnya)
Model: EQ2 Dependent variable: STEBU Share tebu Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX3 M S T D2 D3
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1
parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > IT1
2.045928 0.016456 0.013442 0.148323 -0.036581 -0.111742 -0.002461 -0.029713 -0.002749 -0.033486 -0.031572
Model : EQ3 Dependent variable: SBAKAR Share bahan bakar Parameter Estimates Variable INTERCEP Yl Y2 HX1 RX2 HX 3
M S T
n2 I3 3
Parameter Estimate -0.005079 -0.000779 0.003520 -0.036581 0.044017 -0.007436 -0.001274 -0.001107 .000098777 -0.002498 -0.001420
Standard Error 0.009439 0.001346 0.000951 0.000531 0.000605 0.000672 0.000441 0.000222 0.000144 0.001998 0.001800
T for HO: Parameter=O -0.538 -0.579 3.702 -68.842 72.736 -11.057 -2.889 -4.992 -0.685 -1.250 -0.789
Prob > I TI 0.5908 0.5628 0.0002 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.0040 0.0001 0.4936 0.2118 0.4307
Variable INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX1 HX2 HX3 M S T D2 D3
DF
Variable Label Intercept Log. p r o d u k s i G u l a Log. p r o d u k s i tetes Log. h a r g a t e b u g i l i n g Log. h a r g a Bahan b a k a r Tenaga k e r j a Log. u p a h Log. b i a y a Management Log. b i a y a p e n y u s u t a n Tahun Dummy k a p a s i t a s [ l = R e n d a h , Dummy k a p a s i t a s ( l = S e d a n g ,
O=lainnya) O=lainnya)
C r o s s Model R e s t r i c t i o n s : Parameter Estimates
Variable
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T f o r KO: Parameter=O
RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT
-0.334654 1281.252548 2859.609783 3.413983 -18.965218 -532.072877 138.622493 -625.383539 14.788757 7.244979 314.631138 -39.604728 3178.003752 3054.064093 974.954699 3810.715200 3945.765127 4536.849505 4783.751129 1988.192150 215.208378 104.871364 -290.620633 -250.700173 -2087.810970 -268.968161 -507.042115 -557.958108 -63.540325 182.887574 -59.978154 -1.349711
0.521393 107.642091 849.791440 38 -500423 40.912521 99.538629 60.105481 147.881900 30.016386 29.311236 92.116162 63.406326 935.444547 888.727530 298.626105 613.306436 1129.718810 1391.699595 1275.509102 530.593945 85.641710 58.552356 650.032385 615.463648 281.766164 391.972354 774.164699 966.463343 866.440278 345.529757 59.276838 48.393869
-0.642 11.903 3.365 0.089 -0.464 -5.345 2.306 -4.229 0.493 0.247 3.416 -0.625 3.397 3.436 3.265 6.213 3.493 3.260 3.750 3.747 2.513 1.791 -0.447 -0.407 -7.410 -0.686 -0.655 -0.577 -0.073 0.529 -1.012 -0.028
Prob >
I TI
0.5215 0.0001 0.0007 0.9294 0.6434 0.9001 0.0210
o.rJoo1 0.6227 0.8050 0. 9006 0.5327 0 . 9006 0. 9006 0 . '1011 0.9001 0.9005 0.5011 0. 0002 0.9002 0.5118 0 . 'J733 0.6552 0.6842 0 . '1001 0.4931 0.5130 0.5642 0.51416 0.5571 0.3121 0.5778
L I n v ( X I X ) L'
0.0002941278
0.00001872
0.0002355172
Inv(L Inv (X'X) L' )
Test: Uji Dummy Slope Secara Simultan 4 DF: 1.422415 Numerator: 1597 DF: Denominator: 1.202898
LB-C
0.0000150088
-0.030988658
Lagrangians
FValue: Prob>F:
1.1825 0.3166
Lampiran Tabel 7. Hasil Pendugaan Parameter Fungsi Biaya Translog dan Fungsi Pangsa Input Tidak Tetap dengan Variabel Dummy Lokasi Pabrik (D4 SYSLIN P r o c e d u r e Ordinary Least Squares Estimation M o d e l : EQ1 Dependent v a r i a b l e :
LB Log.
t o t a l biaya Variabel Analysis of Variance
DF
Sum o f Squares
Mean Square
46 499 545
243.43876 7.84565 251.28441
5.29215 0.01572
336.592
R o o t MSE Dep Mean
0.12539 16.28411 0.77002
R-Square A d j R-SQ
0.9688 0.9659
Source Model Error C Total
C.V.
