Segmentation, Targeting and Positioning
Lili Adi Wibowo
[email protected]
Oce Ridwanudin
[email protected]
MARKETING STRATEGY
Marketing Strategy = • (S) Segmentation • (T) Targeting • (P) Positioning • (MM) Marketing Mix
Steps in Segmenting, Targeting, Positioning 6. Develop Marketing Mix for Each Target Segment
5. Develop Positioning for Each Target Segment 4. Select Target Segment(s) 3. Develop Measures of Segment Attractiveness
Market Positioning
Market Targeting
2. Develop Profiles of Resulting Segments
1. Identify Bases for Segmenting the Market
Market Segmentation
Step 1: Market Segmentation Levels of Segmentation Mass Marketing Same product to all consumers (no segmentation) Segment Marketing Different products to one or more segments (some segmentation) Niche Marketing Different products to subgroups within segments ( more segmentation) Micro-marketing Products to suit the tastes of individuals or locations (complete segmentation)
Boswie Education
Four levels of Micromarketing Segments
Niches
Local areas
Individuals
Boswie Education CHP: 8&10-6
Mass Marketing Mass Marketing, di mana penjual menjual produksi masal, distribusi massal dan promosi massal atas produk tertentu bagi semua pembeli Boswie Education
Contoh: HenryFord menerapkan strategi massal untuk Mobil Ford Model- T dengan warna apa pun, asalkan warna tersebut hitam Coca cola mempraktikan pemasaran massal selama bertahun-tahun ketika ia menjual hanya satu jenis Coke dalam botol 6,5 oncea
Ford’s Model T Followed a Mass Market Approach
Boswie Education CHP: 8&10-8
Mass Marketing Argumen bagi pemasaran massal adalah ia menciptakan potensi pasar yang besar, yang akan menghasilkan biaya yang lebih mudah dan pada akhirnya akan dapat menghasilkan harga lebih rendah atau marjin lebih tinggi
Boswie Education
Namun, banyak kritik yang menunjukkan pada kenyataan bahwa pasar itu sebenarnya terpecah-pecah, sehingga pemasaran massal lebih sulit dilaksankan
Segmentasi Konsep segmentasi diperkenalkan oleh Wendell R Smith Tahun 1956 dalam artikel yang terkenalnya berjudul “ Product Differentation and Market Segmentation as Alternative Marketing Strategies” • Menurutnya, konsumen itu bersifat unik dan berbedabeda. Konsekuensinya, mereka membutuhkan program pemasaran yang berbeda pula. Dalam artikelnya Smith menawarkan diferensiasi produk untuk melayani segmen yang berbeda sebagai alternatif strategi pemasaran.
Segment Marketing
Targeting a group of customers who share a similar set of needs and wants.
Boswie Education CHP: 8&10-11
Segmentasi Proses mengelompokkan pasar keseluruhan yang heterogen menjadi kelompok-kelompok atau segmen-segmen yang memiliki kesamaan dalam hal kebutuhan, keinginan, perilaku dan/atau respons terhadap program pemasaran spesifik.’ Segmentasi pasar merupakan konsep pokok yang mendasari strategi pemasaran perusahaan dan pengalokasian sumber daya yang harus dilakukan dalam rangka mengimplementasikan program pemasaran
Segmentasi Membagi bagian yang lebih besar dan lebih heterogen menjadi bagian yang lebih kecil dan lebih homogen. • More segmentation = improved marketing mix and increased cost. Teknologi dapat membantu segmentasi lebih akurat • If you are “out segmented” you may be “out of the market!” • You segment so that you can position! • •
Pemasar tidak menciptakan segmen. Tugas pemasaran adalah mengidentifikasi segmen dan memutuskan mana yang akan di bidik
Basic Market Preference Patterns
CHP: 8&10-14
Niche Marketing
Kelompok pelanggan yang Mencari bauran manfaat yang Terbedakan (distinctive)
Boswie Education CHP: 8&10-15
Ciri-ciri Pelanggan Niche Marketing Memiliki kumpulan pelanggan dengan kebutuhan yang benar-benar berbeda Bersedia membayar harga lebih tinggi kepada perusahaan demi memuaskan kebutuhan mereka Bagi perusahaan, produk dan jasa yang dihasilkan pada Niche Marketing sangat spesialisasi dan memiliki ukuran, laba serta potensi pertumbuhan yang memadai Memiliki sedikit pesaing Contoh : Hallmark memperkenalkan lini yang membidik segmen pasar spesifik. Yaitu Hallmark En Espanol (pengirim kartu dari keturunan Spanyol)
Ciri-ciri Pelanggan Niche Marketing Memiliki kumpulan pelanggan dengan kebutuhan yang benar-benar berbeda Bersedia membayar harga lebih tinggi kepada perusahaan demi memuaskan kebutuhan mereka Bagi perusahaan, produk dan jasa yang dihasilkan pada Niche Marketing sangat spesialisasi dan memiliki ukuran, laba serta potensi pertumbuhan yang memadai Memiliki sedikit pesaing Contoh : Hallmark memperkenalkan lini yang membidik segmen pasar spesifik. Yaitu Hallmark En Espanol (pengirim kartu dari keturunan Spanyol)
Micro-Marketing atau Local areas
Customerization
Combines operationally driven mass customization with customized marketing in a way that empowers consumers to design the product and service offering of their choice.
