No title

(&/,1/*+$06%.YRRUKHHQ/-1%.*HUHFKWVKRI$PVWHUGDP

(&/,1/*+$06%. ,QVWDQWLH

*HUHFKWVKRI$PVWHUGDP

'DWXPXLWVSUDDN

'DWXPSXEOLFDWLH

=DDNQXPPHU

5HFKWVJHELHGHQ

6WUDIUHFKW

%LM]RQGHUHNHQPHUNHQ+RJHUEHURHS ,QKRXGVLQGLFDWLH

*UDQDDWH[SORVLHRSMDQXDULLQFDIp)DPLOLDLQ$PVWHUGDP 1RRUG9HUGDFKWHLVJHFRQIURQWHHUGPHWHHQRQWSORIILQJLQHHQ FDIp1DGHH[SORVLH]LMQKHWOLFKWHQGHPX]LHNHYHQXLWJHYDOOHQ ZDVHUURRNODJHQHUJHZRQGHQRSGHJURQGHQYOXFKWWHQPHQVHQ KHWFDIpXLW9HUGDFKWHKHHIWYHUNODDUGQDDU]LMQYULHQGLQRS]RHN WH]LMQJHJDDQHQLVGDDUELMRSVODFKWRIIHU JHVWXLWGLH]RDOVLV JHEOHNHQGHJUDQDDWKHHIWODWHQH[SORGHUHQ6ODFKWRIIHU ZDVPHW HHQEDUNUXNHHQDQGHUHEH]RHNHUYDQKHWFDIpGLHRSGHJURQG ODJDDQKHWVODDQ9ROJHQVYHUGDFKWHKHHIWKLMVODFKWRIIHU GDDURS DDQJHVSURNHQHQLVYHUYROJHQVGRRUVODFKWRIIHU GLHZRHVWXLW]LMQ RJHQNHHNJHVODJHQHQEHHWJHSDNWHQURQGJHVOLQJHUGDOVRIKLMHHQ OHGHQSRSZDV6ODFKWRIIHU ]RXGDDUELMWHYHQVJHURHSHQKHEEHQ GDWKLMYHUGDFKWH]RXDIPDNHQ9HUGDFKWHYHUNODDUWLQGRRGVDQJVW WHKHEEHQYHUNHHUGHQKHHIW]LMQSLVWRROJHSDNWGRRUJHODGHQHQ KHHIWRSVODFKWRIIHU JHVFKRWHQRP]RDOVYHUGDFKWHYHUNODDUW ³ORVWHNRPHQ´ +HWKRIFRQFOXGHHUWGDWGHWHUWHUHFKW]LWWLQJYDQKHWKRIELMGH UHFKWEDQNELMGHUHFRQVWUXFWLHHQELMGHSROLWLHDIJHOHJGH YHUNODULQJHQYDQGHYHUGDFKWHQLHWZRUGHQZHHUVSURNHQGRRU KHWJHHQGRRUGHSROLWLHLVEHYRQGHQHQLQKHWGRVVLHULV QHHUJHOHJG +HWKRINRPWWRWGHFRQFOXVLHGDWDDQQHPHOLMNLVJHZRUGHQGDW YHUGDFKWHGRRUVODFKWRIIHU ]RGDQLJLVEHODDJGGDWHUVSUDNHLV JHZHHVWYDQHHQRJHQEOLNNHOLMNHHQZHGHUUHFKWHOLMNHDDQUDQGLQJ ZDDUWHJHQKLM]LFKPRHVWYHUGHGLJHQ]RGDWKLMKHHIWJHKDQGHOGLQ HHQQRRGZHHUVLWXDWLH'HUHDFWLHYDQYHUGDFKWHRSGH ZHGHUUHFKWHOLMNHDDQUDQGLQJYDQVODFKWRIIHU PRHWHYHQZHODOV GLVSURSRUWLRQHHOZRUGHQEHVFKRXZG'DDURPNRPWYHUGDFKWHJHHQ EHURHSRSQRRGZHHUDOVEHGRHOGLQDUWLNHOHHUVWHOLGYDQKHW :HWERHNYDQ6WUDIUHFKWWRH +HWKRIDFKWDDQQHPHOLMNJHZRUGHQGDWKHWVFKLHWHQPHWKHW SLVWRRORSKHWOLFKDDPYDQVODFKWRIIHU NHQQHOLMNKHWRQPLGGHOOLMNH JHYROJLVJHZHHVWYDQHHQKHYLJHJHPRHGVEHZHJLQJGLHGRRUKHW RSKHPWRHJHSDVWHJHZHOG±WHJHQGHDFKWHUJURQGYDQGHRQWSORIWH JUDQDDWGHFKDRVLQKHWFDIpKHWGRRUVODFKWRIIHU VODDQYDQ EH]RHNHUFDIp GLHRSGHJURQGODJPHWHHQEDUNUXN±YDQHHQ YHUPRHGHOLMNZRHGHQGHVODFKWRIIHU ELMGHYHUGDFKWHLVRQWVWDDQ $DQQHPHOLMNLVJHZRUGHQGDWGHYHUGDFKWHGLHLQI\VLHNRS]LFKW GXLGHOLMNGHPLQGHUHYDQVODFKWRIIHU PRHWZRUGHQJHDFKWKHHIW JHKDQGHOGXLWGRRGVDQJVWGDWKHWUHHGVWHJHQKHPJHSOHHJGH JHZHOG]RXYRRUWGXUHQGDWKLMHUQLHWWHJHQRSJHZDVVHQZDVHQ GDWKLMHU]LFKQLHWDDQNRQRQWWUHNNHQ %LMGH]HVWDQGYDQ]DNHQLVKHWKRIYDQRRUGHHOGDWYHUGDFKWHHHQ EHURHSWRHNRPWRSQRRGZHHUH[FHV]RGDWKLMGLHQWWHZRUGHQ RQWVODJHQYDQDOOHUHFKWVYHUYROJLQJWHU]DNHYDQKHWRQGHU EHZH]HQYHUNODDUGHIHLW