F Value
Parameter Estimates
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX3 M
s YlYl Y2Y2 YlY2 HXlHXl HXlHX2 HXlHX3 HX2HX2 HX2HX3 HX3HX3
MM SS MS
YlHXl YlHX2 YlHX3 Y2HXl YZHX2 Y2HX3 Y1M Y1S
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
71.087935 -5.096715 4.940569 0.376565 -0.644506 -8. 021880 -2.264067 1.206998 -0.026532 -0.072567 0.076737 0.124640 -0.135019 0.067144 -0.140174 0.124483 0.475162 0.014752 0.004239 0.000359 0.046324 0.103911 0.190759 -0.025611 -0.031717 -0.192820 0.153177 0.009691
19.480168 1.504328 1.330812 0.722378 1.467983 2.684829 0.517488 0.292855 0.113348 0.055202 0.064715 0.090712 0.041243 0.044578 0.184635 0.068018 0.206318 0.010625 0.006492 0.006859 0.044402 0.072425 0.096095 0.036318 0.065140 0.083847 0.038277 0.029160
T f o r HO: Parameter=O 3.649 -3.388 3.712 0.521 -0.439 -2.988 4.375 4.121 -0.234 -1.315 1.186 1.374 -3.274 1.506 - 0 . -759 1.830 2.303 1.388 0.653 0.052 1.043 1.435 1.985 -0.705 -0.487 -2.300 4.002 0.332
P r o b > IT1 0.0003 0.0008 0.0002 0.6024 0.6608 0.0029 0.0001 0.0001 0.8150 0.1893 0.2363 0.1701 0.0011 0.1326 0.4481 0.0678 0.0217 0.1656 0.5140 0.9583 0.2973 0.1520 0.0477 0.9810 0.6265 0.0219 0.0001 0.7398
Variable
DF
Variable Label Intercept Log. produksi Gula Log. produksi tetes Log. harga tebu giling Log. harga Bahan bakar Log. upah Tenaga kerja Log. biaya Management Log. biaya penyusutan Tahun Dummy lokasi (O=luar Jawa, l=Jawa)
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX1 HX2 HX3 M
s T D4
Model: EQ2 Dependent variable: STEBU Share tebu Analysis of Variance DF
Sum of Squares
Mean Square
9 536 545
8.35645 2.65342 11.00987
0.92849 0.00495
187.559
Root MSE Dep Mean C.V.
0.07036 0.74436 9.45230
R-Square Adj R-SQ
0.7590 0.7549
Source Model Error C Total
F Value
Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T forHO: Parameter=O
INTERCEP Y1
1 1 1
0.168356 0.037210 0.009415
0.158404 0.011230 0.009205
1.063 3.313 1.023
Y2
Prob > IT1
M o d e l : EQ3 Dependent v a r i a b l e :
SaAKAR S h a r e b a h a n b a k a r
A n a l y s i s of V a r i a n c e
DF
Sum o f Squares
Mean Square
F Value
R o o t MSE Dep Mean C .V.
0.00743 0.04840 15.36218
R-Square A d j R-SQ
0.9001 0.8984
Source
Model Error C Total
Parameter Estimates
Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1
1
Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX3 M
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
S
T D4
Variable INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX 3
M s T D4
Parameter Estimate
Standard Erros
T f o r HO: Parameter=O
1
DF
Variable Label Intercept Log. p r o d u k s i Gula Log. p r o d u k s i tetes Log. h a r g a t e b u g i l i n g Log. h a r g a Bahan b a k a r Tenaga k e r j a Log. upah L o g . b i a y a Management Log. b i a y a penyusutan Ta h u n Durmny l o k a s i ( O = l u a r J a w a ,
l=Jawa)
SYSLIN Procedure Seemingly Unrelated Regression Estimation Cross Model Covariance EQ1
Sigma
EQ2
EQ3
Cross Model Correlation Corr
EQ1
EQ2
EQ3
Cross Model Inverse Correlation Inv Corr
EQl
EQ2
EQ3
Cross Model Inverse Covariance Inv Sigma
EQ1
EQ 3
EQ2
System Weighted MSE: 1.199 with 1600 degrees of freedom. System Weighted R-Square: 0.9530 Model: EQ1 Dependent variable: LB Log. total biaya Variabel Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1
1 1 1 1
9.126454 -0.809012 1.880985 2.004244
1.153662 0.445707 0.397870 0.065791
7.911 -1.815 4.728 30.464
Prob > IT1 0.0001 0.0701 0.0001 0.0001
HX2 HX3 M