Boswie Education CHP: 8&10-19
Examples of Market Customization
CHP: 8&10-20
Step 1: Market Segmentation Bases for Segmenting Consumer Markets Geographic Nations, states, regions or cities
Demographic Age, gender, family size and life cycle, or income
Psychographic Social class, lifestyle, or personality
Behavioral Boswie Education
Occasions, BENEFITS, uses, or responses
Bases for Segmenting Consumer Markets Geography
Demographics
Characteristics Used to Segment Markets
Psychographics
Benefits Sought
Usage Rate Boswie Education
22
Bases for Segmenting Consumer Markets Geographic Segmentation
Region of the country or world Market size
Market density Climate Boswie Education
23
Family Life Cycle
Age
Marital Status
Boswie Education
Children
24
Bases for Segmenting Consumer Markets Psychographics
Personality Motives Lifestyles Psychographic Segmentation Boswie Education
Geodemographics 25
SRI Consulting: Values & Lifestyles
Boswie Education
Self-Orientation Motivation to pursue products, services, & experiences •Principle-oriented: abstract, idealized criteria •Status-oriented: demonstrations of success to peers •Action-oriented: social or physical activity, variety, & risk taking
Resources Psychological, physical, demographic, & material means •Education •Income •Self-confidence •Health •Eagerness to buy things •Intelligence •Energy level Boswie Education
VALS Types: Resource Levels & Orientation
Resources
Orientation
Actualizers
highest
growth & expression
Fulfilleds Achievers Experiencers Believers Strivers Makers Strugglers
higher higher higher lower lower lower lowest
principle status action principle status action security & safety
Boswie Education
VALS Types Actualizers (H) Successful, sophisticated, active, “take-charge” High self-esteem, open to change Interested in growth & selfexpression Wide range of interests Cultivated tastes Boswie Education
Strugglers (L) Constricted lives Poor, ill-educated, lowskilled, weak social bonds Elderly, concerned about health Resigned & passive Cautious & loyal consumers
VALS Types Fulfilleds (H, principle) Mature, satisfied, comfortable, reflective Value order, knowledge & responsibility Activities center around home Look for durability, functionality & value Boswie Education
Believers (L, principle) Conservative, conventional Concrete beliefs based on family, church, community, & nation Deep, literal moral codes Established routines Favor American products & established brands
VALS Types Experiencers (H, action) Young, vital, enthusiastic, impulsive & rebellious Seek variety & excitement Formulating life values & behavior patterns Disdain conformity Avid consumers who spend heavily on clothing fast food, music, movies, etc. Boswie Education
Makers (L, action) Practical, traditional, constructive Value self-sufficiency Experience the world by working in it Suspicious of new ideas Unimpressed by possessions without practical function
VALS Types Achievers (H, status) Successful, careeroriented Value consensus, predictability & stability Committed to work & family Conventional, conservative Prefer established, prestige products Boswie Education
Strivers (L, status) Seek motivation & approval Striving for secure place in life Insecure, low resources, impulsive & easily bored Money defines success & life gave them raw deal Seek to be stylish
Segmenting by Age and Psychographics: 4 Types of Generation Xers Cynical Disdainers
pessimistic and skeptical about their prospects
Traditional Materialists
optimistic; feel motivated to achieve symbols of the American dream like career, homes and families
Hippies Revisited
attracted to 60s lifestyle, express themselves through music, fashion, spirituality
Fifties Macho
conservative, resist accepting equal gender roles, multiculturalism
Value of Benefit Segmentation Define targets based on what they want from the product
In a multi-attribute attitude model, customers in the same benefit segment would share similar importance weights on attributes
Benefit segments are very actionable! BUT, benefit segments are hard to identify
And, potentially harder to reach
Media are usually described in terms of demographics
Market Segmentation Requirements for Effective Segmentation Measurable
• Size, purchasing power, profiles of segments can be measured.