:HWVYHUZLM]LQJHQ

:HWERHNYDQ6WUDIUHFKW :HWERHNYDQ6WUDIUHFKW

9LQGSODDWVHQ

5HFKWVSUDDNQO 16 1%675$)

8LWVSUDDN DUUHVWQXPPHU SDUNHWQXPPHU GDWXPXLWVSUDDNGHFHPEHUELMYHUYURHJLQJ

7(*(1635$$.

KWWSXLWVSUDNHQUHFKWVSUDDNQOLQ]LHQGRFXPHQW"LG (&/,1/*+$06%.


$55(679$1+(7*(5(&+76+2)7($067(5'$0

JHZH]HQRSKHWKRJHUEHURHSLQJHVWHOGWHJHQKHWYRQQLVYDQGHUHFKWEDQN$PVWHUGDPYDQ DXJXVWXVLQGHVWUDI]DDNRQGHUSDUNHWQXPPHUYDQKHWRSHQEDDUPLQLVWHULH WHJHQ

>9HUGDFKWH@ JHERUHQWH>JHERRUWHSODDWV@RS>GDWXP@ DGUHV>DGUHV@ WKDQVYHUEOLMYHQGHLQ3,0LGGHQ+ROODQG+Y%'H*HQLHSRRUWWH$OSKHQDDQGHQ5LMQ

2QGHU]RHNYDQGH]DDN 'LWDUUHVWLVJHZH]HQQDDUDDQOHLGLQJYDQKHWRQGHU]RHNRSGHWHUHFKW]LWWLQJHQLQHHUVWHDDQOHJYDQ PHLPHLPHLHQDXJXVWXVHQRSGHWHUHFKW]LWWLQJHQLQKRJHU EHURHSYDQMDQXDULHQGHFHPEHU +HWKRIKHHIWNHQQLVJHQRPHQYDQGHYRUGHULQJYDQGHDGYRFDDWJHQHUDDOHQYDQKHWJHHQGRRUGH YHUGDFKWHHQGHUDDGVOLHGHQQDDUYRUHQLVJHEUDFKW