s YlYl Y2Y2 Y1Y2 HXlHXl HXlHX2 HXlHX3 HX2HX2 HX2HX3 HX3HX3
MM
s5 MS YlHXl YlHX2 YlHX3 Y2HX1 Y2HX2 Y2HX3 Y1M Y1S Y2M Y2S HX l M HXlS HX2M HX2S HX3M HX3s T TT TKXl THX2 THX3 TY1 TY2 D4HXl D4HX2 D4HX3 D4
Variable INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX 3 M
s T D4
Variable Label Intercept Log. produksi Gula Log. produksi t e t e s Log. harga tebu g i l i n g Log. harga Bahan bakar Log. upah Tenaga kerja Log. biaya Management Log. biaya penyusutan Tahun Dummy l o k a s i (O=luar Jawa,
l=Jawa)
Model: EQ2 Dependent variable: STEBU Share tebu Parameter Estimates f arameter
Variable
DF
INTERCEP
1 1 1 1 1
Y1
Y2 Hx1
HX2 HX 3 M S T D4
Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > IT1
1 1
1 1
I
Model: E Q 3 Dependent variable: SBAKAR Share bahan bakar Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX3 M
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
S T
D4
Variable
DF
INTERCEP
1 1 1
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Variable Label
Intercept Log. produksi Gula Y2 Log. produksi tetes HX1 1 Log. harga tebu giling HX2 1 Log. harga Bahan bakar HX3 1 Log. upah Tenaga kerja M 1 Log. biaya Management s 1 Log. biaya penyusutan T 1 Tahun D4 1 Dummy lokasi (O=luar Jawa. l=Jawa) Cross Model Restrictions: Y1
Prob > IT1
Parameter Estimates
Variable
DF
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T f o r HO: Parameter=O
RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT L I n v ( X I X ) L'
I n v ( L Inv(XIX) L' )
Test:
U j i Dummy S l o p e S e c a r a S i m u l t a n Numerator: 12.7166 DF: 2 Denominator: 1.199043 DF: 1600
LB-C
Lagrangians
F Value: ProblF:
10.6056 0.0001
Prob >
IT1
Lampiran Tabel 8. Kasil Pendugaan Parameter Fungsi Biaya Translog dan Fungsi Pangsa Input Tidak Tetap dengan Variabel Dummy Proses Pabriksasi D5) SYSLIN Procedure Ordinary Least Squares Estimation Model: EQ1 Dependent variable: LB Log. total biaya Variabel Analysis of Variance DF
Sum of Squares
Mean Square
46 499 545
243.35012 7.93429 251.28441
Root MSE Dep Mean C.V.
0.12610 16.28411 0.77435
Source Model Ef ror C Total
F Value
Prob>F
5.29022 0.01590
332.710
0.0001
R-Square
0.9684 0.9655
Adj R-SQ
Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1 YZ HX 1 HX2 HX 3
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
M S YlYl Y2Y2 Y1Y2 HXlHXl HXlHX2 RXlHX3 HX2HX2 HX2HX3 HX3HX3 MM
ss
MS YlHXl YlHX2 YlHX3 Y2HX1 Y2HX2 Y2HX3 Y lM YlS
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > [TI
Y2M Y2S HXlM HXlS HXZM HXZS HX3M HX3s T TT THx1 THX2 THX3 TY1 TY2
D5HX1 D5HX2 D5HX3 D5 Variable
DF
Variable Label Intercept Log. produksi Gula Log. produksi tetes Log. harga tebu giling Log. harga Bahan bakar Log. upah Tenaga kerja Log. biaya Management Log. biaya penyusutan Tahun Dummy Proses Pabriksasi (O=Karbonatasi, l=Sulfitasi)
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX1 EX2 HX 3 M S T D5
Model: EQ2 Dependent variable: STEBU Share tebu Analysis of Variance DF
Sum of Squares
Mean Square
9 536 545
8.26912 2.74076 11.00987
~ o o tMSE Dep Mean C.V.
0.07151 0.74436 9.60659
Source Model Error C Total
F Value
Prob>F
0.91879 0.00511
179.685
0.0001
R-square Adj R-SQ
0.7511 0.7469
Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > I TI
INTERCEP Y1
1 1 1
0.146613 0.037434 0.015363
0.161320 0.011493 0.009717
0.909 3.257 1.581
0.3638 0.0012 0.1145
Y2
Model: EQ3 Dependent variable: SBAKAR Share bahan bakar Analysis of Variance DF
Sum of Squares
Root MSE Dep Mean C.V.