Accessible
• Segments must be effectively reached and served.
Substantial
• Segments must be large or profitable enough to serve.
Differentiable Actionable Boswie Education
• Segments must respond differently to different marketing mix elements & actions. • Must be able to attract and serve the segments.
Step 2. Market Targeting Evaluating Market Segments Segment Size and Growth
Analyze sales, growth rates and expected profitability.
Segment Structural Attractiveness
Consider effects of: Competitors, Availability of Substitute Products and, the Power of Buyers & Suppliers.
Company Objectives and Resources
Company skills & resources relative to the segment(s). Look for Competitive Advantages.
Targeting
TARGETING STRATEGIES 1. 2. 3.
Mengidentifikasi dan menganalisis segmen dalam pasar produk. Menentukan segmen yang akan menjadi target. Merancang dan melaksanakan strategi posisioning dalam setiap target.
Lima Pola Pemilihan Pasar Sasaran Konsentrasi Segmen tunggal
Spesialisasi produk
Selektif spesialisasi
M1 M2 M3
M1 M2 M3
M1 M2 M3
P1
P1
P1
P2
P2
P2
P3
P3
P3 spesialisasi pasar
Cakupan Seluruh pasar
M1 M2 M3
P = Produk M = Pasar
M1 M2 M3
P1
P1
P2
P2
P3
P3
Step 2. Market Targeting: Market Coverage Strategies Company Marketing Mix
Market
A. Undifferentiated Marketing
Company Marketing Mix 1 Company Marketing Mix 2 Company Marketing Mix 3
Segment 1 Segment 2 Segment 3
B. Differentiated Marketing
Segment 1
Company Marketing Mix
Segment 2 Segment 3
Boswie Education
C. Concentrated Marketing
Undifferentiated Strategy Advantages: Potential savings on production and marketing costs
Disadvantages: Unimaginative product offerings Company more susceptible to competition
Boswie Chapter 6 Education Ver 2e
©2000 South-Western College Publishing
42
Concentrated Strategy Advantages: Concentration of resources Meet needs of narrowly defined segment Small firms can compete Strong positioning
Disadvantages: Segments too small, or changing Large competitors may effectively market to niche segment Boswie Chapter 6 Education Ver 2e
©2000 South-Western College Publishing
43
Multisegment Strategy Advantages: Greater financial success Economies of scale
Disadvantages: High costs Cannibalization
Boswie Chapter 6 Education Ver 2e
©2000 South-Western College Publishing
44
Costs of Multisegment Targeting
$
Product design costs
$
Production costs
$
Promotion costs
$
Inventory costs
$
Marketing research costs
$
Management costs
$
Cannibalization
Boswie Education
45
Step 2: Market Targeting Choosing a Market Coverage Strategy Company Resources Product Variability
Product’s Stage in the Product Life Cycle Market Variability
Boswie Education
Competitors’ Marketing Strategies
POSITIONING Differentiation vs Positioning Posisi adalah tempat di benak konsumen dibandingkan dengan pesaing. • Diferensiasi adalah suatu strategi dlm membangun posisi yang unik dan diinginkan. • You will never beat the leader by being just like them! • You must understand your, and your competitors position Boswie Education
Diferensiasi Produk
Bentuk
Fitur
Daya tahan
Kean dalan
Boswie Education
Kinerja
Mudah Diper baiki
Kualitas
Gaya
Kese suaian
Desain
Diferensiasi Pelayanan
Pengiriman
Boswie Education
Pemasa ngan
Konsultasi pelanggan
Pelatihan Pemeliharaan & perbaikan pelanggan
Pelayanan Lain-lain
Kemudahan pemesanan
Diferensiasi Personel Kompetensi Keramahan
Keandalan
Boswie Education
Tanggung jawab
Kredibel
Komunikasi
Diferensiasi Citra Media
Suasana
Lambang
Peristiwa
Boswie Education
POSITIONING Single-benefit positioning is usually best best quality lowest price best value most reliable
Boswie Education
POSITIONING People tend to remember # 1. But, what if you are # 2 or # 3? If you are not # 1 Perkuat posisi saat ini Ambil posisi yagn belum terambil Deposisi atau reposisi pesaing Raih jumlah terbesar dalam segmen tertentu Boswie Education Strategi ekslusif
POSITIONING
Positioning Concept Posisioning yagn diharapkan dari suatu produk di mata dan benak target pembeli (functional, symbolic, experiential) Positioning Strategy Kombinasi dari strategi program pemasaran yang digunakan dalam memotret konsep posisioning. Positioning Effectiveness Sejauhmana tujuan posisioning manajemen Boswiedapat Education diraih dalam target pasar.