7HQODVWHOHJJLQJ

$DQGHYHUGDFKWHLVWHQODVWHJHOHJGKHWJHHQYHUPHOGVWDDWLQGHLQOHLGHQGHGDJYDDUGLQJ RYHUHHQNRPVWLJGHRSGHWHUHFKW]LWWLQJLQHHUVWHDDQOHJYDQDXJXVWXVRSYRUGHULQJYDQGH RIILFLHUYDQMXVWLWLHWRHJHVWDQHZLM]LJLQJWHQODVWHOHJJLQJ 9DQGLHGDJYDDUGLQJHQYRUGHULQJZLM]LJLQJWHQODVWHOHJJLQJ]LMQNRSLHsQLQGLWDUUHVWJHYRHJG'H GDDULQYHUPHOGHWHQODVWHOHJJLQJZRUGWKLHURYHUJHQRPHQ

9RRU]RYHULQGHWHQODVWHOHJJLQJWDDOHQRIVFKULMIIRXWHQYRRUNRPHQOHHVWKHWKRIGH]HYHUEHWHUG'H YHUGDFKWHZRUGWGDDUGRRUQLHWLQGHYHUGHGLJLQJJHVFKDDG 9RQQLVZDDUYDQEHURHS +HWYRQQLVZDDUYDQEHURHSNDQQLHWLQVWDQGEOLMYHQRPGDWKHWKRI]LFKGDDUPHHQLHWYHUHQLJW

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

'HEHZLMVPLGGHOHQWHQDDQ]LHQYDQGHIHLWHQHQ

7HQDDQ]LHQYDQIHLW 9HUGDFKWHKHHIWWHUWHUHFKW]LWWLQJLQKRJHUEHURHSYDQGHFHPEHUYHUNODDUGGDWKLMRS MDQXDULLQFDIp)DPLOLDURQGXXULQGHRFKWHQGPHWHHQVHPLDXWRPDWLVFKSLVWRROYDQQDELM



PHHUGHUHNRJHOVKHHIWDIJHYXXUGRSKHWOLFKDDPYDQ>VODFKWRIIHU@'HNRUWQDGLWWLMGVWLSLQKHW FDIp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³(UZDUHQELMVHFWLHEORHGULMNHORQJHQPHWGXLGHOLMNHNQHX]LQJ'HUJHOLMNOHWVHOLVQLHW RQJHZRRQELMGRRUVFKRWHQGRRUGHERUVW]RDOVELMVFKRWOHWVHOLQFRPELQDWLHPHWELMYRRUEHHOG UHDQLPDWLH]RXNXQQHQRSWUHGHQHFKWHUPHGHJH]LHQGHGRRUGHYHUEDOLVDQWJHPHOGHH[SORVLH]RX GLWRRNGRRUELMYRRUEHHOGH[SDQGHUHQGJHZHOGNXQQHQRSWUHGHQ$DQKHWOLFKDDPZDUHQ PDFURVFRSLVFKYHUGHUYULMZHOJHHQWHNHQHQGLHRSHHQH[SORVLHZLM]HQRIRSRUJDDQVFKDGH]RDOV YHUZDFKWNDQZRUGHQELMHHQH[SORVLH(HQH[SORVLHEHKRHIWDOVGHGUXNJROIYROGRHQGHXLWZHJ ZRUGWJHERGHQHQVODFKWRIIHUVQLHWGRRUYOLHJHQGHYRRUZHUSHQZRUGHQJHUDDNWJHHQRIYULMZHO JHHQVSRUHQDDQKHWOLFKDDPQDWHODWHQ´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

7HQDDQ]LHQYDQIHLW 7HUWHUHFKW]LWWLQJLQKRJHUEHURHSGGGHFHPEHUKHHIWYHUGDFKWHYHUNODDUGQDHHQUX]LHGLH HHUGHURSGHDYRQGLQFDIp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

&DIp³)DPLOLD´LVJHYHVWLJGDDQ>DGUHV@WH$PVWHUGDP1RRUG,QGHQDFKWYDQ]DWHUGDJMDQXDUL LVHULQKHWFDIp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