0.00742 0,04840 15.33448
source
Mean Square
F Value
R-Square R-SQ
0.9004 0.8988
Prob>F
Model Error C Total Adj
Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX 3 M
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
s T D5 Variable INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX3 M
s T D5
DF
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > IT1
Variable Label Intercept Log. produksi Gula Log. produksi tetes Log. harga tebu giling Log. harga Bahan bakar Log. upah Tenaga kerja Log. biaya Management Log. biaya penyusutan Tahun Dummy Proses Pabriksasi (O=Karbonatasi.l=Sulfitasi)
SYSLIN Procedure Seemingly Unrelated Regression Estimation Cross Model Covariance EQ 1
Sigma
EQ2
EQ3
Cross Model Correlation Corr
Cross Model Inverse Correlation Inv Corr
EQ1
EQ2
EQ3
Cross Model Inverse Covariance Inv Sigma
EQ2
EQ1
EQ3
System Weighted MSE: 1.1963 with 1600 degrees of freedom. System Weighted R-Square: 0.9509 Model: EQ1 Dependent variable: LB Log. total biaya Variabel Parameter Estimates Variable INTER Y1 Y2 HX1 HX2 HX3 M S
YlYl Y2Y2 Y1Y2
DF
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T forHO: Parameter=O
Prob > I T
I
HXlHXl HXlHX2 HXlHX3 HX2fM2 HX2HX3 HX3HX3 MM
ss MS YlHXl YlHX2 YlHX3 YZHXl Y2HX2 Y2HX3 Y1M Y1S Y2M Y2S HX lM HXlS HXZM HX2S HX 3M HX3S T TT THX1 THX2 THX3 TY1 TYZ D5HX1 D5HX2 D5HX3 D5 Variable
Variable Label
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX3 M S T D5
Intercept Log. produksi Gula Log. produksi tetes Log. harga tebu giling Log. harga Bahan bakar Log. upah Tenaga kerja Log. biaya Management Log. biaya penyusutan Tahun Dummy Proses Pabriksasi (O=Karbonatasi,l=sulfitasi)
Model: EQ2 Dependent variable: STEBU Share tebu
Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > IT I
Model: EQ3 Dependent variable: SBAKAR Share bahan bakar Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
Parameter Estimate
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX3 M S T D5
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
-0.011459 0.000387 0.002766 -0.036525 0.044172 -0.007647 -0.001193 -0.001260 -0.000084598 0.002187
Variable
DF
INTERCEP Yl Y2
1 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 I 1
HX1
HX2 HX 3 M
s T D5
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > IT1
Variable Label Intercept Log. produksi Gula Log. produksi tetes Log. harga tebu giling Log. harga Bahan bakar Log. upah Tenaga kerja Log. biaya Management Log. biaya penyusutan Tahun Dummy Proses Pabriksasi (O=Karbonatasi.l=Sulfitasi)
Cross Model Restrictions: Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
Parameter Estimate
RESTRICT
-1 -1
-0.205011 1263.034915
RESTRICT
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > IT1
0.491641
-0.417 11.713
0.6771 0.0001
107.830626
RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRTCT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT L I n v ( X I X ) L'
Inv(L Inv(X'X)
Test:
L' )
Uji dummy s l o p e secara s i m u l t a n 2 3.675787 DF: Numerator: 1600 D e n o m i n a t o r : 1.196275 DF:
LB-C
Lagrangians
F Value: Prob>F:
3.0727 0.0466
Lampiran Tabel 9. Hasil Pendugaan Parameter Fungsi Biaya Translog dan Fungsi Pangsa Input Tidak Tetap Dengan Variabel Dummy Rendemen ( D 6 ) SYSLIN Procedure Ordinary Least Squares Estimation Model: EQ1 Dependent variable: LB Log. total biaya Variabel Analysis of Variance Source
DF
Sum of Squares
Mean Square
Model Error C Total
46 499 545
244.67742 6,60699 251.28441
Root MSE Dep Mean C.V.
0.11507 16.28411 0.70662
F Value
Prob>F
5,31907 0.01324
401.729
0.0001
R-Square Adj R-SQ
0.9737 0.9713
Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1 Y2
1 1 1
HX1
1
HX2 HX3 M S YlYl Y2Y2 Y1Y2 HXlHXl HXlHX2 HXlHX3 HX2HX2 HX2HX3 HX3HX3 MM SS MS YlHXl YlHX2 YlHX3 YZHXl Y2HX2 Y2HX3 Y1M YlS
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
Y2M
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > IT1
Y2S HXlM HXlS HX2M HXZS HX3M HX3s
T TT THXl THXZ THX3 TY1 TY2 D6HX1 D6HX2 D6HX3 D6 Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1 Y2
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
HX1
HX2 KX3 M
s D6
Variable Label Intercept Log. produksi Gula Log. produksi tetes Log. harga tebu giling Log. harga Bahan bakar Log. upah Tenaga kerja Log. biaya Management Log. biaya penyusutan Dummy Rendemen Hablur (l=besar, O=kecil)
Model: EQ2 Dependent variable: STEBU Share tebu Analysis of Variance DF
Sum of Squares
Mean Square
9 536 545
8.30973 2.70015 11.00987
Root MSE Dep Mean C.V.