Strategic Positioning Positioning Concept
Positioning Effectiveness
Boswie Education
MARKET TARGET
Positioning Strategy
Positioning of Different Bar Soaps High moisturizing • Tone
• Zest
7
4
• Lever 2000
• Dove 2 5
• Safeguard • Lux
Nondeodorant
8
Deodorant
3
1
“Product Space”
• Lava
Representing Consumers’ Perception for 6 Different Brands of Bar Soap Low Boswie Education moisturizing
• Dial • Lifebuoy
Positioning Errors Underpositioning Pemahaman yang kabur atau kurang jelas dari suatu produk Overpositioning Terbatasnya pemahaman tentang produk perusahaan (Mont Blanc) Confused Positioning Pesan yagn sering berubah dan kontradiksi Doubtful Positioning BuktiEducation tidak sesuai dengan janji Boswie
Positioning High Price
Buick
Expressive
Conservative
Cadillac Oldsmobile
Chevrolet
Pontiac
Perceptual Mapping (General Motors--1989) Low Price Boswie Chapter Education 6 Ver 2e
©2000 South-Western College Publishing
58
Positioning Bases Attribute Price and Quality Use or Application Product User
Positioning Bases
Product Class Competitor
Boswie Chapter 6 Education Ver 2e
©2000 South-Western College Publishing
59
Global Market Segmentation
Trends Global Market Standardization Micromarketing
Boswie Education
60
Step 3. Positioning for Competitive Advantage Product’s Position - the place the product occupies in consumers’ minds relative to competing products;
Complex set of perceptions, impressions and feelings consumers hold for the product
Marketers must:
Plan positions to give products the greatest advantage Develop marketing mixes to create planned positions
Procter & Gamble--11 Brands of Detergent Tide: all purpose family detergent, tough on stains, keeps clothing looking like new Cheer with Triple Color Guard: the color expert, guards against fading Bold: built in fabric softener Gain: gives you clean, fresh-smelling clothes Era: built in stain removers Dash: does it all for a low price Dreft: removes tough baby stains but gently Ariel: targeted to Hispanic market
Toothpaste Example Crest Close-Up Gleem Topol Colgate Jr.
Tooth Decay Sex Appeal Whiter Teeth Remove Stains Kids brand with fluoride
Using Perceptual Maps: Positioning Politicians Liberal
Warren Beatty Ideal point Traditional Democrats
Gore
Uncaring Ideal point Traditional Republicans
Buchanan Boswie Education
Conservative
Bradley
Clinton “Swing” Voters
Bush
Compassionate
Perceptual Map of Women’s Apparel Retailers Fashion Forward Bloomingdale’s
The Gap
TJ Maxx Marshall’s Limited Service
Sears “Softer Side” JC Penney
Wal-Mart Boswie Education
Sears (old)
Traditional
Nordstrom Extensive Service
Steps to Choosing and Implementing
a Positioning Strategy Step 1. Identifying a set of possible competitive advantages:
Competitive Differentiation.
Step 2. Selecting the right competitive advantage. Step 3. Effectively communicating and delivering the chosen position to the market. Step 4: Evaluate market response and reposition if necessary
What Kind of Advantages to Focus On? Product Class
Product/Service Attributes
Away from Competitors
Benefits Offered G H
Against a Competitor
C
A D E
Usage Occasions
B F
Personnel
Image Users
Boswie Education
Which Competitive Advantages? Important
Profitable
Affordable
Preemptive Boswie Education
Criteria for Determining Which Differences to Promote
Distinctive
Superior
Communicable
How Many Differences to Promote? Trend to broaden and position to more segments
Lever 2000 soap: cleanses, deodorizes, moisturizes Risks of disbelief and loss of clear position
Avoid
Under positioning Over positioning Confusion
Targeting and Positioning Product Strategy
Promotion Strategy
Positioning Strategy
Market Target
Price Strategy Boswie Education
Distribution Strategy