KHWFDIpJHUHQGWH]LMQGHGHXUJHRSHQGWHKHEEHQHQQDDUEXLWHQWH]LMQJHUHQG2SGDWPRPHQW]LMQ RQJHYHHUSHUVRQHQLQFDIp)DPLOLDDDQZH]LJ 2PXXUNUHHJGHSROLWLHGHPHOGLQJGDWHUHHQH[SORVLHILQFDIp)DPLOLD]RX]LMQ DIJHJDDQ,QKHWFDIpZRUGW>VODFKWRIIHU@DDQJHWURIIHQ'HPDQZDV]ZDDUJHZRQGPDDUDGHPGHQRJ +LMUHDJHHUGHQLHWPHHURSDDQVSUHNHQ'HLQPLGGHOVWHUSODDWVHJHNRPHQ** *'KHHIWGHPDQ RQWNOHHGHQJHSUREHHUGWHUHDQLPHUHQ(YHQODWHULVGRRUSHUVRQHHOYDQGH** *'YHUNODDUGGDW >VODFKWRIIHU@ZDVRYHUOHGHQ 2SJURQGYDQKHWYRUHQVWDDQGHNDQDDQJHQRPHQZRUGHQGDWHURPVWUHHNVXXUHHQJUDQDDWLV DIJHJDDQLQFDIp)DPLOLD>*HWXLJH@KHHIWYHUNODDUGGDW>VODFKWRIIHU@LQKHWFDIpQDDUKHPLV WRHJHNRPHQHQJH]HJGKHHIWGDWKLMGHSLQQLHWPHHULQGHJUDQDDWNUHHJ+LM]LHWKHPYDQDIGHNDQW YDQKHWWRLOHWRSKHPDIORSHQHQ³GDWGLQJRYHU]LMQVFKRXGHUZHUSHQ´>*HWXLJH@KHHIWYHUNODDUG GDW>VODFKWRIIHU@DFKWHUKDDUVWRQGPHW]LMQKDQGHQERYHQ]LMQVFKRXGHUVHQGDWQDGDWKLMZDWOLHW YDOOHQGHH[SORVLHNZDP>*HWXLJH@KHHIWWLMGHQVGHUHFRQVWUXFWLHYHUNODDUGGDW>VODFKWRIIHU@KHP HHQJUDQDDWOLHW]LHQ'HSLQYDQGHKDQGJUDDWLVLQGHOLQNHUMDV]DNYDQ>VODFKWRIIHU@DDQJHWURIIHQ1D GHH[SORVLH]LMQKHWOLFKWHQGHPX]LHNHYHQXLWJHYDOOHQLVHUURRNOLJJHQHUJHZRQGHQRSGHJURQGHQ HUYOXFKWHQPHQVHQKHWFDIpXLW>*HWXLJH@KHHIWYHUNODDUGGDWKLMHHQKHHOKDUGHNQDOKRRUGHHHQ OLFKWIOLWV]DJGDWKLMHHQVXLVLQ]LMQRUHQKDGHQKLM]DJDOOHPHQVHQLQKHWFDIp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

9HUGDFKWHLVWHUWHUHFKW]LWWLQJLQKRJHUEHURHSELM]LMQHHUGHUDIJHOHJGHYHUNODULQJHQPHWEHWUHNNLQJ WRWKHWFRQIOLFWPHW>VODFKWRIIHU@JHEOHYHQ9HUGDFKWHKHHIWYHUNODDUGGDWKLMQDGHH[SORVLHLQKHW FDIp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