0.07098 0.74436 9.53516
Source Model Error C Total
F Value
Prob>F
0.92330 0.00504
183.283
0.0001
R-Square Adj R-SQ
0.7548 0.7506
Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
INTERCEP Y1
1 1 1 1
0.115620 0.042969 0.008946 0.204547
0.160332 0.011420 0.009350 0.006074
0.721 3.763 0.957 33.677
Y2
HX1
Prob > IT1 0.4711 0.0002 0.3391 0.0001
Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1
Variable Label Intercept Log. produksi Gula Log. produksi tetes Log. harga tebu giling Log. harga Bahan bakar Log. upah Tenaga kerja Log. biaya Management Log. biaya penyusutan Tahun D-y Rendernen Hablur (l=besar, O=kecil)
Y2 HX1 HX2 HX3 M
s T D6
Model : EQ3 Dependent variable: SBAKAR Share bahan bakar Analysis of Variance DF
Sum of Squares
Mean Square
9 536 545
0.26713 0.02939 0.29652
0.02968 0.00005
541.387
Root MSE Dep Mean
0.00740 0.04840 15.29973
R-square Adj R-SQ
0.9009 0.8992
Source Model Error C Total
C.V.
F Value
Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX 3 M
1 1 1 1
s T D6
1
1 1 1 1 1
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > IT1
Variable INTERCEP Y l Y2 HX1 HX2
AX3 M S
T D6
Variable Label Intercept Log. p r o d u k s i Gula Log. p r o d u k s i t e t e s Log. h a r g a t e b u g i l i n g Log. h a r g a Bahan b a k a r Log. upah Tenaga k e r j a Log. b i a y a Management Log. b i a y a p e n y u s u t a n Tahun D-y Rendernen Hablur ( l = b e s a r , O = k e c i l )
Cross Model C o v a r i a n c e
Sigma
EQ1
EQ2
EQ3
Cross Model C o r r e l a t i o n Corr
EQ1
EQ2
EQ3
Cross Model I n v e r s e C o r r e l a t i o n I n v Corr
EQ1
EQ2
EQ3
Cross Model I n v e r s e C o v a r i a n c e Inv Sigma
EQ1
EQ2
System Weighted M S E : 1.1775 w i t h 1600 d e g r e e s o f System Weighted R-Square: 0.9603
EQ3
freedom.
Model: E Q 1 Dependent variable: L B Log. total biaya Variabel Parameter Estimates
Variable INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1 IM2 HX3 M
DF
1 1 1 1 1
1
YlYl Y2Y2 Y1Y2 HXlHXl HXlHX2 HXlHX3 HX2HX2 HX2HX3 HX3HX3
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
ss MS YlHXl YlHX2 YlHX3 Y2HX1 Y2HX2 Y2HX3 Y1M Y1S Y2M Y2S HX l M HXlS HX2M HX2 S HX3M HX3S T TT THX 1 THX2 THX 3 TY1 TY2 D 6HX 1 D6HX2 D 6HX 3 D6
Standard Error
1 1
S
MM
Parameter Estimate
Model: EQ2 Dependent variable: S T E B U Share tebu
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > I TI
Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
parameter Estimate
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX1 HX2 HX3 M S T
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1.983181 0.026919 0.006879 0.151710 -0.036354 -0.115355 -0.002629 -0.027128 -0.002370 -0.017241
D6
Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX3 M
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob z IT1
Variable Label Intercept Log. produksi Gula Log. produksi tetes Log. harga tebu giling Log. harga Bahan bakar Log. upah Tenaga kerja Log. biaya Management Log. biaya penyusutan Tahun Dummy Rendemen Hablur il=besar, O=kecil)
s T D6
Model: EQ3 Dependent variable: S a A K A R Share bahan bakar Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1 HX2 HX 3 M
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
S
T D6 Variable
DF
INTERCEP Y1 Y2
1 1 1 1 1
HX1
HXZ
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
Variable Label Intercept Log. produksi Gula Log. produksi tetes Log. harga tebu giling Log. harga Bahan bakar
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > IT1
HX 3
1 1 1 1 1
M
S T
D6
L o g . upah Tenaga k e r j a L o g . biaya M a n a g e m e n t L o g . b i a y a penyusutan Tahun Dummy R e n d e m e n H a b l u r ( l = b e s a r , O = k e c i l )
Cross Model R e s t r i c t i o n s : Parameter Estimates
Variable
DF
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T f o r HO: Parameter=O
RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT L Inv(X'X1
L'
I n v ( L I n v ( X I X ) L')
Test:
LB-C
Lagrangians
DUMMY
Numerator: Denominator:
2.701494 1.177541
DF: DF:
2 1600
F Value:
Prob>F:
2.2942 0.1012
Prob z
IT I
L Inv(XIX) L'
Inv (L Inv (X'XI L ' 544.83511816 Test: JOINT Numerator: 10.85995 Denominator: 1.177541
NOTE:
DF: DF:
1 1600
LB-C
)
Lagrangians 76.921263721
F Value: Prob>F:
Restrictions in effect for model tested.