>*HWXLJH@KHHIWELMGHSROLWLHYHUNODDUGGDW]LMQDDUKHWKRIEHJULMSW >VODFKWRIIHU@]DJLQVODDQRSHHQ 0DURNNDDQGDWYHUGDFKWHULHS³1LHWGRHQQLHWGRHQ´GDW>VODFKWRIIHU@]LFKRPGUDDLGHHQULHS³,N PDDNMRXRRNDI´HQGDW>VODFKWRIIHU@WRHQRSYHUGDFKWHEHJRQLQWHVODDQ+LHUQDKRRUGH]LMVFKRWHQ >*HWXLJH@KHHIWELMGHSROLWLHYHUNODDUG³,N]DJYHUGDFKWHDDQNRPHQORSHQRS>VODFKWRIIHU@DIHQKLM ]HLLHWVDOVJHQRHJ]R>6ODFKWRIIHU@JDIKHPPHWHHQHHQNODSLQ]LMQJH]LFKW«7RHQSDNWH VODFKWRIIHU YHUGDFKWHELM]LMQNHHORIGDDUHUJHQV´7RHQSDNWHYHUGDFKWHGDWGLQJHQVFKRRWRS >VODFKWRIIHU@KHWKRIEHJULMSW>VODFKWRIIHU@ >*HWXLJH@KHHIWELMGHSROLWLHYHUNODDUGGDW>VODFKWRIIHU@QDGHH[SORVLHKHOHPDDOXLW]LMQGDNJLQJ +LMSDNWHHHQNUXNHQURVWHHHQ0DURNNDDQVHPDQLQHONDDU9HUGDFKWHNZDPHUWXVVHQHQ]HL³1LHW GRHQQLHWGRHQ´9HUGDFKWHZHUGGRRU>VODFKWRIIHU@YDVWJHSDNWHQ>VODFKWRIIHU@EHJRQYHUGDFKWHWH ³URVVHQ´HQULHS³,NPDDNMHDI,NPDDNMHDI´'DDUQDKRRUGH]LMNQDOOHQ

'HJHWXLJH>JHWXLJH@KHHIWWHUWHUHFKW]LWWLQJLQKRJHUEHURHSYDQGHFHPEHUYHUNODDUGGDW KLMJH]LHQKHHIWGDW>VODFKWRIIHU@QDGHH[SORVLHPHWHHQEDUNUXNHHQJHZRQGH0DURNNDDQVHPDQDDQ KHWVODDQZDV=HOIZDVKLMRRNJHZRQGNURRSQDDUEXLWHQHQKRRUGHRSGDWPRPHQWGHYHUGDFKWH VFKUHHXZHQ³QLHWGRHQQLHWGRHQ´9RRUWVKHEEHQGHJHWXLJHQ>JHWXLJH@EODG]LMGH%WP HQ>JHWXLJH@%WP RSIHEUXDULLHGHUYRRU]LFKELMGHSROLWLHYHUNODDUGGDW]LM YHUGDFKWHKHEEHQKRUHQVFKUHHXZHQ³ODDWPHORV´HQGDW]LMGDDUQDNQDOOHQKHEEHQJHKRRUG 7LMGHQVGHUHFRQVWUXFWLHKHHIW>JHWXLJH@YHUNODDUGGDW>VODFKWRIIHU@QDGHH[SORVLH]yERRVZDV³$OV >VODFKWRIIHU@ERRVZRUGW>VODFKWRIIHU@LV]RJURRW'XVLNURHSKHP,NURHSKHP0DDUKLMUHDJHHUWQLHW RSPLM+LMOLHSQDDUGHEDUHQSDNWHHHQNUXN(UODJLHPDQGGDDUHQGLHZLOGHKLMVODDQ´



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³,NJDQLHWPHW>JHWXLJH@RP :LMJDDQSULYpQLHWPHWHONDDURP´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

'HYHUNODULQJYDQYHUGDFKWHGDWKLMKHHQHQZHHUJHVOLQJHUGZHUGGRRU>VODFKWRIIHU@HQLQGLH VLWXDWLHJHVFKRWHQKHHIWLVPLQVWJHQRPHQQLHWLQVWULMGPHWKHW1),UDSSRUWµ3DWKRORJLHRQGHU]RHN QDDUDDQOHLGLQJYDQHHQPRJHOLMNQLHWQDWXXUOLMNHGRRG¶EODG]LMGH% ZDDULQRQGHUPHHUVWDDW YHUPHOG³$DQJDDQGHGHYUDDJKRHKHWVODFKWRIIHUWHQWLMGHYDQEHVFKLHWHQJHSRVLWLRQHHUG]RX NXQQHQ]LMQLVRSJURQGYDQGHVHFWLHEHYLQGLQJHQJHHQXLWVSUDDNPRJHOLMNDQGHUVGDQGDWYRRUDOVQRJ GHVFKRWEDQHQYDQOLQNVQDDUUHFKWVHQRQGHUYHUVFKLOOHQGHKRHNHQYHUORSHQKHWJHHQRQJHZRRQLV YRRUHHQVODFKWRIIHUGDWELMYRRUEHHOGVWLORSGHJURQGOLJWEHNHNHQYDQXLWKHWSHUVSHFWLHIYDQppQ VWLOVWDDQGHVFKXWWHU$QGHUV]RXKHWZRUGHQELMHHQRIPHHUGHUHEHZHJHQGHVFKXWWHUVRIHHQ EHZHJHQGVODFKWRIIHU´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

KDQGHOHQLQVWULMGPHWDUWLNHOHHUVWHOLGYDQGH:HWZDSHQVHQPXQLWLHHQKHWIHLWEHJDDQPHW EHWUHNNLQJWRWHHQYXXUZDSHQYDQFDWHJRULH,,, HQKDQGHOHQLQVWULMGPHWDUWLNHOHHUVWHOLGYDQGH:HWZDSHQVHQPXQLWLH

6WUDIEDDUKHLGYDQGHYHUGDFKWH 2PWUHQWGHVWUDIEDDUKHLGYDQYHUGDFKWHRYHUZHHJWKHWKRIPHGHLQKHWOLFKWYDQKHWWHU]DNH JHYRHUGHYHUZHHUKRRIGVWXNYDQGHSOHLWQRWDEODG]LMGHVWRWHQPHW DOVYROJW

=RDOVDOYDVWJHVWHOGRQGHU³6WUDIEDDUKHLGYDQKHWEHZH]HQYHUNODDUGH´LVYHUGDFKWHJHFRQIURQWHHUG PHWHHQRQWSORIILQJLQHHQFDIp1DGHH[SORVLH]LMQKHWOLFKWHQGHPX]LHNHYHQXLWJHYDOOHQZDVHU URRNODJHQHUJHZRQGHQRSGHJURQGHQYOXFKWWHQPHQVHQKHWFDIp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



YHUGDFKWHYHUNODDUW³ORVWHNRPHQ´ +HWKRIFRQFOXGHHUWGDWGHWHUWHUHFKW]LWWLQJYDQKHWKRIELMGHUHFKWEDQNELMGHUHFRQVWUXFWLHHQELM GHSROLWLHDIJHOHJGHYHUNODULQJHQYDQGHYHUGDFKWHQLHWZRUGHQZHHUVSURNHQGRRUKHWJHHQGRRUGH SROLWLHLVEHYRQGHQHQLQKHWGRVVLHULVQHHUJHOHJG

+HWKRIDFKWDDQQHPHOLMNJHZRUGHQGDWKHWVFKLHWHQPHWKHWSLVWRRORSKHWOLFKDDPYDQ>VODFKWRIIHU@ NHQQHOLMNKHWRQPLGGHOOLMNHJHYROJLVJHZHHVWYDQHHQKHYLJHJHPRHGVEHZHJLQJGLHGRRUKHWRSKHP WRHJHSDVWHJHZHOG±WHJHQGHDFKWHUJURQGYDQGHRQWSORIWHJUDQDDWGHFKDRVLQKHWFDIpKHWGRRU >VODFKWRIIHU@VODDQYDQ>JHWXLJH@GLHRSGHJURQGODJPHWHHQEDUNUXN±YDQHHQYHUPRHGHOLMN ZRHGHQGH>VODFKWRIIHU@ELMGHYHUGDFKWHLVRQWVWDDQ $DQQHPHOLMNLVJHZRUGHQGDWGHYHUGDFKWHGLHLQI\VLHNRS]LFKWGXLGHOLMNGHPLQGHUHYDQ>VODFKWRIIHU@ PRHWZRUGHQJHDFKWKHHIWJHKDQGHOGXLWGRRGVDQJVWGDWKHWUHHGVWHJHQKHPJHSOHHJGHJHZHOG]RX YRRUWGXUHQGDWKLMHUQLHWWHJHQRSJHZDVVHQZDVHQGDWKLMHU]LFKQLHWDDQNRQRQWWUHNNHQ %LMGH]HVWDQGYDQ]DNHQLVKHWKRIYDQRRUGHHOGDWYHUGDFKWHHHQEHURHSWRHNRPWRSQRRGZHHUH[FHV ]RGDWKLMGLHQWWHZRUGHQRQWVODJHQYDQDOOHUHFKWVYHUYROJLQJWHU]DNHYDQKHWRQGHU EHZH]HQYHUNODDUGHIHLW