9.2226 0.0024
Lampiran Tabel 1 0 . U j i Kelayakan Model dengan Metode OLS dan Metode SUR a. Uji Kelayakan Model Metode OLS SIMLIN Procedure Statistics of Fit Variabel LB STEBU SBAKAR
Mean Error
N 546 54 6 546
-3.213-13 -3.18E-16 -8.223-17
Mean % Error -1.004416 -1.2061 0.1021
Mean Abs Error 1.0807 0.0554 0.005551
Mean Abs % Error 0.49669 8.17616 14.11834
Statistics of Fit Variable LB STEBU SBAKAR
RMS Error 0.1080 0.0695 0.007271
RMS % Error
Label Log. Total biaya variabel Share tebu Share bahan bakar
0.661 11- 5 7 8 5 19.9249
b. Uji Kelayakan Model Metode SUR SIMLIN Procedure
Statistics of Fit Var iabel LB STEBU SBAKAR
Me an Error
N 54 6 54 6 54 6
0.003550 -0.004475 -0.000332
Mean % Error 0.0178 -2 - 6 7 5 7 1.1786
Mean Abs Error 0.1075 0.0657 0.006303
Mean Abs % Error
0.66050 10.14250 16.78810
Statistics of Fit Variable LB
STEBU SBAKAR
RMS Error 0.1446 0.0880 0.008537
RMS 8 Error 0.8904 15.9700 25.3470
Label Log. Total biaya variabel Share tebu Share bahan bakar
Lampiran Tabel 11. Hasil Pendugaan Parameter Fungsi Biaya Translog dan Fungsi Pangsa Input Tidak Tetap dengan Variabel Dummy Status Pabrik (Dl), Dummy Lokasi Pabrik (D4). Dummy Proses Pabriksasi (D5). SYSLIN Procedure Seemingly Unrelated Regression Estimation
Cross Model Covariance Sigma
EQ1
EQ2
Cross Model Correlation Corr
EQl
EQ2
Cross Model Inverse Correlation Inv corr
EQl
EQ2
EQ3
Cross Model Inverse Covariance Inv Sigma
EQ 1
EQ2
System Weighted MSE: 1.2411 with 1580 degrees of freedom. System Weighted R-Square: 0.9558
EQ 3
SYSLIN Procedure Seemingly Unrelated Regression Estimation Model: EQ1 Dependent variable: LB Log. total biaya Variabel Parameter Estimates Variable
DF
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T fox HO: Parameter=O
Prob > IT1
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HXl HX2 HX3
I 1 I 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
-6.806917 -1.630123 6.140328 1.975673 -0.015983 -0.959690 -0.190335 -0.008502 -0.177505 -0.631872 0.227435 0.149639 -0.035863 -0.113775 0.045181 -0.009317 0.123093 -0.007160 0.003902 -0.000046651 0.031354 0.001632 -0.032986 0.006147 0.002458 -0.008606 0.108350 0.047827 -0.086205 -0.081884 -0.003421 -0.029895 -0.000847 -0.001305 0.004268 0.031200 -0.015142 -0.004481 -0.001985 0.000026638 0.001958 -0.008907 0.014555 -0.002457 -0.004646 0.007102 -0.010232
13.101600 4.552896 2.950192 0.069362 0.007588 0.074452 0.139461 0.095542 1.894244 1.902322 1.859799 0.004671 0.000541 0.004989 0.000587 0.000687 0.005374 0.007635 0.005014 0.004691 0.010719 0.001161 0.011508 0.008956 0.000973 0.009615 0.030763 0.025654 0.026682 0.018566 0.004051 0.002064 0.000446 0.000221 0.004348 0.002215 0.040491 0.000982 0.001269 0.000140 0.001362 0.007158 0.006594 0.021123 0.002235 0.022669 0.010068
-0.520 -0.358 2.081 28.483 -2.106 -12.890 -1.365 -0.089 -0.094 -0.332 0.122 32.037 -66.278 -22.804 76.985 -13.557 22.907 -0.938 0.778 -0.010 2.925 1.406 -2.866 0.686 2.525 -0.895 3.522 1.864 -3.231 -4.410 -0.844 -14.485 -1.898 -5.902 0.982 14.086 -0.374 -4.564 -1.565 0.190 1.438 -1.244 2.207 -0.116 -2.07 8 0.313 -1.016
0.6036 0.7205 0.0379 0.0001 0.0357 0.0001 0.1730 0.9291 0.9254 0.7399 0.9027 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.3488 0.4368 0.9921 0.0036 0.1603 0.0043 0.4928 0.0119 0.3713 0.0005 0.0629 0.0013 0.0001 0.3989 0.0001 0.0583 0.0001 0.3268 0.0001 0.7086 0.0001 0.1183 0.8495 0.1511 0.2140 0.0278 0.9075 0.0382 0.7542 0.3100
M S
YlYl Y2Y2 Y1Y2 HXlHXl HXlHX2 HXlHX3 HX2HX2 HX2HX3 HX3HX3 MM SS
MS YlHXl YlHX2 YlHX3 Y2HX1 Y2HX2 Y2HX3 Y1M Y1S Y2M Y2S HX lM HXlS HX2M fix2S HX3M BX3S T TT THXl THX2 THX3 TY1 TY2 DlHXl DlHX2 DlHX3 D4HX1
D4HX2 D4HX3 D5HX1 D5HX2 D5HX3 DlYl D1Y2 D4Y1 D4Y2 D5Y1 D5Y2 DlYlYl DlY2Y2 DlYlY2 D4YlY1 D4Y2Y2 D4YlY2 D5YlY1 D5Y2Y2 D5YlY2 Dl D4 D5 Model: EQ2 Dependent variable: STEBU Share tebu Parameter Estimates Varfable
DF
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
Prob > IT I
INTER Y1 Y2 HX1 HX2 HX3 M S T Dl D4
D5 Model: EQ3 Dependent variable: SBAKAR Share bahan bakar Parameter Estimates Variable
Dl?
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T for HO: Parameter=O
INTERCEP Y1 Y2 HX 1
1 1 1 1
-0.015983 0.001632 0.002458 -0.035863
0.007588 0.001161 0.000973 0.000541
-2.106 1.406 2.525 -66.278
Prob > IT1
Cross Model R e s t r i c t i o n s : Parameter Estimates
Variable
DF
Parameter Estimate
Standard Error
T f o r HO: Parameter=O
RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT RESTRICT
-7.104 -0.296 0.191 -7.102 -7.127 -7.166 -7 -548 -6.943 -7.997 -0.241 -7.119 -7.144 4.988 4.022 5.089 5.052 0.908 5.806 4.235 4.927 5.283 5.380 -1.103 5.359 4.454 4.192 4 -221 -9.812 -1.283 1.694 4.049 4.303 4.829 1.031 3.587 3.882 LB-C
Prob
> IT I 0.0001 0.7675 0.8491 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.8100 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.3643 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.2706 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.1998 0.0902 0.0001 0.0001 0.0001 0.3032 0.0003 0.0001
)
Test: D l Numerator: 1.741895 Denominator: 1.241141
DF: DF:
7
1580
Lagrangians
F Value: Prob>F:
LB-C
1.4035 0.1996
Test: D4 Numerator: Denominator:
11.16746 1.241141
DF: DF:
7 1580
F Value: Prob>F:
8.9977 0.0001
LB-C
Inv ( L Inv (X'X) L' )
Test: D5 Numerator: Denominator:
1.961939 1.241141
DF: DF:
7 1580
Lagrangians
F Value: Prob>F:
NOTE: R e s t r i c t i o n s i n e f f e c t for model t e s t e d .