,QKHWOLFKWYDQKHWYRUHQVWDDQGHEHKRHYHQGHRYHULJHGRRUGHUDDGVOLHGHQJHYRHUGHYHUZHUHQJHHQ EHVSUHNLQJ

7HQDDQ]LHQYDQIHLW (ULVJHHQRPVWDQGLJKHLGDDQQHPHOLMNJHZRUGHQGLHGHVWUDIEDDUKHLGYDQGHYHUGDFKWHXLWVOXLW]RGDW GHYHUGDFKWHVWUDIEDDULV 2SOHJJLQJYDQVWUDI 'HUHFKWEDQN$PVWHUGDPKHHIWGHYHUGDFKWHYRRUKHWRQGHUHQWHQODVWHJHOHJGHYHURRUGHHOGWRW MDDUJHYDQJHQLVVWUDIPHWDIWUHNYDQYRRUDUUHVWFRQIRUPDUWLNHO:HWERHNYDQVWUDIUHFKWHQGH YRUGHULQJYDQGHEHQDGHHOGHSDUWLMWRHJHZH]HQWRWHHQEHGUDJYDQ¼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sOH'RFXPHQWDWLHYDQQRYHPEHULV YHUGDFKWHHHUGHUWHU]DNHYDQYHUPRJHQVHQJHZHOGVGHOLFWHQYHURRUGHHOG +HWKRIKHHIWNHQQLVJHQRPHQYDQGHRPWUHQWYHUGDFKWHXLWJHEUDFKWH3V\FKLDWULVFKH5DSSRUWDJH3UR -XVWLWLDEHWUHIIHQGHYHUGDFKWHYDQQRYHPEHUGRRUUDSSRUWHXU>UDSSRUWHXU@SV\FKLDWHU

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

7RHSDVVHOLMNHZHWWHOLMNHYRRUVFKULIWHQ



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yyUGHWHQXLWYRHUOHJJLQJYDQGH]HXLWVSUDDNLQGH]H]DDN LQYHU]HNHULQJHQYRRUORSLJHKHFKWHQLVLVGRRUJHEUDFKWELMGHXLWYRHULQJYDQGHRSJHOHJGH JHYDQJHQLVVWUDILQPLQGHULQJZRUGWJHEUDFKW

7HQDDQ]LHQYDQGHEHQDGHHOGHSDUWLM>EHQDGHHOGHSDUWLM@ :LMVWDIGHYRUGHULQJYDQGHEHQDGHHOGHSDUWLM

+HIWRSKHWEHYHOWRWYRRUORSLJHKHFKWHQLVYDQGHYHUGDFKWH

'LWDUUHVWLVJHZH]HQGRRUGH]HVGHPHHUYRXGLJHVWUDINDPHUYDQKHWJHUHFKWVKRIWH$PVWHUGDP ZDDULQ]LWWLQJKDGGHQPU1$6FKLPPHOPU-)1LMERHUHQPU+:-GH*URRWLQ WHJHQZRRUGLJKHLGYDQPU2%RHNUDDGJULIILHUHQLVXLWJHVSURNHQRSGHRSHQEDUHWHUHFKW]LWWLQJYDQ GLWJHUHFKWVKRIYDQGHFHPEHU


No title

Recommend Documents