1.5808 0.1367
Lampiran Tabel 12a. Nilai Ekonomi Cakupan Usaha (Economies o f EOS) Pabrik Gula di Indonesia Scope, Berdasarkan Status Pabrik : 1990-1997. Economies STATUS PABRIK
Biaya
( y l , y2)
Biaya
(0, ~ 2 )
BiaYa
(yl,
O)
of S c o p e
BUMN
13121753.00
12937606.44
13081040.21
1.02
Swasta
77811076.09
78464936.39
77832853.75
1.01
Total
15254368.05
15097848.08
15215715.38
1.02
Lampiran Tabel 12b. Nilai Ekonomi Cakupan Usaha Economies o f Scope, EOS) Pabrik Gula di Indonesia Berdasarkan Lokasi Pabrik : 1990-1997. Economies STATUS PABRIK
Biaya
( y l , y2)
Biaya
( 0 , y2)
Biaya
(yl, 0)
of scope
BUMN
12391350.27
12152312.79
12369478.08
1.02
Swasta
31454858.90
31765267.32
31321253.30
1.01
15097848.08
15215715.38
1.02
15254368.05
Total
Lampiran Tabel 12c. Nilai Ekonomi Cakupan Usaha (Economies o f Scope, EOS) Pabrik Gula di Indonesia Berdasarkan Proses Pabrikasi : 1990-1997. Economies STATUS
PABRIK
~i~~~ (yl,
y2)
Biaya
(0.
~ 2 )
BiaYa
( ~ 1 ,0 )
of scope
BUMN
10047240.62
10475641.68
10106399.13
1.01
Swasta
16070739.72
15822516.04
16016752.25
1.02
15097848.08
15215715-38
1.02
Total
15254368.05
L a m p i r a n T a b e l 12d. N i l a i Ekonorni C a k u p a n U s a h a (Economies o f Scope, EOS) P a b r i k Gula d i Indonesia Berdasarkan Status Pabrik dan Lokasi P a b r i k : 1990-1997. BUMN
STATUS PABRIK Swasta
LOKASI PABRIK Jawa
Biaya
( ~ 1y,2 )
12391350.27
Biaya
(0,
12152312.79
Biaya
(yl,
y2)
L u a r Jawa
12369478.08
0)
Economies o f
Scope
Biaya
( ~ 1 y. 2 )
Biaya
(0,
Biaya
(yl,
y2)
.
0)
1.02 18417172.81
77811076.09
18630985.40
78464936.39
18239865.68
77832853.75
Economies o f S c o p e Total
I
1-01
1.01 77811076.09
Biaya
( ~ 1 ,y 2 )
13121753.00
Biaya
( 0 , y2)
12937606.44
78464936.39
Biaya
(yl,
13081040.21
77832853.75
0)
Economies o f
Scope
1.02
1-01
L a m p i r a n Tabel 12e. N i l a i Ekonomi C a k u p a n Usaha (Economies o f Scope, EOS) Pabrik Gula di Indonesia Berdasarkan Status Pabrik dan Proses P a b r i k a s i : 1990-1997. BUMM
STATUS PABRI K Swasta
PROSES PABRIKASI Karbonatasi
Biaya
( ~ 1 y,2 )
7931323.82
86220245.42
Biaya
(0, y2)
7993025.72
99849816.19
Biaya
(yl,
7915192.17
88989849.80
0)
1.01
1.21
Biaya
(yl,
$2)
13941294.45
76759929.93
Biaya
(0, y2)
13718329.71
75791826.42
(yl,
13896700.43
76438229.24
1.03
0.99 77811076.09
Economies o f S c o p e Sulfitasi
Biaya
0)
Economies o f Total
Scope
Biaya
( ~ 1y . 2)
13121753.00
Biaya
(0, y2)
12937606.44
78464936.39
Biaya
(yl.
13081040.21
77832853.75
1.02
1.01
0)
Economies of
Scope
Lampiran Tabel 12f. Nilai Ekonomi Cakupan Usaha (Economies of EOS) Pabrik Gula di Indonesia Scope, Berdasarkan Lokasi Pabrik dan Proses Pabrikasi : 1990-1997. PROSES PABRIKASI Sulfitasi Karbonatasi
LOKAS I P A B R I K Jawa
Biaya
(yl,
Biaya
(0,
Biaya
(yl,
7931323.82
13210538.80
y2)
7993025.72
12916263.47
0)
7915192.17
13187612.22
y2)
Economies o f L u a r Jawa
Biaya
(yl,
Biaya
(0,
Biaya
(yl,
y2) y2) 0)
Economies o f Total
Scope
Scope
y2)
1.01
1.03
86220245.42
30085724.24
99849816.19
30063153.60
88989849.80
29879538.39
1.21 10047240.62
1.01 16070739.72
Biaya
(yl.
Biaya
(0, y2)
10475641.68
15822516.04
Biaya
(yl,
10106399.13
16016752.25
0)
Economies o f
Scope
1-01
1.02
Lampiran Tabel 12g.Nilai Ekonomi Cakupan Usaha (Economies of Scope, EOS) Pabrik Gula di Indonesia Berdasarkan Status Pabrik, Lokasi Pabrik dan Proses Pabrikasi :1990-1997.